5 ms·
I am highly opposed to this kind of screening, mainly because there's no objective measure of what "decent" speech is. There are highly politicized topics - thi
by kstrauser 11y ago
I am highly opposed to this kind of screening, mainly because there's no objective measure of what "decent" speech is. There are highly politicized topics - think abortion rights - where the "common sense, decent" opinions on either side seem like radical extremism to the other.
There is literally not an opinion you can hold that won't offend a significant portion of attendees. Do you believe in global warming? You might seem to be an environmentalist whacko to the conservatives in the audience. Vocally support second amendment rights on Twitter? Some liberals might think you're a dangerous gun nut. Believe that misandry and reverse racism are real? A good chunk of the crowd will believe you're sexist and racist. Don't believe that they're real? Another group will think you're a hardline SJW weirdo.
I have no idea about the political opinions of most of the people I've seen speak. Maybe they'd be my best friend in real life, or maybe they're despicable. I don't know; I don't care. I'm not endorsing or condoning their personal opinions by listening to and benefitting from their technical experience in the subjects I'm interested in.
- solipsism 11y agothere are no objective measures for what a good topic for a talk would be either. why should a measure necessarily be objective?
- kstrauser 11y ago"Is this talk on-topic and appropriate to the target technical level" is much more well-defined than whether unrelated political views are "good". Should a tech conference in San Francisco eschew Republicans? Would it be OK if a con in Topeka shunned Democrats? And would either serve the greater public good of mixing people with different beliefs together so they can find common ground and open communication channels?
- Shivetya 11y agoAs it has been pointed out my many comedians, they intolerance of college campuses has become too burdensome to even bother with. Even some college professors and adjuncts have posted similar problems. We have entered an era of selfishness. Where nothing is permitted to annoy the individual. We have moved beyond groups taking to shouting down they oppose; they still do; to where now the "feelings" of individuals are enough to silence speech. In groups defined as liberal it has to be the about as opposite as you can get from the definition. Yes there are people who say stupid things, but that does not remove value from all their thoughts. Who needs the government thought police when the current generation wants that role?
- forthefuture 11y agoIn the same vein, if you as a conference organizer don't want to deal with the drama that an attendee might bring, you should have every right to exercise your freedom to deny speakers. The same people who would criticize you for being racist will criticize you for screening racists from speaking. There is no winning in these situations. I personally value individual freedom over anything else. If you want to be a bigot and make people uncomfortable, or run around naked and make people uncomfortable, you should have every right to. Just as people have the right to not like you because you are doing things that make them uncomfortable.
- gizmo 11y ago> to where now the "feelings" of individuals are enough to silence speech This is a straw man. People protest against hate speech not because of feelings, but because hate speech is believed to cause harm. Either it is the case that hate speech is harmful (e.g. contributes to hateful actions, contributes to subconscious prejudice, etc) or hate speech is harmless (only feelings are hurt, but there are no other negative consequences). So we're dealing with an empirical claim about the world. Social science departments can -- and do -- research this. Dismissing an entire field of research as "feelings" is unhelpful.
- kstrauser 11y ago> This is a straw man. People protest against hate speech not because of feelings, but because hate speech is believed to cause harm. I think the point was that my hate speech is often your rational, logical opinion (and vice versa). There's a lot of stuff that almost everyone can agree is horrible - when you get into extremes like burning crosses, not many people will argue for it - but the concept of hate speech is often diluted to the point of absurdity in common speech. I've personally all too frequently heard and read people define "hate speech" as "speech disapproving of my behavior or political views". I mean, I've heard sincere rants that supporting gay marriage is anti-religious hate speech. No one but the ranter was likely to agree with him, but there you have it.
- gizmo 11y ago
- rojoca 11y agoI agree with the general sentiment that someone's technical experience should in almost all cases be able to be presented independent of their political views but I would append to that the following: "but conferences can do whatever they like providing it is lawful".
- gizmo 11y agoYou're effectively arguing that's it's all relative, therefore any political opinion is tolerable. Even though this has never been the case. There would be so much outrage if vindictive prosecutors (like Carmen Ortiz) or patent trolls would get to speak at Strange Loop. Think about it for a second. It's utterly inconceivable they would be allowed in, no matter the technical merit of their hypothetical talk. Shunning people like Moldbug is really no different. People with such abhorrent views shouldn't get a platform or the effective endorsement from the tech community.
- kstrauser 11y agoI think that political opinions not related to the conference are irrelevant. I'd draw the distinction that Ortiz's and Darl McBride's actions actively oppose the thing that the conference is about: technology and innovation. It's reasonable not to invite a hog farmer to a vegan conference, but I don't think it would be right to kick him out of a hog farming convention because he also happens to be pro-choice.