3 ms·
While we're on the subject, perhaps it's time to take another look at Hacker News's ban of gawker.com domains in submissions. While yes, there is a lot of link
by minimaxir 11y ago
While we're on the subject, perhaps it's time to take another look at Hacker News's ban of gawker.com domains in submissions.
While yes, there is a lot of linkbait trash, there are relevant original articles to tech (e.g. http://gawker.com/remember-brands-can-turn-your-dumb-tweets-into-embarra-1710409054 http://gawker.com/remember-brands-can-turn-your-dumb-tweets-...) that get caught by the filter. At the least, I haven't seen any of the former being submitted.
- tptacek 11y agoThere is an easy fix for that problem: write a short blog post summarizing the (rare) valuable Gawker story, and submit that.
- minimaxir 11y agoThen this violates Hacker News's rule of linking to a news story's original source. Thus the Catch-22.
- tptacek 11y agoNo. HN prefers the news story's original source, but does not have a "rule" against posting secondary or tertiary sources. Meanwhile, if the mods rewrite the link back to Gawker (unlikely), mission accomplished. Anyways: the site is better off with the blunt-force ban on Gawker articles. There might be occasional worthwhile things there, but most of the stuff that isn't worthwhile is poison.
- Shivetya 11y agois the list visible for sites not permitted?
- tptacek 11y agoNot a current one.
- MBlume 11y agoI had no idea such a ban existed and am pleasantly surprised
- whatok 11y agoIf you can find an article that has not been already linked here and is somehow enhanced by a Gawker "journalist" writing a two sentence summary on it... The original "articles" are few and far between.