8 ms·
TTIP and CETA need to go away. The trade aspect isn't terrible. Everything else is. Treaties shouldn't be negotiated in private and withheld from scrutiny. Not
by Nursie 11y ago
TTIP and CETA need to go away. The trade aspect isn't terrible. Everything else is.
Treaties shouldn't be negotiated in private and withheld from scrutiny. Not anywhere claiming to be democratic.
ISDS is just wrong. TTIP opens the way for companies to use a supranational, binding court of arbitration to sue any country that impacts future profits. If a country, for instance, changed environmental protections, worker rights, food safety standards, whatever, they can be sued for large sums.
It's anti democratic and it hands sovereignty over to business interests. It's being pushed by bureaucrats and lobbyists who have tried their damnedest to keep it out of the light. To the extent that even MEPs have had to sign an NDA before being allowed to set eyes on a draft (we know this because one or two broke the NDAs)
https://stop-ttip.org https://stop-ttip.org
- pathy 11y agoYou are aware that ISDS already exist and have been a part of trade deals for at least 20 years? TTIP may extend these rights, and it certainly should be negotiated in such a secretive way, but the ISDS provisions are nothing particularly new. ISDS exist because national courts are not always unbiased, and may unduly favour the host nation.
- amirmc 11y ago> "ISDS exist because national courts are not always unbiased, and may unduly favour the host nation." As opposed to favouring ... what, exactly?
- gpvos 11y ago> You are aware that ISDS already exist and have been a part of trade deals for at least 20 years? Yes, I recently learned that, too. I find it shocking. I can understand it somewhat when dealing with underdeveloped and corrupt countries, but even then I'm not sure it would be the best way. But most countries involved in this treaty have a well-functioning and reasonably fair court system. A secretive arbitration system is no improvement.
- rbehrends 11y ago> You are aware that ISDS already exist and have been a part of trade deals for at least 20 years? Yes, and it has created its share of problems already. Which is exactly why a lot of people are concerned; i.e. because it is known to not just be a hypothetical issue.
- Nursie 11y agoI am aware that such things exist already, yes, and I disagree with their existence at all. Extending their reach, as you may gather, is not something I'm in favour of. I don't really care why ISDS exist, it's a dilution of democracy and national sovereignty.
- lordfoom 11y agoI live in South Africa, which is currently renegotiating or terminating all such treaties because we've discovered first hand that it allows corporations to evade or set government policy. Just because it isn't new doesn't mean we should shrug and accept it.
- rylee 11y ago>and it certainly should be negotiated in such a secretive way But why?
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoThe problem with TTIP in my opinion is, that those that pull the strings from the background are the big corporations and those that act for the interests of the big money. The results can be seen for example in the US/Mexico treaty that resulted in lower standards (eg. environmental, health, worker welfare, ...) and lower wages on both sides of the border.
- jcfrei 11y agoI am also very concerned about the implications of ISDS for democracies. However I would not argue that TTIP should be abolished entirely because of it. Studies expect an annual increase in GDP growth of about half a percent - which doesn't seem like much considering the historical GDP growth, but GDP growth is expected to be much weaker in the western hemisphere than in the past - so we shouldn't outright dismiss half a percent as too little. Furthermore, as mentioned by other commentators, ISDS is already a part of many treaties. However one fundamental flaw - which is a part of many of the previous treaties involving ISDS - was that the conditions required for allowing corporations to sue governments were very loosely defined: The treaties usually allow corporations to sue governments if any kind of "indirect expropriation" occurs - From a paper on CETA: "Indirect expropriation can only occur when the investor is substantially deprived of the fundamental attributes of property such as the right to use, enjoy and dispose of its investment; " (1) This clause allows corporations to sue against a very broad range of policy measures. The TTIP supposedly contains a more detailed outline under what circumstances corporations can sue (2): • We have reaffirmed the right to regulate. In CETA we have made clear in the preamble of the agreement that the EU and Canada preserve their right to regulate and to achieve legitimate policy objectives, such as public health, safety, environment, public morals and the promotion and protection of cultural diversity. • We have defined key concepts like “fair and equitable treatment” and “indirect expropriation”, in order to prevent abuse. For the first time, CETA provides a definition of these terms. "Fair and equitable treatment" is defined through a clear, closed text which defines precisely the content of the standard without leaving unwelcome discretion to arbitrators. Moreover, detailed language has been agreed upon to clarify what constitutes indirect expropriation, particularly excluding claims against legitimate public policy measures. As it so often happens during negotiations, the fundamental decisions are made when definitions are being defined. Only if the policy makers in the US and EU can agree on a very specific definition of "indirect expropriation" that is not vulnerable to abuses by corporate lawyers, then we can hope for a good long term outcome for the consumer. And if these requirements are enforced in the arbitration courts, then the ISDS in my opinion becomes a much more sensible part of the treaty. However due to the secrecy involved in the current negotiations, I don't know which exact definitions are currently part of the treaty. (1) http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2013/november/tradoc_151918.pdf http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2013/november/tradoc_1... (2) http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2015/may/tradoc_153408.PDF http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2015/may/tradoc_153408...
- a3n 11y ago> It's anti democratic and it hands sovereignty over to business interests. I wouldn't like that, but playing the devil's inquirer, why shouldn't business interests hold sovereignty? And what's to stop them?
- Nursie 11y ago>> why shouldn't business interests hold sovereignty? Society is allegedly organised by the people, for the people. Businesses are allowed to exist and governed by laws set up with the benefit of the society in mind. They are limited by inconvenient things like safety standards, pollution restrictions etc etc. The pure profit motive with which businesses operate (and with which some will advocate they are required by law and shareholders to operate) are necessarily on conflict with these as they add cost. If these protections are removed then we all lose out, including businesses, as they have to operate in a society wracked with illness from pollution, or from accidents (in my trivial example). So it's not in anyone's interest to let business set all the rules. Not even in the interests of business. >> And what's to stop them? Now that is a much more interesting question...
- enraged_camel 11y ago>>Society is allegedly organised by the people, for the people. And Citizens United ruling says corporations are people, so what's the problem here? ;)
- johneth 11y ago> And Citizens United ruling says corporations are people In the United States.
- meatysnapper 11y agoIn Europe corporations are only 3/5 of a person.
- stsp 11y ago> why shouldn't business interests hold sovereignty? One reason is that humans need affordable and clean water to drink. ISDS cases have caused water quality and price regulations to be disregarded in Germany and Argentina. Source: http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/jun/10/obscure-legal-system-lets-corportations-sue-states-ttip-icsid http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/jun/10/obscure-lega...
- fweespeech 11y agoISDS isn't wrong. ISDS is a necessary part of trade treaties to balance the scales and prevent Country Y from screwing Country Z because Country Z exports 90% of substance N while Country Y wants people to use domestic substitute M. That said, the problem with ISDS in several treaties in the past 20 years is how it has been employed [e.g. Cigarette companies using in attempts to force labeling changes and/or threatening small countries with ISDS cases. ] It really just needs a "If the company who pursues the suit loses, they pay Costs+$X" provision to strongly discourage ISDS suits that are frivolous and to have a public health/safety exception.
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoIn theory, you might be right. In practice it is absolute different. Those courts where mostly installed in the past to protect the interests of bigger countries against smaller countries. Of course, in some cases it was necessary, but in practice it was used to protect the interests of big corporations against the smaller countries. And that is the reason, we got such frivolous acting of corporations. They just knew, that the courts acted on their side. An exception in direction "health/safety" will not help either, since bad countries will label everything "health/safety" further on and the other way around there are still enough possibilities for frivolous movements of corporations. Secret courts will never be the solution!
- fweespeech 11y ago> Secret courts will never be the solution! They aren't secret and the fact you'd make that claim pretty much completely invalidates your opinion. https://ustr.gov/about-us/policy-offices/press-office/fact-sheets/2015/march/investor-state-dispute-settlement-isds https://ustr.gov/about-us/policy-offices/press-office/fact-s... > Full transparency in cases. Governments must make all pleadings, briefs, transcripts, decisions, and awards in ISDS cases publicly available, as well as open ISDS hearings to the public. One key objective of these provisions is to allow governments that are party to the agreement, as well as the public at large, to carefully monitor pending proceedings and more effectively make decisions about whether to intervene. > Public participation in cases. Tribunals have the clear authority to accept amicus curiae submissions. In U.S. cases, amicus briefs have been submitted by a variety of NGOs, including the Sierra Club, Friends of the Earth, and Center for International Environmental Law. (Documents in all investor-State cases filed against the United States are available on the State Department website.)