3 ms·
So.. you want a dedicated physical server with a single host OS, running your containers... what do you need VMWare for again?
by stephenr 11y ago
So.. you want a dedicated physical server with a single host OS, running your containers... what do you need VMWare for again?
- chris_wot 11y agoTheir management tools.
- stephenr 11y agoManagement of what exactly?
- acdha 11y agoNon-startups have existing applications. It'd be really nice if you could use one tool suite to manage conventional VMs and containers with the same HA & capacity management tools (i.e. keep n instances running on y separate hosts), virtualized networking and storage, etc. Think about working somewhere really big: it's both hard and risky to split a huge business system into containers in one release. Imagine instead doing something like carving out the database, load balancer, task queue workers, etc. piecemeal with a discrete component being containerized in each release. If you were taking the agile approach like that, not saying “Here's a completely different way to manage all of the new services” has significant value.
- stephenr 11y agoContainers and HyperVisors/VMs have intrinsically different abilities and different use-cases. Why would you expect one tool to manage both. Do you also expect your email client to manage your photo library and keep track of your phone calls?
- TallGuyShort 11y ago>> Do you also expect your email client to manage your photo library and keep track of your phone calls? Gmail will basically do that, what with tight integration with Picassa and Google Voice...
- acdha 11y ago> Containers and HyperVisors/VMs have intrinsically different abilities and different use-cases. Why would you expect one tool to manage both. Can you explain why you believe this to be true? Consider my database server example – if I want to have a MySQL/Postgres service available for our developers to use why would it matter whether it runs inside a VM or a container at the level where I'm saying “Keep 2 copies running on separate hosts for HA” or “Block network access except for hosts in this service group”? To me, it's a sign of bad system design if the consumers of a service need to know whether it's running on a VM or a container. Only the developers and operators should need to care at that level.
- chris_wot 11y agoTo me, it's a sign of bad system design if the consumers of a service need to know whether it's running on a VM or a container. Only the developers and operators should need to care at that level. This. The advantage of containers is that you isolate and control your resources more precisely - if those using the software running in the container find they have differing requirements, you should just be able to change the resources allocated to the container - in much the same way you would with a normal server.
- chris_wot 11y agoReally? If you've isolated your resources to a group of processes, and you further isolate IPC, network, mount points, process, users, groups and hostnames to that same group of processes - how does this not fall under the definition of what a hypervisor does?