2 ms·
I see, so how long has this -- you can buy a home loan now and bank on rental prices increasing soon. In around 4-5 years the rents would have increased enough
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I see, so how long has this -- you can buy a home loan now and bank on rental prices increasing soon. In around 4-5 years the rents would have increased enough to cover the mortgage, and then its time to start shopping for a new building. -- been going on? 5 years? 10 years? 75 years?
There was an interesting article in Bloomberg about Mumbai in 2012 (http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2012-07-05/mumbais-boom-turns-renters-into-millionaires http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2012-07-05/mumbais-boom...) with the rent control there causing huge market imbalances as India lifts millions of people out of poverty into the middle classes. It reads similarly to situations in Shanghai and Chengdu as a people's wages have risen faster than the housing market could keep up.
The reason I ask about how long it has gone on is that the situation you describe always ends up correcting at some point, (here in the US we called it the housing bubble), and when it does all the people who were betting on the ever increasing rents find themselves going bankrupt because rents cannot increase any further, and that puts them into a financial emergency where they sell, which depresses prices of houses, which results in other speculators also falling out of the market, and you get a really huge recession with lots of people going broke and a bunch of supporting industries (construction, remodelling, furniture, etc) being carried along as well.
- rdsubhas 11y agoSorry for the late response, not sure if this thread is active anymore. By correction, I guess you mean a slowdown or stall of the rent rate rise. I'm just saying that enough damage is already done here, and what we'll see is just two extremes (obsession or recession). Given that so many people's livelihood depends on having a roof above their head, there has to be a better option. I don't know exactly how Germany is planning to implement these laws. But at least I feel a sustained rate of growth should make life better for everybody in the city, rather than plain rent caps or slabs.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThanks again for responding. By 'correction' I mean rents reverting to market rates rather than speculative rates. When that happens a lot of people will go bankrupt and often in those situations there is a time where things are cheaper than they 'should' be (by market forces). Foreclosed homes in the US was a good example of this, since the bank will sell at any price, it allows the price to go much lower than if people are selling. When your loan holders get desperate because the loan is due and no one is willing to pay their extortionate rent, they will either go broke (lender reclaims the property and sells it at a loss) or reduce rents dramatically to insure 100% occupancy (lowering prices to capture more of the demand). Sometimes both, rents will go down and the people owning the buildings will go bankrupt. If you're willing too, let me know what city this is happening in, I'd like to put it into my crawler to flag articles about rents to watch how this plays out over time.