3 ms·
I don't feel like setting prices is the hallmark of independent contracting. Mechanical Turk, for example, the price is (rightfully) set by the problem setter.
by dnautics 11y ago
I don't feel like setting prices is the hallmark of independent contracting. Mechanical Turk, for example, the price is (rightfully) set by the problem setter. Perhaps amazon would find it necessary to comply with your judgment by obscuring the price as a 'bid' and effectively require the turker to guess how much the problem setter is willing to pay, creating market inefficiency,reducing transparency, and potentially being more exploitative (amazon pockets the difference if the turker lowballs it)
- tdaltonc 11y agoThe point about price setting isn't that it must be the driver/turk. It's just that it can't be uber/amazon.
- pyvpx 11y agoI have no idea how Mechanical Turk works, however the end result in this situation would be the same. The independent contractor is allowed to choose the price by accepting tasks priced acceptably. the IC still "sets" the price they are willing to work for by only entering into agreements for work where they agree on the price being offered.
- dnautics 11y agoThat's not a good analogy if you want to argue drivers are not ICs. The independent driver is allowed to quit driving if Uber sets the prices too low. The driver "sets" the price by only logging on when he agrees to the price that Uber has set.
- s73v3r 11y agoThe ability to quit doesn't mean a thing. Everyone, regardless of whether they're an IC or an employee, technically has the ability to quit.
- bsder 11y ago> The independent driver is allowed to quit driving if Uber sets the prices too low. But then the driver loses the ability to see when the price goes back up. If you are "ON" the Uber app, you are required to accept the Uber price, or you get penalized. At no point can you say, "I am willing to accept this price which is lower than Uber." nor can you say "I am not willing to accept a fare below this price for this distance."
- jacobr1 11y agoI don't the situation is analogous. Amazon would be similar to Uber if they set the price for hit tasks. But they don't the hit submitters can set their prices and there is a vibrant market driving to certain price levels. If Uber let drivers set their own prices in some manner, then Uber would be operating a market. Instead they don't operate a market, they operate a direct to consumer service. I'm not certain if their drivers should be considered contractors or employees, but neither situation would be exposed directly to the consumer unless they switched to a market model.
- jegutman 11y agoAmazon doesn't set the prices though, the problem setter does. I think that's a meaningful distinction as there is not one rate for everything.
- dnautics 11y agoSo is the Turk an employee of the problem setter?
- maxerickson 11y agoProbably not. As I said to you previously (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9592532 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9592532 ): What value do you expect to get out of demanding that people analyze these random situations? Ultimately, it's the government bureaucrats and legal system that make the decisions, so even if someone gives you some relatively definitive answer, it could still turn out to be wrong. The determination is made by applying a series of subjective standards, looking at situations that are somewhat comparable along one of those standards is not necessarily going to inform the outcome if the other standards are subjectively more important. There is room to articulate some frustration with the seeming arbitrariness of the law, but do that instead of asking argumentative questions that are only vaguely interesting to the topic.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]