7 ms·
I don't even know how Oracle is still the juggernaut that they are. A $10,000 dollar computer running postgres can serve a ridiculous amount of queries. I sus
by CyberDildonics 11y ago
I don't even know how Oracle is still the juggernaut that they are. A $10,000 dollar computer running postgres can serve a ridiculous amount of queries.
I suspect the general idea is to spend huge amount of money to run incredibly inefficient SQL queries.
- hkmurakami 11y ago>I don't even know how Oracle is still the juggernaut that they are. Their existing massive install base, aggressive salesforce, and being perceived as a "safe" choice by customers is a strong position to be in.
- bradleyankrom 11y agoThat, and enterprise-grade product support is often a requirement.
- kyllo 11y agoThis. Who is going to sign a Service Level Agreement for your postgres install? Support contracts are super important for enterprise.
- alex_anglin 11y agoEnterpriseDB? http://www.enterprisedb.com/ba/license-support-services-v3-0 http://www.enterprisedb.com/ba/license-support-services-v3-0
- dagw 11y agoThe drive time from the nearest EnterpriseDB office to my office is at least 12 hours (and that is probably quite a bit below the median). To the nearest Oracle office it's a 15 minute walk. That is probably going to have some effect on the call out time for technicians.
- tallanvor 11y agoThat's a good first step, but that's not enough for many companies. If you're an enterprise customer with IBM, Oracle, or Microsoft, you know that you can have someone onsite within 24 hours if you have a critical failure, sometimes even sooner. You know that you can have people engaged 24/7 for as long as it takes to get you back up and running and you'll have not just technical people, but also incident managers who will keep you updated and help the engineers locate additional resources. They'll have someone sit in a conference bridge around the clock if you want, ready to provide updates. Enterprises are also thinking about long time spans. With IBM, Microsoft, Oracle, Redhat, and others, they generally guarantee at least 10 years of support for their products, plus the ability for custom agreements that go beyond their normal support dates. Offering 3+2 is a good start, but that's not long enough. Remember, many (probably most) banks still have applications written in COBOL running. Don't get me wrong, I think everyone should look at all the available options - free and paid. At the end of the day, though, there are a lot of projects where the risks and expected application lifecycle pretty much mandate the level of support you only get from the big companies.
- jlarocco 11y agoIt doesn't hurt that their database is actually really good.
- hendzen 11y agoCan Postgres do distributed transactions? Oracle can.
- Sanddancer 11y agoYes. Federated tables was added in Postgres 9.3.
- chrismarlow9 11y agoSo much legacy still runs on it. I've seen many projects at the top of very very large companies (think telcos) that still use Oracle DB. The cost to upgrade these systems with full end to end testing is not worth the investment. Every system I've seen that has this setup is extremely archaic in every way. We're talking java applets in the browser to show a form where you choose options that compose a query in the background and every option you would want is in the interface, however there is no direct query access. Imagine creating a UI that represents everything you can possibly do in a sql query, building it in a java applet, and powering it with a database that costs a buttload of money. Also oracle has a very large reach with salesforce so I've seen many former employees pitch oracle products heavily. Seems like once you work there you're part of the forever cult of ellison.
- rodgerd 11y ago> Seems like once you work there you're part of the forever cult of Ellison. Not just working at Oracle. Once Oracle bought Sun our Oracle DBAs started relentlessly agitating for us to buy SPARC servers because they were now the best, obviously, and a failure to use them meant we clearly were doing it wrong.
- chrismarlow9 11y agoI can understand why. They specialize in a very niche product and their entire worth to the tech industry is based on the adoption of that product. I get it, but I dont like it.
- donw 11y agoA number of reasons that form an important lesson in sales at the enterprise level: 1. Oracle does provide value. They have clustering and high-availability offerings that Postgres just can't touch, and those come with service and support personnel as part of the contract. A one-stop solution is a powerful sales pitch. 2. They have a massive existing install base within the Fortune 500, which spend amounts of money that the average hacker just can't grasp. Somebody that I know very recently worked on an enterprise project to create more-or-less a web page that had a $1,000,000 budget. Oracle is not asking for unreasonable amounts of money, by enterprise standards. 3. Companies value safety over risk, and Oracle has a long track record at the executive level of providing safety. The mindset goes something like: Postgres might be good enough for Imgur or Joe Bob's Bait Shack And Social Network, but neither of those is a bank, healthcare provider, or an entity capable of ordering an air strike. Oracle is telling the story their customers want to hear. 4. Because Oracle has such a large install base and so many success stories at the enterprise level, they are one of a very few number of default choices that an enterprise will make. They have spent decades building up sales momentum. Business decisions usually have very little do to with the underlaying technology.
- chatmasta 11y ago> Companies value safety over risk Yes. In the case of a database, "safety" is safety from downtime, data loss, data theft. So companies want a database that is fault tolerant and secure. > Postgres might be good enough for Imgur or Joe Bob's Bait Shack And Social Network, but neither of those is a bank, healthcare provider, or an entity capable of ordering an air strike. Banks and healthcare providers strike me as far more insecure than tech companies, and especially more insecure than the large computing platforms like EC2, Google Cloud, etc. Any cloud can host a postgres database, and many of them offer database-specific services. Oracle is competing not just with Postgres, but with literally every other database offering, many from leading tech companies. The cloud extracts value by utility billing a large customer base. Oracle extracts value by overbilling a small customer base. Which model seems more sustainable? Eventually EC2, Google Cloud, etc will overtake Oracle completely. Maybe if Oracle is lucky they can provide the overpriced consultants to manage their client's EC2 boxes.
- toyg 11y ago> the general idea is ... to choose an established vendor with a big name and large resources, so that you won't get fired if things don't work out. Even if your project goes down in flames, you can blame the vendor, snatch a "compensation" discount or freebie on some other license renewal, and you'll be fine. Nobody in the enterprise space will ever get fired for choosing IBM, Oracle, Microsoft or SAP.
- tl 11y agoThe handful of companies that I've dealt with using Oracle bought into a product that Oracle sells (like payroll) that runs on an Oracle database (obviously). Oracle convinces them to pay for way more than they need for that application and in-house development ends up being done using Oracle rather than MySQL, SQL Server, etc...
- Spooky23 11y agoThey sell solutions to business problems at the CEO/COO/CFO level. The database as outrageous as it is, is just a sideshow. I think New York spent something like $40M for a general ledger system. There is ridiculous amounts of money in these projects.
- parasubvert 11y ago$40m is quite affordable. I've seen not super complicated SAP implementations of GL and FICA hit $100m+... Let's not forget telecom billing systems where Amdocs easily charges $200m and up in customization. What is this money spent on? Well, if you consider knowledge a scarce resource.... Capital is a poor substitute but all you've got when you're clueless.
- rdtsc 11y agoSimple -- the crowd who picks and buys Oracle doesn't hang out on HN. So if you are on HN then you think everyone runs Docker, Kubernetes, RethinkDB, Go, and something...something Reactive.
- travjones 11y agoThis is spot on. "Enterprise" dev life is way different than HN dev life.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deciplex 11y agoPicks and buys, perhaps, but some of us who have to use the stuff are here :-)
- saiya-jin 11y agoindeed, we are! now back to work...
- jacquesm 11y agoExactly. There is a huge world of professional IT that HN is almost blind to. Though I'd wager that there is someone on HN from just about every niche in IT.
- pjmlp 11y agoWe do hang around here, but technologies are adopted on "business value" not "geek factor".
- thrillgore 11y ago.gov. PeopleSoft was such a windfall for them entirely because of this.
- noonespecial 11y agoYou don't pay Oracle for a database. You pay them for a kind of lawsuit insurance policy that just happens to come with a database. It looks like they sell software but I think it closer to the truth to say that they are an insurance company.
- davidgerard 11y agoStraddling the fine line between "insurance company" and "protection racket".
- ams6110 11y agoIf you really need Oracle, no open source products can replace it. That said, there are a lot of people who buy Oracle but don't actually need it: they just use it as a fairly simple-minded CRUD database. That is just wasting money.
- hboon 11y agoBesides purely political and technical reasons, the more you move towards enterprise software, the more the database will need to be required to work with other enterprise software. E.g. if you run data warehousing, you might find that the solution you picked only supports Oracle DB.
- pierre 11y agoFor what I see in the entreprise world they play it like that : 1. lock entreprise in a 5 year contract. 2. when contract is about to expire lower prices to match wathever other companies are offering for the next 5 years + migration cost. 3. Win the deal as you offer the best value for the money : same ammount + no risk. 4. repeat This is the main reason why you can see companies running on mainframe in 2015.
- radicalbyte 11y ago5. threaten a compliancy audit unless they re-sign.
- vetinari 11y ago5a. fine, go for it. However, any cost for compliance audit we will add to your solutions' TCO, when comparing competitive offers.
- dagw 11y agoThere are a lot of large third party enterprise applications that only support Oracle. I know several places that I deal with that are still on Oracle, not because replacing Oracle with Postgres is particularly hard per se. but because replacing everything that talks to the Oracle database is too hard.
- vidarh 11y agoFor starters, consider that Oracle does not just sell the Oracle RDBS but a huge range of other enterprise software.
- yxhuvud 11y agoThey do what they always have done - they buy companies that are behind their prime time and then provide legacy support for their systems. That is their bread and butter. If sales go down? Buy some more faded companies and watch sales improve again. Queries per second is simply not a relevant question.