7 ms·
To all of those saying ranting on twitter is the wrong move I couldn't disagree more. Twitter is often the ONLY tool that the average person can use to communic
by joshstrange 11y ago
To all of those saying ranting on twitter is the wrong move I couldn't disagree more. Twitter is often the ONLY tool that the average person can use to communicate and/or call out large companies on their actions. This is BS and should be made known. Homebrew is an amazing tool and I'd be falling over myself getting the offer papers in this guy's hands if he came to me looking for a job. The fact that google turned him away only further cements my opinion that google would be a terrible place to work.
- supergirl 11y agomaybe Homebrew is amazing, but Google can hire the best people in the world. that day they might've interviewed 10 people better than him who just didn't make a popular tool
- leetNightshade 11y ago"that day they might've interviewed 10 people better than him who just didn't make a popular tool" Are you judging this on their ability to invert a binary tree? People here are ranting about having a problem with interview practices not representing whether or not you are good at your job. That's presumably (IMO) why the tweet was posted.
- supergirl 11y agothe tweet is made to trigger that discussion. but you can rephrase the tweet to something like: even though I made a popular tool, I didn't get a job at Google because I'm not good at other things they need. Google probably has a lot of factors counted into the final decision, including algorithm skills, other software engineering skills, human skills, contributions to open source projects. It's never 1 reason why you get rejected, it's the total score.
- seiji 11y agobecause I'm not good at other things they need. It's not that you're not _good_ at it, but you're not able to demonstrate under time constraints, lack of references, lack of iterative code/compiler/REPL feedback, and while being stared down by someone whose default mindset is "why am I wasting my time on this person?" It's never 1 reason why you get rejected, it's the total score. That depends on how far down the interview process you are. Often they'll cut you off at a phone interview if you stumble. Sometimes they'll cut in-person interviews short if they think you're not worth it. So, they don't always get a "total score" to judge against. It's often just summary judgement off subjective feelings.
- supergirl 11y agodemonstrate under time constraints, lack of references, lack of iterative code/compiler/REPL feedback well that is the interview. for you being good means to know how to invert a binary tree if you have access to a compiler and internet, but for Google it means to know it off the top of your head. they could let you have access to compiler and then make the questions much more difficult. which one is better? I don't know. first one takes less time at least. Often they'll cut you off at a phone interview if you stumble I'd guess that's because they have so many condidates to pick from.
- seiji 11y agoI'd guess that's because they have so many condidates to pick from. Exactly. It's the Big City Dating Problem. There are so many people to pick from, nobody wants to compromise to build a relationship. Just leave at the slightest sign of something not being 100% what you want and on to the next one since there are 20,000 other acceptable people within walking distance. if you have access to a compiler and internet It's not exactly that, but you often don't realize how many micro-checks or micro-confirmations you do while programming. In the absence of any "is this okay so far?" feedback, you're left second guessing yourself and reading your solution redundantly to check for any errors your daily automation would catch immediately by default.
- Terr_ 11y agoIt's also aggravating when a Google recruiter "reaches out" to you and but won't (or can't) reveal any details at all about what role they're trying to fill.
- aaggarwal 11y agoI am speaking from personal experience here, they don't count a lot of factors while rejecting a candidate, you make one mistake on their particular set of questions, you are out. They don't even look at your resumes until all your 4 interviews are completed. However, selecting a candidate is a different matter, in that decision they might consider everything.
- mvgoogler 11y agoDoes your personal experience include actually being involved in the hiring process at Google? Because in my personal experience - as both an interviewer and a hiring committee member - what you said is completely wrong. > they don't count a lot of factors while rejecting a candidate, you make one > mistake on their particular set of questions, you are out. Completely false. I have personally seen many people get hired despite doing poorly in an interview or making mistakes. The hiring committee looks at all of the available information - resume, recommendations, and interview feedback when making a decision. There is no "one-thing" that will make or break a candidate. > They don't even look at your resumes until all your 4 interviews are completed I have no idea where you are getting this from. All interviewers receive the candidate's resume prior to the interview. I always review the resume's to get a sense of what the candidate has done so I can ask appropriate questions.
- aaggarwal 11y agoYes, I was interviewed at Google last year. This was basically what happened. Sure, they have your resume, I am not sure if they read it throughly, the interviewer didn't even know my major until I told him at the end of the interview. While, they don't stop inteview and say you made mistake, it's competitive and it's not possible to hire you. But, you know at that moment that you are not getting hired. I guess, they need plenty of reasons to hire a candidate, but just one reason to reject. I am not complaining, it seems to work for Google very well.
- sremani 11y agoDisagree, this is not some PR campaign of a corporate drone, a real person felt frustrated with the process of hiring in Google. Is it to instigate debate on HN, I doubt it. He is just venting out, that his body of work which is public is effectively ignored in favor of a pedantic exercise.
- supergirl 11y agoHow do you know it was ignored? It's possible it is one of the reasons why he even got this far. Also how do you know he didn't fail a great number of other things they evaluate?
- JamesBarney 11y agoWhy do you think white boarding over the course of an several hours would be a better predictor of these traits than years of making very meaningful contributions to software? It seems to me like creating and managing a repository of more than 4800 contributors is a much better signal of a candidates software engineering, communication, and human skills than a couple of people's opinion of a couple of hours of white boarding.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> maybe Homebrew is amazing, but Google can hire the best people in the world. Then why don't they? I wouldn't consider "the best people in the world" those that can pass an advanced CS class.
- supergirl 11y agoso for you "best in the world" is not someone good at CS. similarly, for Google it appears best in the world is not someone that made a popular tool.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAnd so Google can continue to lose talent to competitors, or have potential hires go off to start their own startups they can then pay a premium for, while keeping "good enough" talent for existing initiatives. I'm starting to realize why Google is absolutely terrible at any sort of customer-facing product.
- supergirl 11y agotalent.. what is talent? they have a set of skills they look for. this guy doesn't have what they need. for you talent means to be the author of a popular tool, but for Google means more; means also boring stuff like being good at communicating, being good in a team, etc. who knows how many of these this guy failed
- georgemcbay 11y agoWell how do you define "better"? Esteemed schools of music probably produce dozens of guitarists "better" (in any way you would measure it academically) than Jimmy Page or Jimi Hendrix per year who go on to a life of producing nothing of lasting worth. I'll take the guy/girl who has actually proved they can produce something useful every time over someone who is "better" but hasn't.
- supergirl 11y agoWell then I guess it's because Page/Hendrix were much more than expert guitarists. They were also good at composition, lyrics, showmanship, marketing, business. Those academic guitarists will make contributions to the guitar field but seems that you wouldn't value that alone and it's OK. You are free to have your opinion about whom to hire just as Google is. For the sake of the argument, you could imagine 100 reasons why Google wouldn't hire Jimi Hendrix. Even though he produced something very popular he lacks many things that Google wants: he's not respectful of other people so he's going to cause other people problems, he's doing hard drugs so he's unpredictable, good with guitar but not other instruments, and so on.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoIf Google keeps telling itself it only hires the very best guitarists, and it turns down someone like Hendrix - because he's "not a team player", or he doesn't know how to tap out 13/18 while improvising an Indian Harikhamboji raga, or for some other inane reason - then it isn't really interested in the best guitarists at all. It's the difference between an holistic view of talent, and an academic and rather narcissistic insistence on specific limited social signals that are believed to correlate with intelligence. And this really matters in practical ways. A lot of talented devs will be reading this story and wondering if they really want to work for Google. Negative PR like this is incredibly damaging. Consider the opposite - if Google could say "Yes, the Homebrew guy works for us." How much value do you think that would have had? Long term, the really smart and inventive people start to stay away. And then you get something that seems to be happening to Google already - declining product quality, a poorer user experience, and diminished reputation. You know - Google's record of hits recently hasn't been that great? So anyone who thinks Google is fine because it still has thousands of applicants is missing the point. Instead of being the kind of place where Hendrix plays, it's in danger of becoming the kind of place where there are a lot of people with a lot of solid but uncreative technical chops, and no one is making cool and interesting music any more.
- baakss 11y agoWe don't have all the details. You might not hire the best computer programmer in the world if he was also a psychopath. Heck, you might skip on him even if he wasn't a good culture fit. I'm not saying this person is / was any of those things, but there's more to hiring than just talent.
- justonepost 11y agoYeah, the twitter rant was a little unnerving. Might not have anything to do with inverting the binary tree.
- visarga 11y agoHe was there and that's what he felt it was the cause of his rejection. We haven't had the opportunity to witness his hiring process.
- soup10 11y agoThat's not what happened at all. Google has an interview process that is designed to weed out false positives(incompetent people getting hired). Because this guy didn't have enough algorithmic knowledge he failed their filter. To work at the borg you must learn and play by the borgs rules!
- sporkmonger 11y agoThere's also the committee factor. Google doesn't hire/no-hire based just on one person's opinion. If half your committee says, "90% of our engineers use his thing!" and the other half says, "But he can't code on a whiteboard!" then the committee is already kinda likely to take a pass due to lack of consensus. If there's any doubts at all on culture fit, which Google absolutely does care a great deal about, even more so. That said, when I was there, I interviewed someone who was essentially going to be my partner on something and everyone else (who weren't going to be working with this person) ranked the person poorly and I was the sole voice of (positive) dissent. I wasn't on the committee, so I don't know what their logic was, but the person was hired. And they were great. So it's not always even a majority opinion thing with the interviewers. In a nutshell, not only are we dealing with incomplete information here, we're dealing with VERY incomplete information.
- vacri 11y agoRanting on twitter is fucking awful. All it gives is nuance-free soundbites, and there are no 'lines to read between' due to it's brevity. Stuff gets taken the wrong way or out of context all the time. One of the reasons why it's so powerful is because it gives lazy journalists a stream of easy reaction quotes. When else in the history of journalism has there ever been a private company that was so heavily promoted, regardless of the media source? And even then, the react quotes are poor quality, single-sentence shit. This rant on twitter is absolutely meaningless unless you have a heap of context to go with it. And because twitter is popular, it's dumbing down public discourse along with it. /rant, that I couldn't have fit in 140 characters.
- philipwalton 11y agoMy main complaint with the tweet is that it's almost certainly speculation. 1) Most companies (for legal reasons) don't tell candidates why they weren't offered a job. Maybe it was because of the binary tree question, but maybe it was for some other reason. 2) Homebrew is a Mac-only product, so the likelihood that 90% of Googlers use homebrew is very low. Moreover, Google does not track the software its employees download onto their laptops, so there's no way they would even know the percentage.
- BinaryIdiot 11y ago> 1) Most companies (for legal reasons) don't tell candidates why they weren't offered a job. Maybe it was because of the binary tree question, but maybe it was for some other reason. So when I was declined at Google I knew people who worked for Google. One looked up my profile in whatever system they used and the other simply asked the interviewer why. OP may have done the same but as you say it's unclear either way but knowing is still possible. > 2) Homebrew is a Mac-only product, so the likelihood that 90% of Googlers use homebrew is very low. Moreover, Google does not track the software its employees download onto their laptops, so there's no way they would even know the percentage. Most of the people I know at Google use Macs so I don't see why not. I don't know what the majority of them use but a good chunk at least do. As far as tracking he could simply be tracking it himself and comparing his results of known Google IPs to employee counts. Not as accurate but might give a rough estimation. He may have further analytics based on data collected (if collected) by each machine.
- philipwalton 11y agoThe tweet starts out: "Google: 90% of our engineers...", which implies that this is information Google told him.
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoOP was obviously being sarcastic to express his frustration.
- 11y ago