4 ms·
I think a major problem is that much of computer science is not interesting. And indeed, almost all jobs that you get after graduation are not interesting eith
by amichail 17y ago
I think a major problem is that much of computer science is not interesting. And indeed, almost all jobs that you get after graduation are not interesting either.
It's too much like a "pen science" -- focusing too much on implementation and not enough on application. Imagine a science where students learn to write as quickly as possible with a pen and to fill the page with as much writing as possible. Who would want to get a "pen degree"?
The fact that many men want to major in CS reflects poorly on men.
The CS curriculum needs to be redesigned to be more applications-oriented and the major needs to be renamed to reflect that change.
- pgbovine 17y agoi haven't RTFA yet, but i'd be interested in seeing whether the same gender gap exists in other countries; from talking with friends who grew up in places like Eastern Europe, it seems like it wasn't as 'nerdy' for women to like engineering, math, or computers, so more talented women got into the field in college and as a career
- bct 17y agoMalaysia has much higher proportions of women in Computer Science (~50%). It's almost as if it's purely a cultural and social issue...
- rick888 17y ago"haven't RTFA yet, but i'd be interested in seeing whether the same gender gap exists in other countries; from talking with friends who grew up in places like Eastern Europe, it seems like it wasn't as 'nerdy' for women to like engineering, math, or computers, so more talented women got into the field in college and as a career" This is a very interesting point. When I was in college, many of my 300 level or higher CS classes had more women than men. The women were either from China, Taiwan, Japan, or India. I rarely ever saw an American woman in any of these classes.
- shaddi 17y agoMuch of computer science may not be interesting to /you/, but that doesn't mean it's not interesting generally. I am sure there are lots of things you find interesting that wouldn't appeal to others.
- amalcon 17y agoWhere is CS taught like that? My understanding is that it's usually taught more like a math.
- amichail 17y agoMuch of CS is concerned with time and space efficiency of programs. Hence the comparison to speed and compactness of writing in pen science.
- amalcon 17y agoThat's not a very good comparison, though, because the person isn't usually carrying out the algorithm. Every engineering discipline is concerned with cost containment (energy-efficient appliances, bridges that require minimal repair, satellites with as little mass as possible). This is what time and space efficiency are for computer programs: cost reduction. Sometimes the costs are incurred by the manufacturer (efficiency of the Google web crawler), and sometimes by the consumer (efficiency of the OS), but it's still cost containment. Now, if the programmer were actually carrying out algorithms, this comparison would be entirely sensible. They're not. They're just trying to make them use as few resources as possible.
- amichail 17y agoThe point is that this perspective is missing the enormous creative potential of the computer -- just as pen science is missing the enormous creative potential of the pen.
- amalcon 17y agoI guess I just don't see why you need an education in that. Civil engineers can design bridges that are quite nice to look at. Mechanical engineers can build very elegant machines that can be quite expressive. To my knowledge, education in those fields is still overwhelmingly about creating something that satisfies the specific requirements.
- bitwize 17y agoThe Europeans have come up with a suitable name which we would do well to adopt. French - informatique Spanish - informática German - Informatik If we spoke not of computer science but of informatics we would make so much progress. Remember: computer science : computers :: astronomy : telescopes. Math, traditionally, has been about solving problems. Computer science is about solving problems concerning how we solve problems. How many things do we need to keep track of in order to solve, say, the 8 Queens problem? How many steps do we need to take? (space and time complexity) What are those steps? Can we substitute different steps with the same extensional effect that do the job more efficiently? (algorithm analysis and optimization) How do we arrange information in such a way to take fewer steps to solve our problem? (data structures) Can we develop a means of representation for steps that is both easy for a universal Turing machine to read and act on and easy for a human to read and write? (programming language theory) This is informatics and if you are not fascinated by it I feel sorry for you. Computer science sounds too much like what it has actually become in most major universities: code grinder trade school.
- elblanco 17y ago>The CS curriculum needs to be redesigned to be more applications-oriented and the major needs to be renamed to reflect that change. They have those majors already, they're called "Software Engineering" and "Information Technology" at most schools.