14 ms·
Magna Carta, Still Posing a Challenge at 800
- caf 11y agoHere is one provision of the Magna Carta (1297 version) listed among the Acts currently in force for one jurisdiction: http://www5.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/act/consol_act/mc129725e1c29100/ http://www5.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/act/consol_act/mc129725e...
- femto 11y agoNice juxtaposition. Compare the text of the Australian Capital Territory's (ACT) law in the parent's link: "No freeman shall be taken or imprisoned, or disseised of his freehold, liberties or free customs, or be outlawed or exiled or in any other wise destroyed; nor will We pass upon him nor condemn him, but by lawful judgment of his peers or by the law of the land." With today's speech by the Australian Human Rights Commissioner, to the ACT's Supreme Court [1]. "Examples of [Federal] government overreach, she said, included powers to indefinitely detain - without rights to judicial review - refugees, asylum seekers, the mentally ill, and those suffering from infectious diseases." The actions of the Australian Federal and ACT governments are diametrically opposite. The ACT government is the local government that looks after Australia's capital city, where the Australian Federal government sits and makes national laws. [1] http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/australian-bill-of-rights-would-enshrine-fair-go-maxim-gillian-triggs-20150615-gho3lq.html http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/austra...
- Ntrails 11y agoDepends on your definition of freeman, of course. I'll lay odds that Aborigines (sp) were not considered to be covered at various points in history
- cmdkeen 11y agoThat's the problem with Magna Carta, it doesn't actually mean anything. If you change "the law of the land" then you can do all of the things listed above - and note it doesn't even say "lawful judgement and" it is an "or" so you can have detention without trial, even execution without trial as long as it is the law.
- caf 11y agoIt does mean something though; the point is that the Executive (in place of the Sovereign) can't just instruct the police to detain you on a whim - it has to be done in accordance with powers specifically granted by the people's representatives in Parliament. If you don't like the laws passed by Parliament, vote in different representatives!
- skidoo 11y agoBecause Flat-Earthers are valid and we should allow their input into a world where microwave ovens can be electronically hacked from a world away and where Kim Kardashian is the bee's knees. I am all for the "wisdom of the ancients", but I wish more folks were willing and able to find a new, better solution than a Baskin & Robbins variation of anything ago. Meaning Libertarianism and Social-Anarchism and anything else that looks great on paper only in the Cliffs Notes version. Vanilla is vanilla, and the world is falling the fuck apart already no matter how many college juniors praise Chomsky. Outside the box or walk.
- skidoo 11y agoWho voted that down? Did I disagree with your favorite commercial media journalist? So sorry for the faux paux. So embarrassed. Will make mental note to pick extra cotton from your master's salt mines when my time comes to leave the shed next month. Hoping to save enough bitcoin to buy a generator for warm water to keep my niece alive. Blessed be! But what about THIS cat vid, cultural commentators? Amirite? That calico almost looked like a foreigner. Can you imagine!
- parwell 11y agoI think it's mostly your annoying attitude.
- coolsunglasses 11y agoYou're not contributing anything and at the time Magna Carta was signed people had known the earth was round for over 1,000 years. Have you ever been on a boat? Look at the horizon. They'd been on boats too. Also see: http://www.windows2universe.org/citizen_science/myw/w2u_eratosthenes_calc_earth_size.html http://www.windows2universe.org/citizen_science/myw/w2u_erat...
- nicobn 11y agoPeople downvoted you because you can't seem to get down from your high horse. But since you started, let me give you a tip. You shouldn't use a language you don't understand. "Faux paux", more like "faux français".
- oska 11y agoCan anyone recommend a good book on the Magna Carta and the historical background to it? Keen to do some reading; I know only the basics.
- rodgerd 11y agoIt's not specific to Magna Carta, but I enjoyed Dan Jones' The Plantagenets, which provides context to how the original document came to be, and how the re-issues were forced by the waxing and waning strength of the kings who followed John. It's an enjoyable book.
- oska 11y agoThanks for the suggestion. Looked the author up on Wikipedia and found he has also recently written a book on the Magna Carta called Magna Carta: The Making And Legacy Of The Great Charter.
- NickSharp 11y ago"1215" by Danny Danziger and John Gillingham is exactly what you want. http://www.amazon.com/1215-Magna-Carta-Danny-Danziger/dp/0743257782/ http://www.amazon.com/1215-Magna-Carta-Danny-Danziger/dp/074...
- icebraining 11y agoI didn't read it, but Magna Carta: A Very Short Introduction has been recommend. Here's a podcast with the author regarding the topic: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/05/nicholas_vincen.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/05/nicholas_vincen.htm...
- javert 11y agoFor anyone wondering about why it's being called "Magna Carta" instead of "the Magna Carta"... From Wikipdia: > Magna Carta was given its name in Latin, a language which has no direct, consistent correlate of the English definite article "the". As a result, the usual academic convention is to refer to the document in English without the article as "Magna Carta" rather than "the Magna Carta". Of course, in proper English it's "the Magna Carta." The rules of Latin have no bearing on proper English. Also: We don't call Paris "Par-ee" like in French. Words in different languages are different words. "Magna Carta" just happens to be spelled the same in English and Latin. Leave it to the NYT to do the wrong but "fashionable" "academic" thing. At least we can count on that. Language is prescriptive, but I don't want to have that debate.
- phaemon 11y ago> Of course, in proper English it's "the Magna Carta." Nope. You don't say, "the Paris" now do you? There's no particular rule of when you use "the" before a name. As that notable academic, Tony Hancock, once asked, "Does Magna Carta mean nothing to you? Did she die in vain?"
- javert 11y agoLegal documents are preceeded by "the" unless they are numbered. So: the Constitution, the Patriot Act, the Articles of Confederation, the Freedom of Information Act, the Federal Register. But: HB 289, Title IX, Proposition 8. This is probably just a species of a more general rule dealing with articles and things that have given names.
- smegel 11y ago> Nope. You don't say, "the Paris" now do you? Or New York. Or London. > There's no particular rule of when you use "the" before a name. Well I don't know if the rules cover all cases, but one rule is you don't use "the" before place names. Or given names "the Barack Obama". Titles are OK "the President of the USA". Clearly the names of "things" like books require the use of "the". Like "the Bible". It's important to distinguish between the "name" of a book and it's title. We clearly don't say "I read the To Kill a Mockingbird".
- esfandia 11y agoOf interest to the Canadian readers: one version of Magna Carta is on tour and currently on display at the Canadian Museum of History (i.e., the good old Museum of Civilization) in Ottawa. http://www.magnacartacanada.ca/ http://www.magnacartacanada.ca/
- calibraxis 11y ago“In a few months, we will be commemorating the 800th anniversary of the sealing of Magna Carta—commemorating, but not celebrating; rather, mourning the blows it has suffered. [...] “To be sure, the reach of the charter was limited. Nevertheless, as Eric Kasper observes in a scholarly review, “What began as a relatively small check on the arbitrary power of King John eventually led to succeeding generations finding ever more rights in Magna Carta and Article 39. In this sense, Magna Carta is a key point in a long development of the protection of rights against arbitrary executive power.” — Noam Chomsky http://www.thenation.com/article/198513/killing-commons http://www.thenation.com/article/198513/killing-commons
- GavinBrown 11y agoWhat's being celebrated today is not Magna Carta itself, but the myth that's grown up around it. The UK's best blogger on law, "Jack of Kent", puts it well: http://jackofkent.com/2015/06/the-meaning-of-magna-carta/ http://jackofkent.com/2015/06/the-meaning-of-magna-carta/
- billpg 11y agoHe's the guy sitting in the corner on New Year's Eve muttering that its just an arbitrary point on the calendar with no natural significance.
- pjc50 11y agoHe's also the one pointing out that the UK government is keen to celebrate Magna Carta (which has no constitutional status or enforceability) while dismantling the Human Rights act (which is definitely enforceable).