3 ms·
The terms, as stated, are ridiculous. If you write an article that gets picked up for the NY Times, they pay you for it. If you write an article for a magazine,
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
The terms, as stated, are ridiculous. If you write an article that gets picked up for the NY Times, they pay you for it. If you write an article for a magazine, they pay you for it. Once they do, and you've granted them a partial copyright (in this case most likely second serial rights) then every time they pull an article to include in their "news" they should pay the author.
The much better way to do this would be, "We'd like to include your RSS feed in our News application, if anyone reads an article that you have provided to us we will make a one time payment to you of $X (say $250), in exchange for that payment you give us the right, in perpetuity, to continue to provide access to that article though our News application."
Basically if you're writing is bringing people to the News application they should pay for that. And once they have, they can monetize there end of it just like newspapers and magazines by putting ads on the site or adding other junk.
It sounds like they are trying to construct some novel theory[1] where if someone managed to find your blog and read it they wouldn't have paid for it, so Apple doesn't need to pay for it if they are using it to attract people to their app.
So lets look at it from an information economics perspective, the author's article derives its value from the author's artistic expression. Nobody else is going to write it just like they did, or how they did. The author "spends" that value to attract readers to the blog, and readers "pay" for that value by by exposed to advertisers who have paid the author to be on their page. So you get that?
The reader "buys" their content by agreeing to be exposed to advertising.
The author "sells" their content by providing access to their readers to advertisers.
The advertiser "buys" access to the content by paying the author when a reader interacts with the ad.
Apple is trying to step in, get the content for free, bring readers to their News App and then sell access to their readers to the Advertisers. You can see that without the Author's content there is no "value" to readers in the news app. Authors who agree to this are simply dropping money into Apple's lap.
[1] It isn't really novel people try to rip off artists by offering them 'exposure' all the time.