7 ms·
What Broke the Magic Online Economy?
- brandnewlow 11y agoI've played online now and then for about 10 years. For me, the biggest difference was the addition of phantom events. Unlike normal online tournements, where you have to buy some packs to paticipate, with phantom events you just pay a price. In return you don't get to keep the cards you play with. For people just looking to play, not to compete or build a collection, phantom events make way more sense. I have to imagine their popularity has also depressed the secondary value of packs.
- thom 11y agoYeah, if they just had a flat monthly fee for infinite phantom drafts, I would love that. Although having played on beta servers, infinite would probably be the wrong number as everyone just drops at the first sign of trouble.
- lacker 11y agoMaybe infinite drafts + some ELO that people care about. Or Hearthstone style where you don't have to face the opponents you just drafted against.
- jpreiland 11y agoNot facing who you just drafted against would be absolutely horrible. Magic sets are designed with draft in mind, and the draft tournament structure takes advantage of the rotating aspect of the draft portion. When you see your 14 potential picks, you know that a number of them are coming back to you and you get to pick another one later. You also know that every card you don't pick is potentially going to be in one of your opponent's decks. Being aware of what's opened in a draft as well as what's being passed has an impact on how you pick (for example: tons of red cards keep going by - table isn't into red, so you can A) wheel red cards easier, and B) bank on not running into a hyper aggressive deck and build accordingly). If you were thrown into a match against someone who didn't draft at your table, they might have a deck that wasn't supported by the collective pool opened at your table and you'll be caught completely off guard.
- wlesieutre 11y agoIf there's a monthly fee, they can just penalize players who disconnect. The usual barrier to that is free games where if you penalize/ban somebody they'll just come back with a new account.
- Vraxx 11y agoI've actually taken the opportunity while the economy is "broken" to get into the online game versus the paper game. I've quite enjoyed being able to draft for about half the price it is on paper in order to get practice, as well as build a smallish online collection. Seemed like the perfect time to jump into the economy.
- CurtHagenlocher 11y ago"Again, I have no data to back this up, just a sense of this trend."
- danielvinson 11y agoThat statement just doesn't fit well with what is being said - what the author meant was something more like "my hypothesis is that constructed popularity goes down over time but since Wizards doesn't release data on this we cannot know for sure". This really should have been caught by the editor (cough Andy... cough) and clarified.
- dogecoinbase 11y agoYes, this is how a hypothesis is formed.
- brandnewlow 11y agoFor those interested in analysis with some actual data of the MTGO world, this site has a few folks who follow it rabidly: http://puremtgo.com/articles/state-program-june-12th-2015 http://puremtgo.com/articles/state-program-june-12th-2015
- gohrt 11y agoWhy do players think it's acceptable to have an "economy" for trading virtual gamepieces? Why don't they walk away and play game/culture that charges a flat fee or a time/usage-based subscription?
- imancit 11y agoIn short, because Magic is one of the best games ever designed, and this is the only sanctioned way to play the full game online. Magic online was created a long, long time ago before more modern concepts of game monetization (freemium / mtx based) were developed. It's ended up as something more akin to an online poker room than a gaming server.
- brandnewlow 11y agoI get why people think it's silly and so forth, but I can't agree more with "one of the best games ever designed." Richard Garfield gave the world something really tremendous with MtG
- Naga 11y agoI've tried other games that are similar to Magic, such as Hearthstone, but I always go back to Magic because there is nothing like it.
- bsder 11y agoHearthstone is very well designed for what it is--an online-only Magic the Gathering that is accessible in a casual way. I simply won't spend on Magic Online since I can't exit. In addition, why should I spend hundreds of dollars on something whose value can plunge drastically? If you have actual physical cards, you can sell them. Powerful modern cards hold their value reasonably well.
- whateverfor 11y agoYou can exit from MTGO pretty easily? There are automated bots that will buy your cards for tickets, and those same companies will give you cash for those tickets (95 cents per ticket right now, not a terrible rate).
- hansjorg 11y agoPlanet Money on NPR did a piece recently on how WotC avoided some of these issues and made the card game such a success twenty plus years ago. There's also some interesting anecdotes regarding the Hasbro buy out. http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/03/11/392381112/episode-609-the-curse-of-the-black-lotus http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/03/11/392381112/episo...
- cdr 11y agoThat was not well researched though, if at all - it's by complete outsiders with little actual knowledge of what happened. Even the person they talk to (Skaff Elias IIRC) gives them a dubious offhand anecdote. It's a Malcolm Gladwell level story.
- hansjorg 11y agoThe stories about the Hasbro buyout I was thinking of were actually from Peter Adkison's blog, read that just after hearing the NPR piece and got them mixed up: http://www.peteradkison.com/blog-entry-3-wizards-of-the-coast-equity-distributions-part-2/ http://www.peteradkison.com/blog-entry-3-wizards-of-the-coas...
- nosuchthing 11y agoThe whole concept of collectable cards feels like a scam, right alongside the freemium pay-for-virtual-clothing hustle.
- carapace 11y agoWhen all my friends got into MtG back in high school I said, "I'll play but I'm going to make my own cards. I don't want to buy them from the store." But no one would go for it. I never understood. I used to say, "But there are no actual wizards at Wizards of the Coast."
- Sone7 11y agocough cockatrice
- thaumasiotes 11y agoI know someone who prints out color images of the cards he wants to play with and sticks them into sleeves as inserts. It works fine. It's even easier and cheaper to insert a little strip of paper with a card name on it, though then you need to be familiar with what all the cards do.
- branchless 11y agoMy six year old came up with this idea for pokemon cards on his own this week. They are loving it - and so am I!
- spiritplumber 11y agoYeah, that was a thing for us too circa 1996. It ended with there being two groups of players: "Poor" players that printed cards and had access to the entire card catalog and could build insane cheese, and "rich" players who didn't and didn't. Then there were the my-dad-owns-a-textile-mill types who would learn a cheese from the print-it-yourselfers, spend millions of lire on cards, and replicate the cheese with the people who played with the official cards.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoI feel like there's a great MtGox joke to be made here, but it's not coming to me.
- alasdair_ 11y agoThe main reason the MTGO economy is broken is simple: MTGO is incredibly shoddily designed and coded. It crashes all the time and has so many memory leaks they still plague users ten years after it was built. All of the issues lead to a LOT of refunds, essentially doubling the product (tickets and cards) in circulation. Recently, the game moved over to "4.0" which was even worse than 3.0 which has, in part, exacerbated the problem. This actually has a knock on effect on the paper magic markets where card redemption (can turn digital cards into paper cards) has a big impact on prices. There are countless articles on MTGPrice.com about this.
- soup10 11y agoHearthstone.
- jvdh 11y agoThe article is using 'fancy' graphs, economic 101 and a long analysis to hide the fact that he is basing most of his theory on gut feeling. There are several points at which he states this himself, but fails to mention that these become crucial to the whole analysis.