3 ms·
What is the expected cost to Uber of this change?
by bhouston 11y ago
What is the expected cost to Uber of this change?
- revelation 11y agoBankruptcy.
- shivpat23 11y agoIf this sticks, Uber cannot absorb that cost and would have to shed many of the drivers - rendering Uber, as we know it now, defunct.
- yincrash 11y agoUber does exist in more than just California.
- ceejayoz 11y agoThe IRS exists in those other areas, though, and may take a similar look at their operations.
- gav 11y agoUberX is now defunct in Los Angeles at least, I assume they've shut it off for all of CA. No cars available this morning.
- tomasien 11y agoThey're appealing so we'll see.
- ceejayoz 11y agoMinimum wage (probably including time you're available but without a fare), overtime, payroll tax, workers comp... and back-pay for all that for the last few years? Enormous, I'd imagine.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThat's only California. If the IRS comes to the same conclusion, they'll owe all of that nationwide.
- VLM 11y agoIF they financially survive the back pay, etc, then numerous policy changes around pages 8 to 10 or so of my scanned copy of the judgement can be applied to mostly patch around the issues. The requirements that uber enforces on its (now) employees would pretty much have to be wiped to make it more of a contractor relationship than an employee relationship. No more banning 2-door cars or 11 year old cars, no more banning tips, no more auto-filtering out all less than perfect records, drivers would have to negotiate fares not uber, no more background checks. Basically uber does a traditional hiring process without actually hiring, whereas they'd have to move to a traditional contracting relationship. Uber forbids contracting relationships in their ToS, its specifically forbidden to hire a subcontractor. Clauses like that really set off labor boards and the IRS about "fake" contracting. Specifically, uber would have to let the end user decide not to accept a ride in my new 2-door Yaris or my wife's 2004 Prius rather than denying for me. Also if riders consistently give me 1 star because of my HN posting habits or whatever, they'd have to let the riders decide to not accept me rather than autofiltering out all sub 4.6 or whatever grade-inflated score they use. They couldn't run a background check on me to join the service, MAYBE they could get away with running it and putting the result semi-anonymously online for the rider to make a judgement. They would have to let me set the minimum fare I'd demand, which actually sounds pretty nice for drivers rather than existing "yes/no" take it or leave it, and tips would have to be permitted. Possibly they could spawn off a "union" or professional organization that only allows members to join that passed a background check and then only allow members to advertise themselves as part of the union. Like my roofing contractor or my unionized electrician. There's a widely held belief, that is completely wrong, that a contractor is just an employee who is treated like dirt in exchange for more money than an employee gets; essentially a gambling relationship. The actual legal position is considerably more complicated and is not concerned with popular beliefs.
- solutionyogi 11y agoWait a second. I understand that they will have to let drivers negotiate rate but as a contractor why can't they enforce that you must have certain type of car? E.g. I did contracting for financial firms in NYC and certain ones expected me to wear business formals (including a tie) whenever I worked in the office. Why can't Uber have similar requirement that you must have car with certain features?