3 ms·
This article is similar to what you would have read in the late 19th century when looms were being mechanized. Hopefully the future will continue to match the h
by chaostheory 11y ago
This article is similar to what you would have read in the late 19th century when looms were being mechanized. Hopefully the future will continue to match the historical precedents of mass mechanization (i.e. Industrial Revolution, 20th century manufacturing, ...). Yes there will be disruption, workers will lose their jobs, and there may even be riots. However in the end we still had progress and we still created jobs; the old jobs were gone but there's always a new need.
- codeshaman 11y ago> Hopefully the future will continue to match the historical precedents I hope not. Rise of communism, fascism and the two world wars isn't what any of us wants at this time.
- chaostheory 11y agoWe have nuclear weapons that serve as deterrents, keeping the peace and limiting the fighting between major powers to proxy conflicts.
- tluyben2 11y agoI read a lot about that but I don't see how that will work this time. In the previous revolutions very specific jobs were replaced and you could kind of see there were still jobs to be done outside it. I come from a loom family; my grandfather was replaced by machines and he became a department head; the rest (family, friends, ...) got forced out and most never got jobs again. But of course next generations managed to do other things unrelated to this line of work my family did for generations. This time I simply don't see what will be 'in the end' as we are replacing all but highly skilled (mostly thinker) jobs and by far most people, no matter how you train them (and most don't want to), are simply not that skilled. The jobs we train people for who cannot get jobs are college graduates, but in something non-tech; we train them for coding & digital marketing. Most (90%) don't get beyond basic coding skills (html/css + copy/paste of js from stackoverflow) and both that and digital marketing skills (keyword search for seo/ads etc) can already be mostly replaced, but it's too expensive to build the software to do it. Someone will do and then these people have nothing; they simply cannot do much of which is in demand. I don't want to say software is the only place ofcourse, but they come to us via the state unemployment bureau after have been there for as much as 7 years for some after graduating; they tried other things. And this is the top % of society that actually went to uni. I really don't see how this will work for anyone with only a high school degree.
- chaostheory 11y ago> I read a lot about that but I don't see how that will work this time. In the previous revolutions very specific jobs were replaced and you could kind of see there were still jobs to be done outside it. This pattern of thought just keeps repeating itself whenever something disruptive comes about. The generations before us also couldn't see what new jobs would replace all of the displaced ones > I really don't see how this will work for anyone with only a high school degree. I think you just answered your own question below: > But of course next generations managed to do other things unrelated to this line of work my family did for generations. People in general are resilient when there's no choice. For example, before the advent of microcomputers and spreadsheets, most businesses had whole departments of people who spent all day just creating one or two spreadsheets. Before mechanical alarm and electronic clocks were widespread, they had people tap on windows to wake people up on time. Before the manufacturing process for computers became mechanized, most of the work was done by female workers 'stitching' wires for machine logic. People adapt. Humanity as a whole advances. Well the good part is that most places have some form of social net that buys us time to figure it out. Maybe someone in HN or one of the major tech hubs can actively try to solve it?