4 ms·
Entire Manhattan, including 200th streets? I can imagine that areas like this already exist, e.g. in most lower Manhattan and upper west side. Did it result in
by nine_k 11y ago
Entire Manhattan, including 200th streets?
I can imagine that areas like this already exist, e.g. in most lower Manhattan and upper west side. Did it result in anything particularly bad, or at least measurably bad?
(Disclaimer: I live in Brooklyn and work on Manhattan; my commute is still better than in most other places I lived.)
- exelius 11y agoEventually, yeah. There is a finite supply of land on Manhattan, and demand from foreign buyers is growing. Downtown and midtown are already saturated, so the billion dollar condo buildings of 2040 will need to be built somewhere.
- bradleyjg 11y agoI don't see any particular reason that Inwood will be more desirable in 2040 than Brooklyn Heights. Being physically on the island of Manhattan just isn't that big a deal. What matters in the long run seems to be commuting time and to a lesser extent zoning and projects. Looking at this heat map: http://project.wnyc.org/transit-time/#40.75805,-73.98571,12,790 http://project.wnyc.org/transit-time/#40.75805,-73.98571,12,... I'd be bullish on Sunnyside / western Woodside.
- runako 11y agoI hear this often, but it doesn't jive with my impressions of Manhattan (lived there years ago, visit periodically). In particular, significant parts of the island top out at walk-up heights (5-6 stories). The economics of rent in Manhattan would change dramatically if the island were rebuilt using modern technologies (chiefly: elevators and the taller buildings they enable). Without knowing the local politics, it seems obvious that there is some force that is preventing the low-productivity uses of land (broadly: "short buildings") from being converted into higher-productivity uses (chiefly "taller buildings"). There's only a finite supply of ground -- this does not mean there has to be a finite supply of usable indoor space. The latter is a choice that can presumably be changed when the will arises.
- nerfhammer 11y agoHistorically it was partly because the later-developed parts of the city were built on less viable land (i.e. swamp/landfill)
- nemo44x 11y agoYou can't just tear down some 4-story building and put up sky scrappers. There is a maximum density capacity that a lot of Manhattan already exceeds. The trains, sewers and electrical requirements need to be thought of too. Especially the trains which are already way over capacity. Look at what has happened in Williamsburg and the L-train. As more and more warehouses have been converted into apartments and new condo's have gone up, the L-train has become awful for large parts of the day. And the train runs as often as possible during those times. I'm not saying you can't do these things but I do think other things need to be considered.
- onion2k 11y agoDid it result in anything particularly bad, or at least measurably bad? I imagine that depends on the timescale you're looking at. A similar thing has happened in London over the past 30 years - the upshot is that schools and hospitals are now finding it practically impossible to recruit teachers and nurses in the city because they can't afford to live within a commutable distance. That's quite bad.
- ars 11y ago> are now finding it practically impossible to recruit teachers and nurses in the city because they can't afford to live within a commutable distance. That's quite bad. Then they will pay more, all the extra money will go to rent, and things will stabilize again. Do Hospitals located in expensive places receive extra reimbursement from the government?