5 ms·
This is so true, and even today with new designs you end up with overkill. A Cortex M0 (32 bit ARM system) with 128K of flash and 64K of RAM is 75 cents in quan
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
This is so true, and even today with new designs you end up with overkill. A Cortex M0 (32 bit ARM system) with 128K of flash and 64K of RAM is 75 cents in quantity. That means the processor complex is essentially "free" with respect to the cost of the other bits (sensors, actuators, communication over distance). The risk is that with all that "extra power" the programmer decides to use it creatively for something like "A built in web server to show you status of everything" and that "feature" requires you connect it to the wider network, and that "webserver" never gets patched, and now you have an HVAC system which becomes the exploit vector to get into a much bigger facility/network.
All because designing in a "limited" computer didn't make economic sense, and programmers couldn't help but use the extra CPU capacity that was available.
That is what makes IoT a challenge / bad-idea to a lot of people.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bliti 11y agoSpot on. Programmers in general are not well-versed in security. I don't mean you, the reader of this comment. But as a collective. The other people who write code through which you can pass buses full of black hats. Not you. Web applications with huge budgets get owned by common mistakes. And those web applications don't have access to anything but data. Imagine having all those same, eh, security issues, in devices that can interact with the real world. I really don't want my microwave to suddenly turn on and keep going for hours at time while I'm out of the house. This comment is purely fictional. IoT is perfect.
- gpvos 11y agoFnord.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 11y agoConstrained resources encourages simplicity by design. Use only whats necessary, no more, no less.
- icebraining 11y agoWell, "no less" is not always true. How many controllers exposing vulnerable interfaces are out there because encryption added too much overhead?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'd consider security, and the resources to enable it, necessary.
- icebraining 11y agoYes, and the constraints encouraged those developers to use less than necessary.
- schnable 11y agoIt seems insane to think that a programmer would just "decide" to build a feature like that. It would have to be decided by the product people, who probably think it's a good idea.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThat is exactly right. A product person who wants to sell this system wants as many bells and whistles as possible because, hey who knows what the one thing is that will push the customer over the edge into the "buy zone" right? So you end up with all sorts of stuff in there. In my experience it is rare to have a programmer who will push back on that request.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI've noticed the opposite thing. Most of the hardware around is built on the weakest specs that still let the thing run. Those various 10 cent savings on flash and μC tend to add up quickly when you go into mass production. But the primary problem, which is not limited to but obviously visible in IoT, is that companies ask themselves "what sells?" instead of "what is good and useful?". All that crap that is being created, with useless "features" that introduce security holes foster the fragmentation of the ecosystem, is pushed because someone out there figures out that people will buy it. But almost no one understands the implications of all these "features" so the buying decision they make is usually wrong and stupid. I wish someone cut out sales people from the design process. You should be able to get designers and engineers together, having them ask themselves what would be an optimal, actually useful smartwatch/smartfridge/smarttoilet/whatever and how to build it, and then tell sales people to figure out how to sell it. But no optimizing for better sellability.
- organsnyder 11y agoI know that salespeople can often be the source of bad decisions, but determining market fit is still vitally important. Who wants to build (or, more importantly, fund) something that no one wants?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI too have seen the intense penny pinching, here in California the soda bottler removed one thread from the tops of plastic bottles, it saves probably a fraction of a cent in plastic, but makes the detached retaining ring for the cap rub on your lips when drinking. That makes it uncomfortable to sip from those bottles. Such a huge price to pay in user dissatisfaction for such a small savings. Can't go this far though : > I wish someone cut out sales people from the design > process. ... no optimizing for better sellability. In my experience, actually doing things this way leads to less economic success for the product and eventually it gets outsold by a competitor without those restraints. And At FreeGate I told sales people "you have to sell what we have, not what we don't have" and still had them come back with complaints about how the competitor could install their box in a data center etc etc. Not a productive conversation (or fun for that matter). There does seem to be a minimally required feature set for selling things these days. "High Quality" isn't the compelling feature it once was.
- samstave 11y agoTotally off the top of my head, but: It seems like a service discovery system for IoT devices might be a good idea where the service discovery system is tracking what is actually allowed to run a particular service - like an HVAC system running embedded webserver. For example, imagine if the industry had it so that the HVAC system was to announce that it had the capability to be an embedded webserver for status - but it instead should check to see if there is a different host to where it should send its metrics. This way you could control what the core host is for said website - and have all systems in the community basically ask for direction on self-hosting or publishing...
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoYou have to not do that. Cycles you don't use cost absolutely nothing. Indeed, they may actually reduce jitter if you're careful ( they should not but that's another story ) . This is the ultimate YAGNI.