4 ms·
I feel sorry for what the various special interests groups are increasingly doing to girls growing up, so many conflicting ideas pushing and pulling them in con
by mistermann 11y ago
I feel sorry for what the various special interests groups are increasingly doing to girls growing up, so many conflicting ideas pushing and pulling them in contradictory directions.
Boys have it so much easier in this respect - yes, the downside for them is they are often the victim of trumped up "rape" charges, but at least they don't have to contend with the mental health aspects of being simultaneously told that they are both all powerful (you go girl, you can do anything) and a perpetual victim (misogyny everywhere, all the time, etc).
Adolescence and young adulthood is confusing enough without experiencing it as if in a house of mirrors.
- cyphunk 11y ago"the downside for [boys] is they are often the victim of trumped up "rape" charges" I do not know a single person that is the victim of trumped rape charges but do know several girls who were victims of actual rape (and many more of sexual abuse). If fake rape charges is a downside for boys then it's not an actual downside, it's a trumped up downside.
- cloakandswagger 11y agoPsh, what's a little false rape allegation? Man up!
- cyphunk 11y agoFalse rape allegations are a crime. But it would be better to say that the downside of being is male is that it appears they are more inclined to rape people. Because I guarantee if you if it were not for that little fact the allegation problem probably wouldn't exist.
- msandford 11y ago> But it would be better to say that the downside of being is male is that it appears they are more inclined to rape people. That's long been held to be obviously true. But a recent study shows that it may not be correct. http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2014/04/male_rape_in_america_a_new_study_reveals_that_men_are_sexually_assaulted.html http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2014/04/male_...
- cyphunk 11y agothe article is good read and I agree males are also victims. But the statistics on those perpetrating the crime (sexual assault or rape) are overwhelmingly male.
- Retric 11y agoIn the US males are both more likely to be the victim and more likely to be the perpetrator. In large part due to Prison but also younger victoms. Note: It's really hard to collect good population statistics, as victims often don't report things. And non-victims sometimes do.
- Karunamon 11y agoStatistically, yes. But stating that statistic is like stating the (also true) statistic that "black people commit statistically more violent crime" - it's worthless on its own, and is often a political dog whistle.
- woodman 11y ago> I do not know a single person ... That says more about you than anything else. I know two guys who were accused of rape, separate incidents, in both cases the guy had an air tight alibi - one was out of town and the other was at church. The churchgoing fellow didn't even know the woman, the only point of overlap for the accuser and the accused was the fact that they went to the same high school ten years prior. > If fake rape charges is a downside for boys ... You have no idea, by your own admission, how incredibly destructive the event can be.
- cyphunk 11y agoRegardless of if I do or do not understand how destructive being on the wrong end of a false rape charge is, generalizing this as a downside for males is utterly offensive.
- woodman 11y ago> ...generalizing this as a downside for males... Where does the logic not follow? False rape accusations disproportionately affect men, and it is a negative experience. So it isn't a generalization, it is a statement of fact. > ...is utterly offensive. That sounds like a personal problem, don't worry - men won't be included in any kind of protected class over this.
- cyphunk 11y agoThe comment I responded to used false rape charges as a single example of disadvantages challenging men. Perhaps I misunderstood the authors intention but that statement left alone presents an idea that of all the challenges facing men this one is one of the most important to mention. This is offensive to me as a male. It was also said in comparison to challenges facing women. This is offensive to me as a human. And I appear to not represent the majority opinion here so you are right, at least on HN, this is a personal problem.
- woodman 11y agoThe problem isn't an issue of deviant opinion, I'm sure many feel as you do, the issue is the distance between the original statement and the emotion driven conclusion you've leapt to. It looks like nobody else has interpreted it the way you have, or at least hasn't felt as strong a sense of righteous indignation. I'd probably reflect on the 'offense as a human' bit as well, leave yourself some spectrum of offense as a buffer - or else you'll be left unable to describe your emotions for the real offenses to humanity. Like how one time I saw a pack of feral dogs tear a human corpse apart after it had been left on the street for a few days, that was offensive to me as a human. Luckily for me I had reserved that category of offense, otherwise my brain might have popped out like a jack in the box upon having my prior threshold of inhumanity, a stale candy apple served to me at the county fair, surpassed.
- pron 11y agoOf course, aside from all the mental health problems girls suffer from, and the constant pressure to accuse guys of rape, they also have to contend with the (less important, perhaps, but undeniable) fact of society actually putting them down. (the first part was sarcasm, obviously)
- facepalm 11y agoWhere is society putting girls down? The wage is not a result of putting women down, but of lifestyle choices. So might be representation in STEM subjects. Men are more often usbject to violence than women, campus rape is a myth that stems from a long refuted decades old study. What problem exactly do women REALLY have?
- pron 11y agoI assume you're being sarcastic, but on the off chance you're not, I'll refer you to the last 50 years of research in social studies (and I'm not going to go through the "please cite one paper" game; I've done it too many times, the people "asking" for them are clearly not interested in the vast incontrovertible evidence, there are literally thousands of papers -- some by very renowned researchers -- and you can find most of them with a simple Google Scholar search). It's a myth just as much evolution is a myth. Both have been thoroughly studied and confirmed. Of course, there are people who deny facts because they don't agree with their world view -- that is also a well-known psychological phenomenon as is the phenomenon that that no amount of evidence can sway most people's opinions once they've made up their minds, so -- learn if you want, or don't.
- facepalm 11y agoHuh what? So you just say "undeniable" and that's it, not even a specific "accusation"? I could also point to countless papers. What about boys being left behind in education, men dying years earlier, more men being homeless and in shitty, dangerous jobs, men having less children and less time with their family and so on. What you say also goes for yourself. Your opinion won't be swayed, presumably because you feel safe and comfy in the feminist camp and don't want to risk losing your faith.
- revelation 11y agoRight, no mixed messages for boys, we just tell them they are unwelcome and useless, their hobbies suspect and ambitions outdated.
- protomyth 11y agoLet's not forget the lack of male teachers in pre-K and K-8, so a majority of their day has no positive male role models.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y ago> yes, the downside for them is they are often the victim of trumped up "rape" charges, How often? I've seen little evidence that this is very common.
- tertius 11y agoCompare and contrast how women are treated when accused of rape with men treated when accused of rape. Guilty until proven innocent. Google is your friend this happens a lot more than you realize.
- msandford 11y agoIt might not be that every man is falsely accused of rape, but that the false positive rate might be high. Which would mean that the existence of an accusation provides little predictive power regarding the guilt of the accused. If 90% of rape allegations resulted in convictions then the existence of an accusation would usually be meaningful. If only 10% of accusations result in convictions, the existence of an accusation would not be very meaningful statistically for the guilt or innocence of any one alleged perpetrator. What makes the situation even more difficult is that there's often little hard evidence of a crime. There can be evidence of sexual contact, but that doesn't ipso facto make the accusation true, because statistically sexual contact in overwhelmingly consensual. When police find a body that's been shot or stabbed that's generally hard evidence that a crime has taken place. There's often no question as to the existence of the crime (except when suicide is a possibility) and it's their job to figure out who did it and bring them to justice. But many rape cases start with the identity of the perpetrator known, and the objective is to figure out who is telling the truth in a situation with no hard evidence to back up either party. It's very different from a murder, but with just as much import. And since prosecutors don't like to lose cases (their job is to win them, and they are judged on their conviction rate) they often don't prosecute unless they have a strong case. So what happens is that it's very difficult to tell if most accusations are false, or merely not provable-enough to win in court. And because there are conflicting motivations by a number of parties in the legal process it's very difficult to suss out the actual truth and then measure the error from the actual truth that the legal system achieves, and then use that to reform the process. Because of all this, it's entirely possible that people who are accused are "often" the victims of trumped up charges while at the same time, only a very few people are accused.