3 ms·
But they were 180-degrees wrong on trans fats. They were touted as a healthy replacement for saturated fat. A fundamental tennent of all heath care/policy is "
by ams6110 11y ago
But they were 180-degrees wrong on trans fats. They were touted as a healthy replacement for saturated fat.
A fundamental tennent of all heath care/policy is "first, do no harm." If you change or do nothing, people are no worse off than they were to begin with. If you want to change something, you better be damn sure you aren't making matters worse.
- rmwaite 11y agobeing damn sure in a lot of cases is impossible. as mentioned previously, nutrition is a very complex system that we have barely started to understand. you might think sitting idly is better than trying to move forward, but i think you are wrong. everything we have today is because people have moved forward in the face of obstacles. sometimes we fail, but eventually we will succeed.
- njharman 11y agoChicken and egg. Hard to tell if widespread use of X is not harmful in anyway until widespread use of X has been studied.
- jessaustin 11y agoShould we be looking forward to the arsenic diet, then?
- njharman 11y ago> is not harmful in anyway
- ticksoft 11y agoBetter off just eating as naturally as possible, rather than listening to some group that's pushing something that's not.
- orbat 11y agoThere are so many competing definitions of "eating naturally" that your sentence is more or less completely meaningless
- justin66 11y agoPartially hydrogenated oils do not exist in nature. If anyone finds that assertion confounding it'd be interesting to hear why. There's some subjectivity as far as "processing" goes. Olive oil is processed mechanically, canola oil is processed chemically, so that's a pretty wide gap that people might fight over. But partial hydrogenation? Seriously?
- cbr 11y agoPartially hydrogenated oils do not exist in nature "Partially hydrogenated" describes what we did to the oil, so of course you won't get that without human involvement. Partially saturated oils, however, even ones with trans bonds, do exist in nature. For example, raw canola oil is around 0.5% trans fat. That aside, I'm still not sure your classification for "processed" or "natural" makes sense. The key step in partial hydrogenation is mixing hydrogen with the oil, [1] while a step in canola refining is mixing hexane with the oil. [2] How does your naturalness heuristic tell us one is ok and one not? [1] Which makes it surprising that this would create trans double bonds, since the effect is to reduce the number of double bonds. The problem is that with all that hydrogen available some bonds flip from cis to trans. [2] As you alluded to by saying "processed chemically".
- justin66 11y agoI did not offer a classification, which sounds like a very boring thing to do. Indeed, I meant to cast doubt on hard and fast classifications with the olive oil versus canola oil example! I just don't think any classification could categorize partially hydrogenated oils as "natural" without rendering the term entirely meaningless. Because of what we do to make them, because of their effect on the body, or because of how they differ chemically from more "natural" stuff: take your pick. The point being, eating "naturally" might be a slippery concept but a lot of what we're talking about here can be safely excluded by anyone shooting for that "natural" goal. Food threads on HN are dumb enough that I'm going to leave it at that. The parent comment has already been downvoted multiple times for some reason...