2 ms·
@ ghshephard Your comment implies they're only paying for an implementation. To be sure, do you have a link to a resource analyzing the patents on ECC and show
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
@ ghshephard
Your comment implies they're only paying for an implementation. To be sure, do you have a link to a resource analyzing the patents on ECC and showing they don't apply to anything they (or we) use for ECC? That it's a moot issue in its entirety or mostly except for known cases? Otherwise, I'm going to guess that you're guessing like everyone else.
- ghshephard 11y agoI'm not sure why you are responding to me here, but don't put words in my mouth. Your question was, "If it's patent free, why are people paying for it as I linked to?" - there are other reasons to purchase a technology than just the patent. Let me spin it another way, and put the ball back in your court. Not that this proves anything, but has anyone (recently) purchased a license for ECC patented technology, that wasn't a license for a certicom specific implementation? Seriously, someone who is an expert in this field (if not the expert), has already made a pretty clear statement here on patent problems wth Ed25519: http://ed25519.cr.yp.to/software.html http://ed25519.cr.yp.to/software.html. As of 2015.06.11 "The authors have not been notified of any claims of patent problems wth Ed25519."
- nickpsecurity 11y agoPeople only get hit with patent suits for commercial use that I'm aware of. They wouldn't be as it's all free and they don't monetize it. A commercial product using it is where the risk is. I'm assessing that risk. Anyway, thanks for the link as he covers a lot of key patents and some prior art to use.