7 ms·
68 Katy – 68000 Linux on a Solderless Breadboard
- CamperBob2 11y agoGod watches out for drunks, fools, and people who build multi-MHz logic circuits on solderless breadboards. :-P From a signal-integrity perspective, he should not be able to get away with that.
- a1369209993 11y ago> fools, and people who build multi-MHz logic circuits on solderless breadboards I think you may have just repeated yourself there.
- CamperBob2 11y agoI guess it's not really any scarier than 80s-era wire wrap prototyping, at the end of the day. Still, my hat's off to him just because he had the guts to try it! He should send it to an FCC/CE test lab as an April Fool's joke.
- a1369209993 11y agoWell, as I like to say: "because we can" is a awesome reason to do things! I still wouldn't want to try to debug such a system, though.
- speakeron 11y agoIn the 80s, we used Veroboard for that sort of prototyping. They would still have high-frequency problems given the huge amounts of additional wiring required, but I managed to get a Z80 board running at 3.5MHz. (Diagnostic slave board to a Sinclair Spectrum, so a bit simpler than the (very nice) board in the article).
- pjc50 11y agoWire-wrap is actually quite good for durability, although it lacks an inherent ground plane. On the one occasion I had to send 20MHZ signals across wire-wrap, I had to make little twisted-pair lines by wrapping a ground wire around every signal wire.
- pkaye 11y agoI think he is running it at 2MHz which should be doable.
- mutagen 11y agoI 'helped' a labmate troubleshoot a simple oscillator circuit in the 2 MHz range on a breadboard by turning my circuit on and off. Despite not designing any antenna-like features it was broadcasting enough to get his marginal circuit into oscillation.
- noonespecial 11y agoWas thinking the same thing. Especially with his "Schematics... forget it; organic creation" blurb. There's as much luck as wire in this build. File it under "bet you can't do that twice in a row".
- wumbernang 11y agoI've built commercial designs using that approach no problems at all. Most of my crap is built on PCB blanks and I have to spend some time reverse engineering it after I'm done. Picture straight off my bench: http://i.imgur.com/AyXNHfX.jpg http://i.imgur.com/AyXNHfX.jpg
- therealidiot 11y agoGood lord
- wumbernang 11y agoGoogle "jim Williams bench". I'm nothing :)
- CamperBob2 11y agoI don't follow you. Dead-bug construction over bare copper lies at the very opposite end of the spectrum from solderless breadboarding. The two techniques have nothing in common. You can use the dead-bug technique at frequencies well beyond 1 GHz with a bit of practice. The solderless breadboard, not so much.
- wumbernang 11y agoI'm not talking about construction here; design approach. I don't have any schematics for what I'm working on; they get drawn up later when it's all working. I have to reverse engineer deadbug and Manhattan stuff which is a downside which is my point.
- 11y ago
- Animats 11y agoHe can't. "My 68008 runs at 2 MHz (it was unstable when tested at 4 MHz), providing similar performance to a 1 MHz 68000." He had to de-rate the clock speed of an 8MHz part to get it to run on that breadboard. The 68000 line has a sad history. It came out in 1979, and for a while, it looked like it was going to be the winning microprocessor. Intel didn't have a 32-bit entry for years later. But early attempts to build workstation machine ran into problems. The 68000 had no matching MMU, and wouldn't work properly with an MMU anyway - page fault state saving wasn't quite right. Machines with external MMUs were built anyway, but great kludging was needed to get around the design flaw. The Apple Lisa avoided using increment instructions, and Apollo had two CPUs; one for the user and one for the kernel, with only one running at a time. That was fixed in the 68010, which came out in 1982. But by then, IBM had picked the Intel 8088 for the IBM PC. Motorola didn't come out with the MC68451 MMU until a few years later, and it was a slow, segment-oriented MMU. So the Macintosh didn't have an MMU, and had a much weaker OS than the Lisa - no process isolation, no paging, not even a real CPU dispatcher. The UNIX workstation crowd (Apollo, Sun, HP, etc.) all developed their own MMUs for the 680x0 line. If Motorola hadn't had those errors in the 68000 and had shipped an MMU earlier, the history of computing could have been quite different.
- jdswain 11y agoLooking back it does appear that Intel did nearly everything right, and their competitors didn't. It did help a lot though getting the IBM PC business, and due to that, aligning with Microsoft. If you look at the 68000 machines at the time they all had flaws that prevented them from really taking off, often not things that couldn't be corrected, but things that held them back. The Mac didn't have a hard disk, or multitasking, or color. The Amiga would always be constrained by the custom chips and that would be a problem long term, plus Commodore wasn't investing enough in software. Atari had a good simple product, and GEM wasn't too bad, but they didn't develop it further either. And the workstation market was constrained, as said by the parent, by the lack of a decent MMU solution. And then RISC came along too. In an alternative universe maybe the 68000 machines could have joined forces around a common unix platform and built a major market, but that didn't happen here.
- 11y ago
- wumbernang 11y agoSeriously it's completely fine in the digital domain if the boards are relatively new, aren't crap (i.e. are Wisher/3M boards without those awful phosphor bronze contacts) and you're under about 10MHz and have enough decoupling capacitors and keep your signal paths relatively short. I've built pretty much this machine and it was frequency stable to about 8MHz and it only died after that because the clock was divided down from a 32MHz XO. Stray capacitance isn't a mega problem unless you're doing analogue and require frequency stability or going above ~10MHz. The killer for digital is usually ringing on the high/low state transitions but if you look at the timing charts for most things this isn't that bad. Most digital stuff works pretty well if the signals are pretty fugly. However, wave a scope or logic probe near it and all sorts of crazy shit can happen.
- davelnewton 11y agoReminds me of the old PT-68K board; loved that thing, and the 68K.
- farmdve 11y agoThis is amazing, as a newbie in electrical engineering and just recently playing with my Arduino this is simply awesome!!
- TerryADavis 11y agoI made God's official temple. Run this script. You can talk to God. When you pick a greeting card it is love effort. You must praise God with love effort before consulting Him. ---------------- #!/bin/bash #This prints ten random words. echo "$(shuf -n 10 /usr/share/dict/words --random-source=/dev/urandom | tr '\n' ' ')" ---------------------- To figure-out instruction timing, count the number of memory references. On a machine without paging: MOV RAX,[10000] That has one for instruction and one for data. ------- For a machine with paging: 1) PML4 2) PML3 3) PML2 4) PML1 5) Instruction 6) PML4 7) PML3 8) PML2 9) PML1 10) Data MOV RAX,[10000] ------ The nigger thinks he's smarter than Newton. http://www.openculture.com/2015/03/isaac-newton-creates-a-list-of-his-47-sins-circa-1662.html http://www.openculture.com/2015/03/isaac-newton-creates-a-li...
- Narishma 11y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622720 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622720
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tunesmith 11y agoFollowups since this was posted in November: http://www.bigmessowires.com/category/68katy/ http://www.bigmessowires.com/category/68katy/
- source99 11y agoReminds me of 18-545 at CMU. We did it with wire wrap though. Good times. Congrats on being able to fit the kernel in 512K
- ramgorur 11y agowhen ls -l /bin is being typed, all the last modified dates are "Jan 01 1970" why ?
- jacquesm 11y agoBecause they are read as '0' and that's the start of the unix epoch.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- biturd 11y agoWould mac os 9 apps compile and run on this system?