4 ms·
Fuckups like this should result in criminal charges (and immediate depeering). DoS attacks are illegal in most countries and this is definitely gross negligence
by ryanlol 11y ago
Fuckups like this should result in criminal charges (and immediate depeering). DoS attacks are illegal in most countries and this is definitely gross negligence.
- alice715 11y agoShit happens. Not that it was intentional. Anyway, who cares about software stuff, nobody dies. Unlike in engineering sector where a negligence could result in injury or death; those could be charged.
- therealmarv 11y agoThis reminds me of arguments some people use in the EU against net neutrality... they want fast lanes for Industry 4.0, online emergency and self driving cars. Incredible thoughts... I know.
- laumars 11y agoThere's a big difference between accidentally breaking something and doing it intentionally. I think some people get too caught up on blaming individuals for accidents. Which I think stems from the culture of litigation and offsetting unforeseen costs. While there obviously should be processes in place to prevent accidents from happening, gross negligence aside I do also think we should stop hunting down individuals to compensate our own greed.
- ryanlol 11y agoPeople are usually still held responsible when they accidentally break things, especially if it's because of their own gross negligence. I don't think anyone is blaming individuals here, in most countries businesses can face criminal charges.
- laumars 11y agoThere hasn't actually been any crime committed though. Unless you want to turn miscoding config files into an international crime - in which case every single person who works in IT would be a criminal since we all error at some point in our careers (usually frequently, to be honest). Granted the scale here is greater than your usual sysadmin would have access to, but the nature of the error isn't any different.
- ryanlol 11y agoYou're completely ignoring the potential monetary damages. A plenty of financial systems use the internet. I've also heard of a couple of other businesses utilizing the internet. "Shit happens" would've been applicable if this was solved in 5 minutes. Accidents like this are trivial to prevent with proper policies.
- pyvpx 11y agoI invite you read over the history of IRR and summaries of SO-BGP, S-BGP, PBGP, and MC-BGP.
- ryanlol 11y agoI'm very well aware, just because there's a history of people messing up doesn't mean the people that mess up shouldn't be held responsible.
- AndrewDMcG 11y agoIt's actually interesting why this idea is so totally wrong. So Telecom Malaysia messed up a config, and Global Crossing accepted their updates automatically. Global Crossing didn't have to accept the bad update. They generally trust updates from other organisations that are generally trustworthy. They apply checks and restrictions proportionate to the risks involved. These mistakes happen rarely. If they were to happen more often, major operators would apply more checks and restrictions. If they were to stop happening, operators would apply less checks and restrictions, because they have a cost in manpower, complexity, and loss of flexibility. That's how the internet works. You could almost say that's what the internet is--the idea of being actively managed by people who know what they're doing and are not bound by exhaustive predefined policies is defining of how the internet came about and how it came to be dominant. If you want a network guaranteed to be resistant to this kind of f---up, build one. The internet is that network which does not work that way, which is flexible, expandable, mostly "good enough" but not ever designed for absolute reliability.
- ryanlol 11y agoThis isn't about how the internet works. This is someone messing up and breaking the internet. If I'm driving a car without paying attention to the road and kill a bunch of kids, that's my fault. If Telecom Malaysia pushes new configs without testing them and breaks the internet, that's their fault. Obviously these two things aren't even remotely comparable in seriousness, but it's clear that in both cases the people messing up should be held responsible.
- Robin_Message 11y agoExcuse me Mr Lol, but since it happened, it would appear that it in fact is how the internet works. If the postal service misdelivers some mail are there criminal charges? I would suggest resisting the urge to hit every problem and mistake in the world with the law hammer; it is rarely productive, and generally isn't how the world works.
- ryanlol 11y ago
- mentat 11y agoCriminal is what jurisdiction? You going to send a drone strike?
- ryanlol 11y agoReading comprehension. I never said what they did was criminal.
- mentat 11y ago> Fuckups like this should result in criminal charges Reading comprehension?
- ryanlol 11y agoI don't think you fully understand what "should" means here. I'm obviously not implying that the legal framework necessarily exists, but that it should. (And not for drone strikes ffs)
- mentat 11y agoInternational legal agreements for criminal charges are pretty limited (AFAIK IANAL). I guess I could see internet service disruption becoming subject to international law but it seems also to introduce another vector for abuse.