3 ms·
Let's assess the pure mathematical effectiveness of this cap with an example: there are 3 landlords renting for 11, 10 and 9 fictional units (to keep numbers si
by pmontra 11y ago
Let's assess the pure mathematical effectiveness of this cap with an example: there are 3 landlords renting for 11, 10 and 9 fictional units (to keep numbers simple). The average is 10. 11 is legal but can't increase, if 9 is lowered 11 isn't legal anymore. I'm sure this is taken into account and they'll revise the limit every few months or years. However a fourth landlord can enter with 11, increasing the average to 41/4. If everybody starts renting at the upper limit the average will move up closer and closer to 11.
This means that at the next check they'll be able to rent at 11+10% = 12.1, increasing the price by 10% per cycle (or they change the rule). For the tenant this is better than getting a +40% on renewal. For the landlord not much so. I suspect that if the rent price detaches too much from the sale value of the house landlords will start selling instead of renting. Big real estate companies get a chance to build up a large portfolio of houses when that happens.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoThought experiments are not statistical evidence.
- abandonliberty 11y agoA house is an income generating asset, selling the houses would cause both a drop in house value and increased investment in other sectors. I don't see a downside, other than in hot markets like Vancouver where the capital appreciation of properties is sufficiently high to not require renting them out in order to turn a profit.