2 ms·
How can they tell it's from the beam and not from say, the Sun? Or other random galactic neutrinos?
by ars 11y ago
How can they tell it's from the beam and not from say, the Sun? Or other random galactic neutrinos?
- cperciva 11y agoI'm guessing the sun is easily ruled out based on the direction the neutrino was travelling (as measured by the momentum of the particle produced when the neutrino interacts with something). "Random galactic neutrinos" are probably a statistical exclusion: Although there could be a tau neutrino coming from the same direction as the experimental neutrino source, there aren't enough of them to create any significant chance of the observation being anything other than an experimental neutrino.
- cshimmin 11y agoThey do model backgrounds; the 5-sigma significance is a claim about the odds that background phenomena could have randomly caused this observation. However, their main backgrounds are not from the sources you mention. OPERA knows exactly what time the beam was on, and only considers data during that time <insert joke about that one time they thought neutrinos were traveling faster than light>. If galactic/solar tau neutrinos were present, they would see them all the time (not just when the beam was on), but they don't. That's not to say that they aren't there, but at the energies measured by the OPERA experiment, they would be exceedingly rare, especially compared to the high intensity of the neutrino beam they are receiving from CERN.