3 ms·
Fixing HN: How to take away the incentive for irrelevant replies.
Currently there is an incentive for placing a comment as a reply to a highly ranked comment even if it is irrelevant to that comment (but still relevant to the submission).
One way to fix this would be to allow people to vote on making a comment be a child of the submission. If a certain threshold is reached in the voting, not only would this be done but the comment would be downvoted as well to discourage people from doing this in the future.
- brk 17y agoSounds like a neat idea. You should download the HN source and implement it.
- amichail 17y agoWhy? This is something that PG could implement rather easily if he wanted to.
- cwan 17y agoWhy would this be necessary? Already, the incentive to do this is reduced because new comments pop up to the top based on some type of vote/time decay function (he accelerated this already right after he tried not showing the number of votes not so long ago if I recall). Doing this would seem to add complexity to a system of voting that seems pretty elegant?
- amichail 17y agoYou might still think your comment will be highly visible for longer as a reply to a highly upvoted comment.