4 ms·
Honestly, I'd say, if his talk has technical merits and he's not going to deviate off into the crap from his blog, let him talk. And for political context, I'm
by eli_gottlieb 11y ago
Honestly, I'd say, if his talk has technical merits and he's not going to deviate off into the crap from his blog, let him talk.
And for political context, I'm basically a Communist, and I think the blow-up around neoreactionaries is silly. You don't need to be as anti-tech as the Baffler[1] to spot that when you pin neoreactionaries down to claims of fact and concrete values, they're wrong on basically everything. They're wrong the way Creationists are wrong.
And they're popular for the exact same reason Creationists are popular: they've got some very well-spoken, intellectual-sounding people on their side to tell the world that everything we know about history, sociology, and science is all a grand conspiracy to cover up how right they are. That's their much-vaunted "Cathedral", and it's a popular narrative with fringe movements all over the world.
It's just got a three major things wrong with it:
1) It's wrong as a matter of fact. The power establishment of society is arranged differently from how they claim: liberal academics and libertarian financiers don't really get along, oilmen actually run Congress more than silly-hippie street activists, power actually flows from the barrel of a gun rather than a Tumblr post, "Cthulhu" was swimming rightwards from roughly the late 1960s until maybe 2013-2014, etc.
2) Reversing the stupidity of the weirdest, most out-there positions you can find on the internet hinterlands of the Left doesn't give you intelligent politics [2].
3) Meta-contrarianism doesn't make you correct [3].
[1] - http://www.thebaffler.com/blog/mouthbreathing-machiavellis/ http://www.thebaffler.com/blog/mouthbreathing-machiavellis/
[2] - http://lesswrong.com/lw/lw/reversed_stupidity_is_not_intelligence/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/lw/reversed_stupidity_is_not_intelli...
[3] - http://lesswrong.com/lw/2pv/intellectual_hipsters_and_metacontrarianism/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/2pv/intellectual_hipsters_and_metaco...
- mcphage 11y ago> "Cthulhu" was swimming rightwards from roughly the late 1960s until maybe 2013-2014 I have no idea what this means.
- brobinson 11y agoIt's a reference to the intro post on Mencius Moldbug's blog: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.ca/2009/01/gentle-introduction-to-unqualified.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.ca/2009/01/gentle-i... The original was "Cthulhu swims left": a metaphor of how Western society has inexorably proceeded leftward.
- mcphage 11y agoGotcha, thanks.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoIt's intended to show that yes, I have actually heard what neoreactionaries say. "Cthulhu only swims left" is Moldbug's way of saying, "Politics only ever moves leftward." As I noted, there was a substantial rightward sing from roughly the late 1960s until roughly 2013, at least in the West. Certain elements of social liberalism advanced, while most were held back or even undone (abortion, for instance, has become de facto more restricted in many places), racial segregation has re-asserted itself, labor was just plain dead as a political power compared to its former self, Communism fell, etc. The point being: history does not actually swing, swim, or evolve inevitably towards anyone's political ideology. Where victories are won, they are usually the result of deliberate activism by devoted ideologues, and they are sometimes undone. This applies to both Left and Right.