8 ms·
How Mt. Gox Imploded
- dylanjermiah 11y ago"The panic that this caused only got worse on Monday when Mark provided the first explanation: the exchange had run up against a flaw in the Bitcoin protocol. The flaw, known as transaction malleability, allowed devious users to request a withdrawal, change the code, and then successfully request the same withdrawal again." It was my understanding that double spending wasn't possible?
- VMG 11y agoDouble spending was not possible. This (known) flaw was about being able to change certain parts of a transaction that were unsigned, allowing multiple equally valid transfers to have different ids. Only one of then ends up in the blockchain, however. You could thus not rely on a transaction id as a reference to see if a payment was made, but some systems did nonetheless. See https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Transaction_Malleability https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Transaction_Malleability
- yc1010 11y agoAnd anyways the transaction malleability "excuse" was debunked, it can not explain millions worth of bitcoins AND millions worth of USD "disappearing" from their bank as well. http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/04/09/mt_goxs_transaction_malleability_claim_rubbished_by_researchers/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/04/09/mt_goxs_transaction_... Karpeles is either a deliberate fraud (he does have a prior history) or possibly a bad programmer whose bugs in code dealing with money caught him with his pants down... Eitherway he has greatly damaged Bitcoin name with his shenanigans, blaming transaction malleability was one of the straws he tried to clutch at as his house of bad code collapsed, he also tried to blame his staff and few other tricks.
- __z 11y ago>a bad programmer He certainly didn't understand a lot about security. In the original topic on bitcoin talk (https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=444.0 https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=444.0) someone pointed out he was sending passwords in the query string. He replied "It is a post over https. It is secure." ignoring the other (obvious) problems with putting passwords in the query string (http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/29598/should-sensitive-data-ever-be-passed-in-the-query-string http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/29598/should-sen...)
- stygiansonic 11y agoHere's an explanation[0] of the issue. As a summary: Apparently they were using the hash to track transactions, and would re-send bitcoins if the transaction didn't appear to go through. This is obviously a problem if the transaction did go through, but with a different hash. Basically, two transactions which effectively do the same thing can end up having a different hash. Because of this, one should not rely on looking for the hash in the blockchain to see whether a transaction has "gone through". This has been a {known issue, flaw} since 2011, but some BTC exchanges (like Mt. Gox) continued to rely on the transaction hash to check whether transactions had been committed to the blockchain. If a transaction hadn't appeared to have gone through, they re-sent bitcoins (under a new transaction). This is a problem if the transaction did indeed go through, but under a different hash, as it would cause the same action (transfer money from A to B) to show up in the blockchain twice. 0. http://www.righto.com/2014/02/bitcoin-transaction-malleability.html http://www.righto.com/2014/02/bitcoin-transaction-malleabili...
- maxerickson 11y agoDouble spending refers to attacking the bitcoin network to rewrite history and use the same coins twice. It is merely infeasible. In the case of Mt Gox, poor internal accounting controls made it possible to make repeated withdrawals. Say a standard transfer is initiated by sending Mt Gox a message, [Mt Gox, send me money.], which causes Mt Gox to check that the funds are available, initiate a legitimate bitcoin transaction and debit the Mt Gox account for that amount. Their system was set up so that if you sent a specially formed message like [Mt Gox, send me MORE money.], it would check that the funds were available, initiate a legitimate bitcoin transaction and not bother debiting the Mt Gox account. That isn't quite technically accurate (the attack involved getting Mt Gox to respond to a different message than ended up on the consensus blockchain), but it captures where the problem was, Mt Gox wasn't keeping track of funds in a careful way.
- mootothemax 11y agoIt was my understanding that double spending wasn't possible? While I'm far from authoritative on the matter, under certain circumstances, it appears to be very possible. Here's one person's explanation of their $10,000 double-spend during a hard fork of the blockchain: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=152348.0 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=152348.0 A mining pool also manipulated the block chain to run a double-spend attach against a dice betting site: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1qqmr4/ghashiocexio_and_doublespending_against_betcoin/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1qqmr4/ghashiocexio...
- jackgavigan 11y ago"For most of January, the price of a Bitcoin on Mt. Gox had been almost $100 higher than on any other exchange..." That doesn't sound right to me. I seem to recall that the price on MtGOX was lower than elsewhere.
- Avalaxy 11y agoNo, it was higher because it wasn't easy to get fiat out. People wanted bitcoin because it was easier to get out. Only after they shut the withdrawals down did the MT Gox BTC price crash.
- jackgavigan 11y agoRight, gotcha.
- celticninja 11y agothis is true but i dont remember the price disparity being quite so high, there was always ~$10 difference, perhaps the $100 figure was at the peak of $1200
- bdcravens 11y agoIt was only lower at the very end. Before that, for several weeks and months, it had been higher.
- mirimir 11y agoWhat about the pump-n-dump that someone was running during 2013 and mid 2014? Was that Mt Gox or someone who had pwned it? The article doesn't even mention the issue.
- jpatokal 11y agoUn-spoiler: As far as I can tell, this article tells nothing new about what happened, and in particular doesn't actually say anything about how Mt. Gox lost all its Bitcoins.
- pakled_engineer 11y agoWouldn't believe anything he told this Vice reporter. Karpeles once famously slammed Prolexic and Black Lotus for weeks claiming they were 'a scam' then somebody noticed he had failed to do even basic firewalling and ports were still wide open allowing attackers to easily bypass the DOS mitigation service. He's only one notch above in competency from the exchange that nuked their wallet when they shut down an AWS VM accidentally. That ol chestnut about the malleability vuln is not supported by their own logs they released it's more likely they were cleaned out months before and ran a scheme to inflate Bitcoin and recoup the losses until even that scheme imploded.
- emodendroket 11y agoHe's not quoted in the article and the only part of the article based on his account comes from another source and notes that it is impossible to verify and there is reason to be suspicious of it. Why not read the article before commenting?
- gwern 11y ago> Wouldn't believe anything he told this Vice reporter. "This is an excerpt from _Digital Gold: Bitcoin and the Inside Story of the Misfits and Millionaires_, a new book by New York Times reporter Nathaniel Popper. Reprinted courtesy of Harper, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers. "
- sparkzilla 11y agoI actually interviewed Karpeles a few months before the crash. At the time it seemed to me he was ill-prepared to deal with the stress of becoming a large organization under a lot of political and financial scrutiny. I also made a timeline of events, which is much more detailed than the article: http://newslines.org/mt-gox/?order=ASC http://newslines.org/mt-gox/?order=ASC
- emergentcypher 11y agoIt's like we need to constantly be rediscovering why the financial system is heavily regulated.
- stygiansonic 11y agoIndeed - there should be a term for this, perhaps "Financial Recapitulation".
- wdr1 11y agoGiven Bernie Madoff alone made off with at least 10x what was lost with Mt. Gox, I'm not sure I agree with that conclusion.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dummy7953 11y agoBitcoin - a fun, new way to mentally masturbate.