3 ms·
Yeah, it's become so pervasive that it's not out of the ordinary for American reporters to say 'Mehiko" instead of Mexico while speaking an otherwise English se
by mc32 11y ago
Yeah, it's become so pervasive that it's not out of the ordinary for American reporters to say 'Mehiko" instead of Mexico while speaking an otherwise English sentence. Or they try to pronounce the surname Velazquez in Spanish, but when it comes to Van Gogh or 習近平, there is no attempt at native pronunciation. This kind of inconsistency is baffling --moreover their Spanish pronunciation is not Castillian even when the person is Spanish. So they are all over the map.
I've been down to Mexico and I'm quite sure people don't try to pronounce 'Nueva York' as 'New York'.
On the other hand, these same reporters mangle Chinese city names with abandon, so it's not as if they're just trying to say the names in a native fashion --which I guess at least would make some consistent sense.
- javert 11y agoRegarding Chinese city names, in the 2008 Olympics, newscasters were trying to use the Chinese name for the location instead of the English name (which is Beijing). It was horrible. It was incorrect. It was "politically correct."
- creshal 11y ago> the English name (which is Beijing) Beijing? Peking? Pei-ching? Peiping? What is the correct spelling and what isn't for foreign names changes over time. (It's quite amusing how Germans go to great lengths to use the new, Polish names for cities in former Prussia, while for Belgian cities that haven't been under German control for much longer, they insist on German names.)
- CPLX 11y agoWell in their defense my understanding is they had a somewhat embarrassing dust-up with Poland a few years back.
- calibraxis 11y agoI think it’s a tip-of-the-hat when you use another culture’s pronunciation. When I’m outside the US, sometimes people do that for me. When I’m speaking a foreign language, I may decide to pronounce an English word with (the so-called) General American accent.
- jcranmer 11y agoIf you're going for phonetic correctness, Mexico should be pronounced "Meshi-co" according to the original Nahuatl. Transcription of foreign languages into Latin script is difficult in its own right since the "obvious" phonetic value of letters presumes certain phonosyntactic rules that don't always hold (e.g., Mandarin Chinese uses an aspirated/unaspirated distinction and not a voiced/voiceless distinction). It furthermore doesn't help that the main sources of transcription (English, French, Spanish, Portuguese) don't agree on the phonetic values of letters, nor that people tend to retain the traditional spellings of place names even when proper phonetic readings of that spelling (or even the verbal pronunciation of the name itself) changes. In my opinion, trying to enforce "native" pronunciation of foreign place names is misguided: those who argue for it don't argue for Österreich, Deutschland, or Hrvatska, so why should we elevate foreign place names that merely happen to be spelled the same in English as their native tongue to getting special treatment?
- mc32 11y agoThat's the problem. Either do it for all or don't do it. It's not as if English does not have the words or English pronunciation for all these places. I don't see many Italians who speak some English saying 'I come from Roma. They say Rome. On they other hand you have people who will say OOrooguay instead of the English Yourugwye. Maybe it's more a Latin American thing, not sure. At least it seems pretty prevalent. Maybe psychologically it has to do with the slightly anti-american disposition of many of the politicians down there. Lot's of them trot out the old "imperialists" trope when it's convenient. so maybe it's a kind of psychologically subversive thing. I remember someone saying, well that's the name of my country in spanish, so that's why I say it that way --something along those lines. As if saying it with the english pronunciation took something away from their country being whole. Or maybe that was just a one off weird person.