6 ms·
You don't want to do that for reasons that Elon understands well. Part of Elon's design for the pylons allows the track to remain stable even when the pylons a
by btilly 11y ago
You don't want to do that for reasons that Elon understands well.
Part of Elon's design for the pylons allows the track to remain stable even when the pylons are moved by an earthquake. Which is kind of important with pods moving around Mach 1. Doing the same thing with a tunnel requires you to have cut a large enough hole to shift the tube inside of. Which is a massively harder piece of engineering.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoInterested. TBMs are designed to drill through the earth, and then to wrap the tunnel walls with concrete blocks that are rated to last over 100 years. I'm curious if a TBM could cut through the earth and build hyperloop infrastructure behind it as well. As with everything, there are tradeoffs. Building above ground means land use issues, and the tunnel needs to be so small you can't stand in the hyperloop pods. Building underground means more support infrastructure, but you're limited less by politics and land use problems and more by engineering. The questions is: which is cheaper to solve? Engineering? Or politics?
- btilly 11y agoThe answer is an emphatic no. Concrete can do many things, but it will not hold back a slip fault. Concrete roads, bridges, etc will buckle and break in the slip zone no matter what they are rated for. Take the 1906 earthquake as an example. As http://pubs.usgs.gov/gip/earthq3/move.html http://pubs.usgs.gov/gip/earthq3/move.html says, the horizontal slip was 21 feet at one point. Something like the Hyperloop has to be designed with the expectation of facing a similar event. Concrete is simply not strong enough to hold back a wall of dirt trying to move 21 feet. Or for more recent history https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/landers-and-big-bear-california-earthquakes-june-28-1992 https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/landers-and-big-bear-califo... where the slip was 18 feet horizontally and 6 feet vertically. And that one demonstrates that it isn't enough to build something special for every slip zone you know about. Because in a real earthquake you are likely to discover slip zones that nobody noticed.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThank you for the info!
- abduhl 11y agoHow is the issue of a horizontal slip different for a tunnel versus for an above ground structure? Neither piece of infrastructure can be economically designed to withstand a seismic movement if the structure crosses the fault where the offset occurs. Why does the possibility of an offset result in a tunnel being an "emphatic no" while still allowing for this pylon idea?
- btilly 11y agoThe pylons are built with an internal structure allowing them to move horizontally both ways, and vertically. The tube itself can remain stationary in the air. We do not have a cost effective way to allow the tube to remain stationary if it is attached to the ground and the ground moves. And avoiding buckling and sudden bends kind of matters when you're traveling at mach 1. Search for "earthquake" in http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha.pdf to confirm that this is a design factor the Elon explicitly considered.
- abduhl 11y agoI'm sorry but no - this does not answer the question. Expansion joints and "lateral dampers" do not make the problem of a joint offset go away. In order to resist a horizontal or vertical offset of 20+ feet with the tube "remaining stationary" then the pylon must be built to allow an extra 40+ feet to account for this movement. How, exactly, does the pylon not suffer the same design flaw as the tunnel under the use case that you yourself brought up of a horizontal or vertical offset occuring along a splay?
- btilly 11y agoWhere do you get your 40+ feet figure from? If each side can move the tunnel 10 feet relative to itself without breaking, you should theoretically be able to handle up to a 20 foot slip between plates. One side bends one away, the other the other way. The pylons move 20 feet relative to each other, and only 10 feet relative to the tube. That said, my information is based on the blueprint that Elon published and I already linked to. It includes graphs showing numerical simulations of how their design is supposed to respond to earthquakes. If you have further questions, you can start with that, then download the designs that they and others have produced and do your own work. I am not an engineer. However I do know that engineers have done exactly what I suggested and come to the conclusion that his design is feasible.