3 ms·
We don't need the concept of privacy to be reinvented so much as we need the US to catch up with Europe on strong legal protections and active enforcement. The
by acdha 11y ago
We don't need the concept of privacy to be reinvented so much as we need the US to catch up with Europe on strong legal protections and active enforcement. The fear of tracking is driven by quite reasonable expectations that this data will be abused and mistakes impossible to correct with little recourse for the average person.
If, instead, there were limits on what could be shared and companies were credibly liable for misuse, breaches, etc. I think many people would be far less concerned with use of information.
> Your face, your voice, your fingerprint, your iris, all of these things cannot be spoofed and are uniquely yours and cannot be taken away from you.
Conversely, this illustrates how important it is to have massive penalties – on the scale of “you are out of business and managers cannot have a position of authority involving personal data for years” – for storing biometric data because there's no way to recover when it's compromised. This is particularly important when you realize that biometric data cannot be trusted over a network connection so there's no point in deploying biometric systems anyway because they can only be trusted when one entity has end-to-end control over the entire system.
What should be deployed is PKI which, unlike direct biometrics, can be made robust against compromises using a revocation mechanism. This also allows biometrics to be used safely because you could have an authenticator which uses biometrics which never leave the device and has no replay value for an attacker once a compromise has been discovered.
Consider the recent breach at the U.S. Office of Personnel Management. The attackers reportedly got everything listed on background and security clearance applications, which burns every common authentication system because the attacker could easily answer most “security” questions. Consider how much worse that would have been if biometrics were in common use and scans of fingerprints, voice or iris patterns, etc. were also available to the attacker.
- rewqfdsa 11y ago> we need the US to catch up with Europe Europe is on a path to technological stagnation and demographic collapse. There's a reason its economy is depressed, its electricity fantastically expensive, its people angry, its programmer wages depressed, and its startup scene anemic. Europeans refuse to embrace modern technology like genetic modification and nuclear power, much less allow the flourishing of information technology. They'd rather comfort themselves with their pseudoscience and their precautionary principle and their Luddite privacy regulations than join the rest of world in imagining something better. Europe is absolutely no model to emulate.
- noir_lord 11y agoAs a European this post made physically laugh out loud, bravo!.
- acdha 11y agoA more careful reader might notice that I was specifically referring to privacy. If you wanted to have a conversation about something else, preferably involving citations not from U.S. political blogs, this is not the place for it.
- rewqfdsa 11y agoIrrational and emotional European paranoia on privacy chills technological development. Look at all the silly cookie warning on the European web. Now imagine having to "warn" users before applying basic algorithms to data they willingly provide.
- task_queue 11y agoLet it be known that an entire continent's economy has been suffocated because of warning boxes on users' computer screens.
- pjc50 11y agoI don't mean to derail a rant with inconvenient facts, but 75% of France's power comes from nuclear power and they have the ITER fusion research facility.
- rewqfdsa 11y agoAnd a big segment of the French public loathes nuclear: http://www.seattlepi.com/business/energy/article/French-bill-seeks-to-boost-renewable-energy-cut-6286570.php http://www.seattlepi.com/business/energy/article/French-bill... The shortsighted and fearful German Greens are making that country shut down nuclear plants and switch to filty brown coal: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-04-14/coal-rises-vampire-like-as-german-utilities-seek-survival http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-04-14/coal-rises... ITER isn't getting nearly enough funding, and it took a fucking decade to decide on the place to build it. Europeans have the same fearful attitude toward GMOs.