4 ms·
I haven't played a video game for more than a few minutes in over a decade, and I had no idea what "gamergate" was until I read the summary on Wikipedia and may
by pron 11y ago
I haven't played a video game for more than a few minutes in over a decade, and I had no idea what "gamergate" was until I read the summary on Wikipedia and maybe some article by a reputable news organization (I don't remember which), but isn't "everyone who's in the KKK is a racist" a much more apt comparison than "all Muslims are terrorists"?
As I gather from the Wikipedia entry, gamergate is a hate group, so by definition anyone who's a part of it is a bully. I mean, saying gamergate is for "journalistic integrity" is like saying the KKK is "anti crime" because they may have, on occasion, lynched people who actually performed crimes. But since the KKK is only anti crime if said crime was committed by a black person -- and then their reaction is not one of protest but of violence -- you can't say that the KKK's stance on crime is "important". Similarly, gamergate only happens to be enraged -- and violently so -- not about journalistic integrity in general (or even in video-games coverage), but only when they sense that integrity happens to coincide with the interests of women. They promote journalistic integrity just like the KKK fights crime -- namely they make up a conspiracy to fight, and may on occasion, by total chance, happen to be partly right (in their claims, not in their actions, of course).
Also, while most people are born into Islam (or convert to it because of some of its many ideals) people choose to join the KKK -- or gamergate -- only because they identify with a rather singular feeling: hate towards the movement's intended victims. One is not born a gamergater, and neither does one become a gamergater simply for believing that journalists should hold themselves to a higher standard.
What I don't understand is, while the KKK may not like or endorse the "hate group" designation, they are well aware that they're not really crime fighters. Are gamergaters confused about that point?
EDIT: While reading more about gamergate I came across the term SJW, which stands for Social Justice Warrior, which is something gamergaters are apparently against. How can a group of nerds be against social justice warriors? Are they against Batman? Do they hate Professor X?
- Zikes 11y agoGamergate is often compared to groups like the KKK, however I would invite you to review all of the replies and discussion resulting from my initial comment on the subject. I made mention of ethical failings regarding journalism in video games. I never purported to be a part of a movement, and have no significant history of harassment, hateful comments, or any personal hatred for anyone involved. But by bringing up the subject, I am immediately associated with that "group" and shouldered with the actions of anyone else who has ever expressed a similar opinion. I have an opinion, and it is important to me. I only ask that judgments of my character be based on my own words and actions.
- pron 11y agoYou wrote, and I quote, "GG isn't perfect, but their promotion of journalistic integrity is important". That is just like saying "The KKK isn't perfect, but their hardline stance against crime is important." Can you imagine anyone uttering those words and not being associated with racism? Gamergate, from what I gather, isn't a think tank or a political movement. They don't have "opinions". They harass people they hate and make up conspiracy theories to support their actions (though they may happen to be right about a fact or two -- I have no idea). Thus, you are not associated with them for expressing an opinion which they don't really share. You may, however, be associated with them for helping paint a run-of-the-mill hate-group made up of geekthugs as a "movement", which, while "not perfect" holds some "important" "opinions". I don't judge your character -- I don't know you -- but I think we can all fairly criticize your judgment in this particular discussion.
- kinghajj 11y ago"GamerGate" is an exonym applied to a group of people who were outraged over allegations made by a former lover of an independent game developer. Whether or not these accusations are true and regardless of the motivations behind those who created and promoted them, it's not difficult to understand why the outrage occurred. It wasn't helped that there appeared to be censorship during early discussions of the issue, though that was explained to be due to an automatic spam filter on /r/gaming. Some of those outraged people went on to do truly horrifying things (doxxing, threats, etc.); but, as nailer pointed out in another comment, so did some from the "anti-gg" crowd, though their acts were not highlighted. Like vdnkh pointed out, there is a stark double-standard of accountability to which the two sides are held. Further, the "GamerGate" crowd has been routinely generalized, and people are all too-happy to ascribe alternative motivations to their grievances (sexism) instead of listening to their actual statements. It reminds me a lot of how terrorists are portrayed--"they hate us for our freedom!", when really there's a larger geo-political structure that causes some to pursue violence. It's easy to get the public at large to dismiss an idea/movement through such means (manufactured consent.) Now, there probably are sexist feelings at the root of many of their members' concerns, but focusing just on that while ignoring the problems they point out--even if most are spurious/fictitious--is counter-productive. Engaging, open dialog is the best way to influence/change minds.
- pron 11y agoI'm sorry, but since I graduated from the seventh grade a long time ago, I find the drama behind this juvenile hate-group and their mortal enemies, the SJWs or whatever, utterly pathetic, yet I do recognize that actual grown-up hate groups may grow out of middle-school hate groups, so I need to point out a few things. Crowds -- either the baddies or the goodies -- aren't outraged by allegations of pre-marital impropriety. In fact, no one is really ever outraged by a scandal, let alone a sex scandal (unless it concerns Silvio Berlusconi) or "scandal" in this case. Whenever you see people outraged about any scandal -- be they sex-starved, sugar crazy gamergate nerd supervillains or buff, handsome, superhero SJWs -- they are simply using a "scandal" as an excuse for their agenda, whether that agenda is that of the gamergater Magneto or Professor X, the ultimate SJW. Finally, don't confuse civilized moderation with censorship, and please understand that all hate groups claim to have "grievances" (you really think the KKK doesn't?). Intelligent people don't listen to those grievances because they range from being blown-out-of-proportion, through conspiracy-theory-nuttiness to downright idiocies. Gamergaters are neither terrorists nor Marxists. They are not part of a larger geo-political structure, but from what I gather, they may be a part of a large group who can't get a date to the junior prom. They don't have an "idea", they're kids having a tantrum, and kids having a tantrum don't get "listened to"; they are told to shut up and grow up. Their "concerns" are exactly the same as the KKK's concerns over crime. If you however, are concerned over crime, I strongly suggest you don't listen to the KKK -- you should listen to the KKK only if you hate blacks. Similarly, if you have concerns over journalistic integrity, talk to some adults about it; there's no need to listen to some shrill kids.