3 ms·
> In the situation of the shirt a reasonable reaction [...] That's a fine claim to make, but I don't agree with your judgment of reasonable, and neither to a l
by wpietri 11y ago
> In the situation of the shirt a reasonable reaction [...]
That's a fine claim to make, but I don't agree with your judgment of reasonable, and neither to a lot of other people. Your theory that we can make major cultural changes through polite, meek requests is... unproven: https://thenib.com/great-moments-in-peaceful-protest-history-44bdadb44cf https://thenib.com/great-moments-in-peaceful-protest-history...
As Deborah Blum puts it, "I do have sympathy for anyone caught in the leading edge of a media storm. But if we are ever to effect change, sometimes we need the winds to howl, to blow us out of our comfort zones."
> the accusation was at best that this guy in his stupidity is responsible for the gender gap in science
I believe the actual accusation was that he was contributing to maintaining the gender gap, not that he was responsible for it.
> we don't talk about young black men having a 50% high school graduation rate while their female counterparts are doing significantly better
Actually, intersectional feminists talk about this quite a bit. They just don't think the solution is to stop fighting sexism.
> Instead we talk about the STEM gap and if we resist we get shamed into public apologies?
Yes, all this middle aged white dude resistance to a dollop of accountability for one's actions is really about helping black men. Now pull the other leg.
> I'm not sure if you realize how condescending it is to assume that you have nothing to learn from me but this is a great opportunity for me to learn from you.
I don't mind as being seen as condescending here, but that's not my point. My point is that I have limited time, and I don't think spending it rehashing stale arguments with dedicated antifeminists is a good way to work towards the goals I have. If somebody actually wants to learn something, I'm glad to help them out. And if I end up with questions, I'll surely ask them. But absent that, I have better things to do.
> I look at this and I see hegemony[0].
Yes. There was an entrenched pro-sexist cultural hegemony that has lasted thousands of years. It is finally dying. I want that replaced with an anti-sexist cultural hegemony, because that shifts us in the direction of a more even distribution of power. I personally hope that what comes after that is the dissolution of hegemonies, but primates being what we are, I suspect the best we'll be able to get is an anti-kyriarchic hegemony. My target for that is 2100, but I've always been an optimist.
> A social group with a significant amount of power over you has publicly shamed you [...]
This is an incorrect reading (and also false), but hey, don't let me get in the way of your fantasies.
> their worldview became your own
Also false. I'm not much of a fellow traveler in that I have a number of deep philosophical disagreements, but our goals are aligned for the next few decades or so.
- hoopd 11y ago> As Deborah Blum puts it, "I do have sympathy for anyone caught in the leading edge of a media storm. But if we are ever to effect change, sometimes we need the winds to howl, to blow us out of our comfort zones." She's implying social change only happens when forced by some group of activists and therefore activism isn't responsible for the collateral damage it causes. Many things cause social change so I think the role of "howling winds" may be overstated. In addition, one must make the argument that this particular form of activism is genuine and deserves solidarity. > I believe the actual accusation was that he was contributing to maintaining the gender gap, not that he was responsible for it. He may not have been blamed for it (the gender gap predates him by centuries) but the responsibility was placed on his shoulders. > Actually, intersectional feminists talk about this quite a bit. They try and I commend them for that. > I don't mind as being seen as condescending here, but that's not my point. My point is that I have limited time, and I don't think spending it rehashing stale arguments with dedicated antifeminists is a good way to work towards the goals I have. If somebody actually wants to learn something, I'm glad to help them out. And if I end up with questions, I'll surely ask them. But absent that, I have better things to do. I'm open to being persuaded and I don't think you can accuse me of deflecting or not taking what you say seriously. In fact I would love to be persuaded, the social punishments for disliking feminism are steep. > I want that replaced with an anti-sexist cultural hegemony, because that shifts us in the direction of a more even distribution of power. No it doesn't, that's only true if being male is a meaningful predictor of power, but it isn't. You can see this in poor white males: class outweighs sex and race combined. Feminism isn't interested in addressing or critiquing the real institutions of power, they want the power for themselves. It could even make the power distribution worse because those in power will have the outward appearance of equality. I'm not sure what your political background is but ideologically your anti-sexist cultural hegemony bears striking similarities to the dictatorship of the proletariat(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dictatorship_of_the_proletariat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dictatorship_of_the_proletaria...) which was rejected by the socialist libertarians of the time and would later become the platform of Lenin and Stalin. Anybody adopting this type of thinking should be aware of the horrors it has brought in the past. > Also false. I'm not much of a fellow traveler in that I have a number of deep philosophical disagreements, but our goals are aligned for the next few decades or so. The reason I say their worldview has become your own is because sometimes it seems like you're reading their script. I don't actually know you.