7 ms·
The Climate Science Isn't Settled
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- alexgartrell 17y agoI'm happy that the CRU hack has introduced all of this healthy skepticism back into the debate. Any time people are so sensationalist about anything, there should be a lot of concern.
- dasil003 17y agoThe skepticism is good, but my concern is that the issue has become so politicized, and people are so emotionally invested in the outcomes, that true objectivity is nearly impossible. Mix in natural variations and the fact that the timescales are not intuitively understood by most people, and I really doubt we'll be able to save ourselves from massive global catastrophe if that's the way this ends up going. In my mind, the real problem is that we do not account for the value of natural resources and the environment in our economics. That, combined with a rabid consumerist mentality is rapidly leading us down a rode of polluted resource-exhaustion.
- lukifer 17y ago> In my mind, the real problem is that we do not account for the value of natural resources and the environment in our economics. Couldn't agree more. We're not going to get anywhere by turning the issue into a polemic "debate". We should be focusing on central tenets so obvious they're impossible to disagree with: wealth is derived from the underlying ecosystem of nature, and securing the long-term health of that system is in everyone's best interest. "A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in."
- vannevar 17y agoWhereas the continued trumped up 'debate' over AGW demonstrates that our society is full of wealthy old men quite willing to sacrifice the distant future for their own profit today. There is no scientific debate here, only the appearance of one. And in the end, that's all those corrupt old men need.
- m_eiman 17y agoThere's a difference between skepticism and paranoid conspiracy theories, though. And I've had more than enough of the latter.
- cwan 17y agoAre you saying that you think this article is an example of "paranoid conspiracy theories"? I'm sympathetic and partial to the view that AGW is probable but I'm not married to the view. I also question the policy prescriptions based on the underlying science given the costs. It strikes me as somewhat arrogant and insulting though when others ask seemingly legitimate questions, "scientists" and policy advocates attempt to crush those who ask them instead of at least attempting to make a reasoned response. Immediately they label these people as "deniers" / "skeptics" or even paranoid. Now we learn that one of the leading climate institutes (not just some university in the UK) didn't keep/destroyed original data sets and even a number of their defenders are calling for heads to roll (e.g. George Monbiot). From TierneyLab @ the NYT (http://tierneylab.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/30/hacking-the-climate-debate/ http://tierneylab.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/30/hacking-the-c...): "I’ve long thought that the biggest danger in climate research is the temptation for scientists to lose their skepticism and go along with the “consensus” about global warming. That’s partly because it’s easy for everyone to get caught up in “informational cascades”, and partly because there are so many psychic and financial rewards rewards for working on a problem that seems to be a crisis. We all like to think that our work is vitally useful in solving a major social problem — and the more major the problem seems, the more money society is liable to spend on it. "I’m not trying to suggest that climate change isn’t a real threat, or that scientists are deliberately hyping it. But when they look at evidence of the threat, they may be subject to the confirmation bias — seeing trends that accord with their preconceptions and desires. Given the huge stakes in this debate — the trillions of dollars that might be spent to reduce greenhouse emissions — it’s important to keep taking skeptical looks at the data. How open do you think climate scientists are to skeptical views, and to letting outsiders double-check their data and calculations?"
- m_eiman 17y agoAre you saying that you think this article is an example of "paranoid conspiracy theories"? No, I didn't read the article. But lately there have been far too many items on the HN front page that are nothing more than conspiracy theory ramblings, and with comments to match. There -have- been a few with reasonable takes on the scandal, but most are just... bleh. That so many, in my opinion, stupid items end up on the front page annoys me for two reasons: 1) they're not "hacker" (and not business either) and obscure real content, and 2) it lowers my respect for the HN community.
- maukdaddy 17y agoOK these anti-climate articles are getting really lame. This is a fucking opinion piece from one of the most conservative papers in the US. Why do so many hackers/HN types seem to be skeptics? I would have thought of all people, hackers/entrepreneurs would be forward-thinking and realistic about what is happening to our environment!
- amalcon 17y agoSkepticism is a good thing in general. It happens to be a bit unfounded in this case, but you wouldn't know it the way things are being presented.
- skipwalker 17y agoConsidering the credentials of the author and the arguments presented, I don't understand how you say the skepticism is unfounded, or even a "bit" unfounded.
- eli 17y agoThere are several very well-credentialed members of the 9/11 Truth movement. Sure, their theories still fly in the face of overwhelming evidence and the great majority of experts in terrorism, building demolition, etc., but there they are. I see a pretty strong parallel between 9/11 truthers and global warming deniers.
- amalcon 17y agoThey are many of the same arguments we see everywhere else. Most of them are true-but-irrelevant (the 2% number given early in the article is essentially meaningless, as it's a percentage of one component of a derivative in a complex system). He's at least smart enough to leave out transparent falsehood. The basic problem is that the Wall Street Journal is a newspaper. You can't address scientific questions in a newspaper. You just can't. It's a tightly-controlled broadcast medium, in which all arguments must be kept simple enough for the average reader to understand without being a professional in a related field. All three of those factors (control, broadcast, simplicity) actively work against science. What scientists need to do is find ways to address these kinds of oversimplifications in ways that the average reader can understand. It's hard, yes, but someone's going to need to do it if the public discourse is ever going to get onto the right track.
- Readmore 17y agoI think it's important to look at both sides of the debate, especially when it appears one side or the other has been fudging data for years. But it's also important to realize that even if Climate Change isn't man made pollution still is and we need to do our best to reduce it. Global Warming has been the specter hanging over our heads for the last decade telling us to clean up our act but we need to start stressing the importance of pollution cleanup and recycling outside of the climate change debate as it is hugely important in its own right.
- CamperBob 17y agoBut it's also important to realize that even if Climate Change isn't man made pollution still is and we need to do our best to reduce it. It's not that simple. "Doing our best" to reduce pollution is a process that carries staggering costs of its own. It is not realistic to achieve a pollution-free lifestyle across all segments of humanity, so we're going to have to decide where the lines are drawn. That, regrettably, is always going to be a political process, and not a scientific one.
- cema 17y agoClimate change, pollution, and global warming are all different issues. Should not be confused.
- Readmore 17y agoReally? It isn't pollution that is the supposed cause of man-made Global Warming? I agree that pollution is a very general term that encompasses things which don't 'contribute' to Global Warming but saying that Pollution and Global Warming are different issues is misleading. You may have different definitions for Global Warming vs. Climate Change but I have heard them used interchangeably, if there is a difference I'd like to know what it is.
- cema 17y ago[Sorry, could not answer earlier.] 1. Pollution is listed as one of the sources of the (alleged) artificial global warming, but not the only one. 2. Pollution and global warming may be related but they are different issues. For example, even if it turns out that global warming is not happening or is not a problem, pollution will remain a big deal and will have to be taken care of. 3. They are sometimes used interchangeably but this is a logical error (if not worse) and should be avoided.
- poutine 17y agoThe climate is an enormously complex thing with so many variables that it's difficult to analyze. If you do not believe the claims for Anthropogenic Global Warming (AGW) I suggest you consider the Precautionary Principle: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precautionary_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precautionary_principle In the context of the environment it essentially states that if there is a reasonable chance that AGW can be true then since the risks are so great we must take action as if it were true. This is what leads me, a hard core skeptic (and trained but very long ago lapsed climatologist) to support reductions in carbon dioxide emissions. We can not afford to be wrong.
- Dove 17y agoAre you also a fan of Pascal's Wager? I personally do not find persuasive the idea that decisions involving high stakes should warrant an approach which embraces risk management over skepticism. All things in proper order. It all depends on the probabilities you assign things. If Traditional Christianity has a 50% chance of being true, then of course the risk mitigation of heaven and hell dominate decision making. But I should like a better assessment of the odds before entering risk management mode. If the odds are near zero, I shall ignore the claim--however horrid the hell or enticing the heaven. So with AGW. Perhaps the doomsday is quite terrible (though even this does not seem obvious to me). I should like to see sound evidence that results in--at a minimum--clear odds before I am willing to worry about it. After all, as with Pascal, I may have other doomsdays to worry about. Perhaps the real doomsday event is a killer asteroid, and nothing matters except a relentless pursuit of technology aimed at a robust presence in space. If that were the case, retarding industry out of a concern for your bogeyman might actually be the cause of doom. One cannot worry about every street preacher who claims the end is near.
- poutine 17y agoNo, Pascal's Wager is foolish since you could not possibly select the correct god from the myriad of gods available (Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, etc) given that belief is mutually exclusive. At any rate it's not the same thing. The precautionary principle is an insurance sale, not some metaphysical nonsense. And you're being unfair about your characterization of Global Warming. It is just not any doomsday scenario. There's enough reputable scientists getting their panties in a knot that it should be cause for concern.
- DaniFong 17y agoThanks, I appreciate this article, despite my being essentially convinced that it's important to do something significant to reduce carbon emissions. The fact of the matter is that the climate science isn't settled. It's a shame that the nuisances of this have been glossed over for the purpose of the public and policy makers.
- febeling 17y agoWhy have carbon emmissions to be reduced, unless climate warrants it? The question is: of a dollar budget, how much should go into reducing emmissions?, and how much should be spent to cure cancer, bring education to Africa, and so on. There are rarely that absolute problems which justify any cost for a solution.
- DaniFong 17y agoI am convinced that the climate does warrant it. I just don't think the science is a closed book. There are other reasons to stop the burning of coal, for example: respiratory illness.
- baix 17y ago"Climate change is real enough, with enough backing observations and theory, to run with the assumption that it is most likely true - but probably more complex than we realize right now." From: http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/dear-science/Content?oid=2820629 http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/dear-science/Content?oid=...