3 ms·
This issue is the most important health and safety issue in the country right now. Add up all of the deaths due to obesity-related diseases and it's an obvious
by moron4hire 11y ago
This issue is the most important health and safety issue in the country right now. Add up all of the deaths due to obesity-related diseases and it's an obvious low-hanging fruit for improvement. For all the yellow-jacket journalism surrounding cars or drugs or strangers or vaccines or guns, they are all drops in the bucket compared to heart disease.
But that said, I don't think the FDA or CDC are doing anything functionally significant towards improving the issue. There is a greater underlying question that still needs to be answered: why has the problem continued to get worse, despite ALL efforts otherwise?
There is a gun against the head of 2/3rds of Americans and nobody is asking how it got there and why it's still there. I'm afraid it's because we keep arguing about the shape and color of the bullets and how you should really be better at dodging bullets of you want to stay alive.
- hga 11y agoNot necessarily; another "unnatural" recommendation by our betters, to shift from fats and meats to carbohydrates, could easily be worse, and maybe synergistic. "Unnatural" in that we were advised to shift from natural saturated fats, and from something resembling the more balanced pre-agriculture diet. And I'm suspicious of mass quantities of unsaturated cis-fats, which I gather weren't quite so common prior to cultivation of oil seeds.
- moron4hire 11y agoHuh? You mustn't have read my post very closely.
- hga 11y agoAh, yes, I too narrowly focused on this particular issue of trans vs. cis and saturated fats and incorrectly inferred what you meant by the "this issue". Taking a step back, yep, the postulated (and being tested by Taubes and company) carbohydrate hypothesis is a part of what your comment is addressing.
- buckbova 11y agoI don't want to tell people how to eat. I'd prefer to let it shake out like smoking tobacco. Over a few generations many wised up and there will be many less smoking related deaths in the future. But everyone dies of something and who am I to tell you how to live while you're still here?
- moron4hire 11y agoNo, I'm not saying I support legislation for this stuff. The problem is that, now that we've mandated healthcare for everyone, it's really only a small jump to mandating healthier lifestyles for everyone. It's even rational: preventive care is cheaper and more effective than treatment. But that's not what they're going to focus on, and it's not really going to work out that way.
- buckbova 11y agoI have a better solution. Anyone with a family history of certain ailments or genetically predisposed should be sterilized. Right at birth. If you want to cut costs. And now that these citizens won't need to take care of any children they can contribute more to the state by way of taxes.
- moron4hire 11y agouuuh, ok crazy guy.
- tomjen3 11y agoHe simply applied the logic of your proposition to its extreme, he does not actually hold that position himself.
- moron4hire 11y agoIt's not my proposition, it's my prediction of how these things are going. I'm not condoning it, and I don't think I deserve snarky replies regardless.