4 ms·
It always amuses me that some people sneer at thinking paper can have value, and point to their security blanket: magic, shiny rocks. (There are magic rocks, a
by patio11 17y ago
It always amuses me that some people sneer at thinking paper can have value, and point to their security blanket: magic, shiny rocks. (There are magic rocks, and shiny rocks, but duh, only the magic, shiny rocks are useful as currency. Naturally.)
You can have wild fluctuations in the supply of magic, shiny rocks -- it has happened before, and it will happen again. For example, when Spain discovered that they could kill people and take their rocks more efficiently than they could mine their own rocks. It also happens on the microeconomic level, a phenomenon known as a Magic Shiny Rock Rush.
When the supply of magic, shiny rocks increases suddenly, the amount of magic, shiny rocks you need to buy things also increases.
- jeromec 17y agoThat's a good point about the risk of supply fluctuations, but there is no denying it keeps govt's in check by removing the ability to (easily) manipulate currency. EDIT: In response to replies the above should read "govt's in check short of using force"
- patio11 17y agoI'm going to go ahead and deny it, actually. North Korea can confiscate value pretty easily regardless of whether they use crispy paper or shiny magic rocks as currency. "Give me all your magic rocks, or I'll send men to beat you." (If that sounds far-fetched, I would note that the United States has banned private possession of gold before.) More subtle variations on this: "We require you to pay us in shiny magic rocks, but we will only pay you in crispy paper.", "Our coins are made out of shiny magic rocks... but, haha, there is less magic in them now! Too bad you're not an alchemist and will never notice!", "These paper entitle you to shiny magic rocks. We're lying, but you don't know that.", etc, etc, etc.
- jeromec 17y agoI partially agree; that's why what I meant would be a total metal reliance, e.g. 1oz silver/gold eagles etc. where the amount of gold/silver is guaranteed and consistent. I'm not saying metal's an optimum solution, only pointing out its abilities.
- sethg 17y agoGuaranteed by whom? If in 2009 the government guarantees that its mint's coins will be at least 99% gold, and then in 2010 it guarantees that they will be at least 90% gold, what are you going to do—assay each coin that comes into your hand before you put it in your wallet? (The Israel Museum once had an exhibit on money which included a series of ancient coins, struck from exactly the same mold over a number of years. The oldest one was something like 90% gold and the most recent was something like 1%.)
- jeromec 17y agoThe metal is just the tool. Like the Constitution or anything else, it's up to the people to hold the govt. to the standard. Unlike non-backed currency, with metals any shaving of value can be detected obviously (more obviously than taxation via inflation) and quantified.
- sethg 17y agoThe only “value” of currency that matters to me is my ability to give it up in exchange for the things that I want and take it in exchange for the things I have. In this sense, if I don’t trust government-provided statistics, all I need to detect changes in the “value” of currency is to keep a budget. If my currency-denominated expenses have gone up and my standard of living has remained constant, that’s an obvious sign of inflation. By contrast, if a supermarket cashier gives me a handful of coins in change and I want to know which are 90% gold, which are 95%, and which are 99%, what am I supposed to do? Carry an analytic balance into the grocery store? That would make me real popular with everyone standing behind me in line....
- jeromec 17y agoWill a dime buy you a gallon of gas today, as it would in the early 1900s? It would if it were a silver dime, which is roughly worth $3 now. People don't notice loss of value as easily as when it's obviously measurable, as in loss of metal. The law (hypothetically) would decree coins had that amount of metal, and discrepancies would make the news. I'm not arguing for metal, so much as pointing out its contrast with non-backed currency.
- ntoshev 17y agoAny commodity approximates currency, but in practice this doesn't keep totalitarian governments in check. The government can take away your house or any possessions you couldn't hide, ban trading of popular commodities (like foreign currencies; this drastically reduces liquidity), or, as a measure of last resort, kill you. Former socialist countries have seen all of these after WWII.
- thaumaturgy 17y agoOr, more subtly -- and not requiring any force at all -- a government can simply hoard any commodity or currency through a series of differences in trading other commodities or currencies, artificially inflating the value of the commodity (or currency).
- anigbrowl 17y agoAhahahaha no. Have no never wondered why standards bodies (which decree official weights and measures) are operated by governments? Many times throughout history, measurements of everything from land area to the standard weight of coins have been adjusted by governments to suit their policies (sometimes in the interests of fairness and trade, sometimes in the interests of refilling the treasury or paying an army). Certainly, one can turn to science and make objective statements about both mass and purity. But unless you have melting facilities and deal in raw metal (rather than stamped coins) there is no advantage in this. As a hypothetical sovereign individual, you'll lose out when trying to trade raw metal because without the word of an independent (and government-licensed) assayer the buyer will discount the value of your lump'o'gold to allow for the possible unreliability of your claims about purity and weight. Most people don't have the facilities to assay precious metals themselves, so they rely on a third party to certify such claims; the implied social contract stamped into a coin or ingot has much greater value than the actual metal itself. Please, look into some history of money. currency abuse is not a recent phenomenon by any means.
- patrickgzill 17y agoGold and silver are insurance against the government's behavior. Paper issued by the government cannot serve that purpose.
- eru 17y agoThen take paper issued either by a foreign government or by a non-government.
- patrickgzill 17y agoQuis custodiet ipsos custodes?
- eru 17y agoDon't you trust the Swiss?
- patrickgzill 17y agoThe Swiss Franc used to be 100% backed by gold. No longer, they removed backing and convertibility in 1999. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_standard#Gold_as_a_reserve_today http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_standard#Gold_as_a_reserve...
- eru 17y agoInteresting. Though I don't care about gold. Just that they don't inflate their currency too much.
- anigbrowl 17y agoDon't be naive. Sure, if you have a small sum of gold buried in the yard, it can hold its value through times of political uncertainty. But to exercise any meaningful opposition to a despotic government, you need to be rich ( in order to pay people to do your will) or well-organized (in order to urge them via the media). In the former case, you can be taxed - governments levying taxes on the very wealthy usually goes down well with the much poorer majority - and in the latter, you can be declared a subversive and censored. You might find it instructive to examine the history of ancient Rome around the time of Nero and Caligula. If you find history books dry reading, get a copy of 'I, Claudius' which presents the history of that period in narrative form and is both educational and entertaining. This is not to say that opposition to a tyrannical government is hopeless - indeed, history with littered with examples of such leading to revolution. But currency alone is a weak check on a determined oppressor. And (as we are sadly reminded by news from Africa on a regular basis) revolutions often result only in a change of players, but the game remains the same.
- dpatru 17y agoWhile it's possible for gold to fluctuate in value, it's not as easy or common to change the value of gold as it is to manipulate the value of fiat currency. The whole point of a gold-standard is to make money a more durable store of value. The argument that gold is not perfect is irrelevant. It's like responding to an argument that you should stop smoking by saying that even non-smokers suffer health problems and die.
- asciilifeform 17y ago> You can have wild fluctuations in the supply of magic, shiny rocks -- it has happened before, and it will happen again. This is not unlike eschewing seat belts because asteroids have been known to smash into the Earth.
- raintrees 17y agoEspecially if certain conspiracy theories are true that some gold ingots are being discovered as gold-covered tungsten and not solid gold...