5 ms·
So, the labels charge the bands for everything they do for them? So why do they then also take 90% of the income? You get a profit if you make an investment, b
by ars 17y ago
So, the labels charge the bands for everything they do for them? So why do they then also take 90% of the income?
You get a profit if you make an investment, but if you charge for all your services, you didn't make an investment, so why do you deserve a profit?
But, I guess it works, since people are doing it.
- pyre 17y agoLoan sharks exist and make money too. "It works."
- jrockway 17y agoThis is why artists don't care if you pirate their music. Their music was already stolen by the record company. Albums basically amount to free advertising for the band.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoSo, the labels charge the bands for everything they do for them? So why do they then also take 90% of the income? Because it means more money in their pockets, duh. Accounting in the entertainment industry is as crooked as it gets.
- tezza 17y agoPlenty of businesses have multiple ways of billing. If you order repeat bank statements from your mortgage bank, are they not allowed to charge you for postage?? As far as the article can show, Warner Bros is out $300K on the deal with little prospect of getting it back. That's presuming the digital download sum was actually $92,000 instead of $65.
- Quarrelsome 17y agoYou missed the bit where he points out that 90% that Warner take off the CD sales are not deducted from the advance. In his figures Warner only had to sell 15,000 of each CD to break even (which the author seems to suggest they did). At this point the band will still be in the red with the label but the label wont be in the red with the band.
- tezza 17y agoI didn't miss that bit. That 90-10% repayment split is part of the contract agreement he made with WB. If it isn't he can sue WB. --- Other world examples: When one pays off a mortgage, you need to pay both for the interest portion as well as the consideration portion. That can vary over time. First you are paying off interest, later a mix. Again very clearly a contract term and not morally wrong.
- ars 17y agoYou don't get it. Why does WB deserve to earn any money from sales, if they don't put in a single cent of their own? Every cent they put in, they charge to the artists. So why do they deserve to make any money at all? Sure, it's in the contact. But it's morally wrong.
- tezza 17y agoLOL! Lecturing me on "not getting it" is not a nice or effective tactic. -- WB put in advance money to make the albums in the first place. Nothing morally wrong there. Further, lets say that 90% fee on current sales goes into the pool of money for signing new bands who might be successful. Nothing morally wrong there. WB does not necessarily blow it all on Cocaine binges and executive Porsches.
- Retric 17y agoWhat about this one: 6 points by pierrefar 2 hours ago | link The numbers are scary: WB claims to be $300k out but they're not accounting for a sizable revenue stream. The post mentions the band earned $12k in 5 years from albums they control, and they expected the albums WB control to earn 2-5X more. Assume 5x$12, and you'll get closer to $200k. Do that over quite a few years, and they'll end up owing the band money while the band members are alive. Keep telling them $62 over five years and they'll never ever need to write them a cheque. How is this not pure and simple theft?
- 17y ago
- InclinedPlane 17y agoYou seem to miss the difference between "legal" and "morally defensible". Sure, bands with no knowledge of business or law (most of them) can sign horrific contracts tremendously skewed toward the advantage of the record labels, all perfectly legal. But that doesn't make it right.
- tezza 17y agoWhat is it with lecturing me about missing stuff...??? Come on. I have a different viewpoint. I happen to think it is completely "morally defensible" thank you. --- One of my best mates at University (in Sydney) graduated in Law and set up business helping unsigned Bands on equitable terms for low fees. Unfortunately for him, there were not enough bands who sought his low-cost, equitable contracts. They preferred the expensive, "morally-indefensible" contracts with terrible terms. My friend is now a primrary school-teacher and enjoying life a lot more. What do you have to say about that? Or will you just say I'm "missing something"? or "you don't get it"
- ABrandt 17y agoI think InclindedPlane was referring to the fact that the article emphasizes that Warner Bros. technically is not out $400k. They've recouped their expenses from the TMJ loan by taking 90% of the band's profits throughout the years. There is no negative cash flow here. What they are missing, however; is the payment from the band. Presumably they agreed to pay back the full amount out of their pockets in the original contract. And where does their personal income flow from? Royalties. This is how I see the numbers if they were to pay back the loan: Gross Profit: $4,000,000 TMJ Share: 400,000 Warner Share: 3,600,000 TMJ Profit: $0 Warner Profit: $4,000,000 Warner Bros. will essentially make a 10x ROI before TMJ earns a dime. Just because bands willingly sign these contracts does not make them morally defensible. The record labels are clearly making a killing off artists who simply break-even, and I think people are finally starting to realize this...perhaps your friend's business was just ahead of its time.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoTo be fair, the record label profit is more like 1/3 of the revenue, not 100%. Still, compared to 10-15% less every expense imaginable, they make out far better (even on "unrecouped" bands) than the artists.
- rbanffy 17y ago"So, the labels charge the bands for everything they do for them? So why do they then also take 90% of the income?" Because, as the article explains, many bands (presumably most of them) never pay back what the label invested. If TMJ never earns them a penny, they have to cover their losses with those who do.
- dagw 17y agoAccording to the article TMJ probably earned the label back all the money they lent them, but from a different revenue stream. The loan doesn't get paid back from all the money the band generates, but from a small percentage of it. Let us say that an album sale makes $6 for the label and $3 for the band, then the label first takes the $6 and then also takes the $3 to pay down the advance. So even though that album sale in effect gave the label $9 in revenue, they only decreased the loan by $3. So in this example the losses from a 90k$ advance will be completely recovered after 10k sales, but the band will still 'owe' the label until they've made 30k sales. So just because a band still 'owes' a label hundreds of thousands of dollars, that does not mean that the label lost that money.
- rbanffy 17y agoThe labels, are, in effect, lending the money the band needs to start and promote itself. If you give me 100K today and I give you back 100K three years from now, I won't expect you to think we are even.
- dagw 17y agoHowever if I gave you 100K today to start a company with the condition that I get 60% of every sale you make plus you still have to pay me back the 100K out of your 40%, then it is certainly possible for me to make out very well from the deal even if you never actually manage to pay me back the full loan. At what point we are considered "even" is of course up for debate.
- coliveira 17y agoThe $100K are used to promote the product, so it is just an investment for the label -- which may be eventually fully paid from the band's money. It looks like a sweet deal to me.
- philwelch 17y agoYour startup hires a hacker. The hacker earns a salary. So why does he get to have equity, too? It's not a matter of principle here, it's a matter of how bad the bargain is in reality. In my example, the employee receives a decent guaranteed pay but low percentage of the upside. The founder receives low guaranteed pay but more upside. The label though receives most of the upside and most of the guaranteed pay too.