4 ms·
Because it's tying in two not-intrinsically-related concepts, namely, whether someone should lose their living and whether someone should lose their status, aut
by geofft 11y ago
Because it's tying in two not-intrinsically-related concepts, namely, whether someone should lose their living and whether someone should lose their status, authority, and power. These get tied together a lot in popular parlance.
In the article about the school principal linked elsewhere in the thread, the "fired" principal actually got a desk job elsewhere in the school district. I think that's a remarkably mature position to take (provided that compensation is not wildly lower): it's certainly excessive for that person to be unable to pay rent/mortgage or provide for his family, but not excessive to be unable to supervise children and teachers.
In the story about Brendan Eich, the CTO position was available for him to step back into (and available for him to have kept from the beginning). Even if we allow that he was forced out of the CEO role less than voluntarily, it seems much clearer that he left employment with Mozilla voluntarily, since there were no calls for his resignation while he was CTO. But it still gets reported that he was sacked.
In the story about Sir Tim Hunt, he resigned (possibly voluntarily, but no matter) from an honorary professorship at UCL, while maintaining his day job at Cancer Research UK. But the media spin is that he lost his job as a professor.
I would absolutely agree that people should not lose their living for a small mistake. I would disagree that any of these are examples of that, and I would strongly disagree that an employer should feel compelled to maintain public ties with someone they wish to distance themselves from, just because they feel an ethical responsibility for providing that person's living. That would compromise freedom of speech and association, namely that of everyone else at the company.
- mcphage 11y ago> I would strongly disagree that an employer should feel compelled to maintain public ties with someone they wish to distance themselves from Here's one of the secrets of the world: companies don't really care who they associate with. They don't really care about much of anything, to be honest. They're businesses, they exist to make money, and most of them don't care beyond that. So to say that a company "wishes to distance themselves from [someone]" is a bit disingenuous. It's not like the company decided "yeah, we don't like X anymore". Maybe people inside the company feel that way! But companies don't have much of an opinion about that. What they do care about is, are there people angry with the company about X? If so, they're going to fire X, or demand their resignation (if firing them would make the company look bad), or if they can't get rid of them, shuffle them off into a corner where nobody notices them. But it's definitely not, the company has a crisis of conscience, and doesn't want to be involved with X anymore.
- afarrell 11y agoWhat if the company is a nonprofit, such as University College London or the Mozilla foundation?
- mcphage 11y agoWell, examine the evidence for them—Mozilla, for instance, had no problem with Eich as a CTO, nor had a problem promoting him to CEO. But a sustained negative publicity campaign—from people within the organization, as well as completely unrelated companies like Ok Cupid—and they backed down. In some cases, they might actually be more aggressive about it, since usually they care about something, and so quick to drop things that interfere with that thing. Take World Vision, for instance. They're a non-profit devoted to supporting orphans. They changed their policy to allow homosexual employees—but a campaign from their primarily evangelical Christian supporters cost them millions of dollars in donations, so they reversed the policy after two days. Did they still feel that allowing homosexual employees was correct? Almost definitely. But they cared more about their work supporting orphans, so anything that got in the way was removed.
- geofft 11y agoYup, that's why I said that it impacts the freedom of speech and association of the people at the company, not the company itself. I don't want to get into "Corporations are people my friend" territory. :) If we have a situation where either one employee feels like their freedom of speech cannot be exercised lest they lose their livelihood, or other employees feel like their freedom of association cannot be exercised lest they lose their livelihood, then we have done a terrible job, as a society, of structuring our framework around livelihoods to make the freedoms of speech and association realistic.
- tedbaker 11y agoYou lie when you say Eich could simply have reverted to CTO -- as CEO he had promptly promoted Andreas Gal to CTO. To promote with succession plans in place is good business practice; to undo those commitments is fatal for a business. Note now that not only is Andreas Gal no longer at Mozilla, but a number of other key leaders have left. Mozilla's undoing of _its_ decision to make Eich CEO looks to be fatal too, with its leadership departing and market share sliding into single digits.
- geofft 11y agoYou're correct, sorry. The Mozilla FAQ says the board offered him some other C-level position. Whether this was the right decision for Mozilla is still an orthogonal question from whether he unjustly lost his livelihood. If bowing to public pressure is bad for corporate health, let's talk about that, and avoid dragging the emotional "but he lost his job!" into it.