6 ms·
You're completely ignoring the potential monetary damages. A plenty of financial systems use the internet. I've also heard of a couple of other businesses utili
by ryanlol 11y ago
You're completely ignoring the potential monetary damages. A plenty of financial systems use the internet. I've also heard of a couple of other businesses utilizing the internet.
"Shit happens" would've been applicable if this was solved in 5 minutes. Accidents like this are trivial to prevent with proper policies.
- pyvpx 11y agoI invite you read over the history of IRR and summaries of SO-BGP, S-BGP, PBGP, and MC-BGP.
- ryanlol 11y agoI'm very well aware, just because there's a history of people messing up doesn't mean the people that mess up shouldn't be held responsible.
- nowayback 11y agoIf they can't take something like this, they should not depend on public packet-switched networks. In many ways, "the internet" is a victim of it's own success - it works so well most of the time that people come to expect too much of it.
- michaelt 11y agoYou're completely ignoring the potential monetary damages. If there's a car accident that closes the road, it's frustrating for everyone involved. But if someone's crash means I'm late for a vital sales meeting and I lose a multi-million-dollar contract, I wouldn't blame them for my consequential losses.
- ryanlol 11y agoIf someone causes a car accident because of their gross negligence, they'll most likely face criminal charges.
- tomjen3 11y agoYou should do that though: it would allow us to know the complete cost of the accident so we can allocate the correct number of resources to preventing it.
- semi 11y agoShould the complete cost of the accident include monetary losses from people who had no plans for dealing with unexpected delays? Or to put it another way; Lets say you're driving across a bridge with your laptop in your car and you get hit causing you to drive through the rail and into the ocean. Should the 'complete cost of the accident' change based on whether or not you were smart enough to make backups?
- forgottenpass 11y agoYou're completely ignoring the potential monetary damages. A plenty of financial systems use the internet. I've also heard of a couple of other businesses utilizing the internet. So what you're telling me is that these financial systems' risk analyses didn't result in them mitigating this risk (1), but because things went pear-shaped now the government needs to step in? I was going to be unsympathetic to them, because in my field we have to analyze and then mitigate certain levels of risk. But I guess if your business is financial, bellyaching after the fact to the government is your mitigation. (1) different design, SLAs, making sure service providers already have those policies, acceptable and expected levels of downtime, whatever...
- bigiain 11y agoThere are "financial systems" who actually care enough about their comms network to build it themselves (Google for "High Frequency Trading in my backyard" for some great stories). Any "financial system" who uses "the internet" without acknowledging and accepting the risk of this sort of downtime should probably be considered incompetent. (Of course, there are probably many such institutions where the techs are currently saying "We warned you! But you refused to authorise the budget to mitigate this!" - who are now baying for blood from people who never signed up to provide 100% reliable networking for some cheapskate financial firm...)
- ryanlol 11y agoThere's also "financial systems" that cannot realistically operate on their own comms networks. Online banking, PayPal, Bitcoin...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]