6 ms·
Is illegal code (i.e. malware) protected by the copyright to begin with? If it is, then all antiviruses blatantly violate copyright. But something tells me they
by shmerl 11y ago
Is illegal code (i.e. malware) protected by the copyright to begin with? If it is, then all antiviruses blatantly violate copyright. But something tells me they don't need to ask any permission from malware authors.
- wvenable 11y agoIt seems like illegal works should be protected by copyright[1] But that begs the question, as ad injectors are probably not illegal. [1] http://www.cardozo.yu.edu/sites/default/files/Eldar%20Haber,%20Wrong%20Copyright.pdf http://www.cardozo.yu.edu/sites/default/files/Eldar%20Haber,...
- shmerl 11y agoI'm not sure they are not illegal. At least they shouldn't be any less illegal than many other types of malware. But I'm not familiar what laws that falls under.
- wvenable 11y agoInjecting ads into content has been what television stations have been doing for decades. Users of the network service may even have agreed to this in the terms of service for using the network. It's a crappy thing to do but not all crappy things are illegal.
- shmerl 11y agoThis example was not about injecting ads. It was about collecting data about users which is violating their privacy (i.e. it's malware).
- wvenable 11y agoWhat are you basing this on? Flash Networks said "The javascript mentioned does not collect or store any user data but is used to deliver user messages." and I haven't heard anything to contrary. In fact, it doesn't sound like it was even going to be used to inject ads except for offering users to upgrade to larger plan when they were near their data expiration. I agree that any code injection is shady and unwanted but you're just making stuff up.
- shmerl 11y agoOn the article: > “This is a standard solution deployed by telcos globally to help their customers keep track of their data usage in terms of mega bytes used. It is therefore meant to improve customer experience and empower them to manage their usage. One of our network vendor partners has piloted this solution through a third party to help customers understand their data consumption in terms of volume of data used.” The same thing was claimed about various malware in the past, which was found capable of doing all kind of weird things way beyond "improving customer experience".
- wvenable 11y agoYou are not stating any facts and so this doesn't add anything to the discussion.
- walshemj 11y agoIn the UK it would be an offence under the section 3 of Computer misuse act. "3.unauthorised modification of computer material, punishable by 12 months/maximum fine (or 6 months in Scotland) on summary conviction and/or 10 years/fine on indictment;[8]" Does India not have something similar on the books.
- chrisBob 11y agoUsing a copyright work and modifying it in some way often qualifies for fair use. I also think that in your example the antivirus companies would be happy to see who complains about their copyright violation. http://copyright.gov/fair-use/ http://copyright.gov/fair-use/
- forgottenpass 11y agoI assume there is some fair use cover AV providers could argue ("purpose and character of use" sounds like their bag) but I'd be surprised if many authors want to come out of the woodwork to fight that fight with them in the first place. As we can see in this case, it's a big deal that the author is seeking copyright takedown.
- shmerl 11y agoIt should teach them a lesson. Being exposed as malware authors (with intent to sell it to be used for malicious purposes) will not serve them well.
- gcb0 11y agowhy not? i can probably patent a full auto gun, even if it's illegal for me to have one
- dkersten 11y agoRegardless of whether or not it is, the article makes statements about how its " freely downloadable via any browser" and how "The crime, it seems, was the uploading of public code to a public repository". The point is that (legal or not), the code is not public and shouldn't be treated as such. No other code (eg javascript from all the HN starstups' web apps) that is downloadable is automatically "public code". Innocent until proven guilty and all that. But... since copyright automatically applies to all works, yes, I think it does and should apply to illegal code (and every other code or work out there). Having said that, I don't particularly see much morally objectionable with what this guy did in this case, even if its not legal.
- shmerl 11y ago> The point is that (legal or not), the code is not public and shouldn't be treated as such. I brought a few examples (like antiviruses). How publishing security research even into the public repository with the code of malware that's involved wrong? Fair use should cover it. If it's indeed illegal, then all antiviruses are illegal too, because not only they publish - they redistribute that said code.
- wvenable 11y agoYou keep making this argument but it's wrong. Antivirus software does not contain complete copies of malware.
- rosser 11y agoYes, malicious code is protected by copyright. Antivirus software isn't distributing the copyrighted virus, and I can't begin to wrap my head around the conception you must have of how they work, in order to think they do. Copyright is utterly irrelevant to the relationship between computer virii and antivirus software.
- shmerl 11y ago> Antivirus software isn't distributing the copyrighted virus Why not? Many of them include patterns for detecting viruses, which literally contain originals in some way (partially at least). There are tons of malware types, including one that's not polymorphic. Regardless, even if they include malware in full, it should be perfectly fine under fair use. I.e. that malware souldn't be protected by the copyright in such case (because it's for the purpose of security).
- rosser 11y agoFair use doesn't remove a copyrighted work's protections. What ever gave you that idea? Think of it in criminal law terms: it's like the "affirmative defense" that having a medical marijuana card gives you in states that have such programs. Pot is still illegal, but if you get caught with some, and have a card (and are compliant with the restrictions of your local MMJ program), then the charges are dismissed. It doesn't change the law; it changes how the law applies to you.
- shmerl 11y ago> Fair use doesn't remove a copyrighted work's protections. It doesn't remove them, it just says that that they aren't even applicable in that case. I.e. there is nothing to remove when it's not there to begin with. I agree that it's somewhat poorly defined that's why there can be different ways to view it. See https://w2.eff.org/IP/eff_fair_use_faq.php https://w2.eff.org/IP/eff_fair_use_faq.php Approach of "affirmative defense" doesn't sound logical to me. Approach of limiting copyright applicability makes more sense. I.e. fair use defines some borders beyond which copyright can't reach.
- biot 11y agoAntivirus software is based upon code signatures. When you install some AV software, it does not come with complete, unabridged copies of every single sample and every mutation of every piece of malware ever. Not only is that a bad idea from a copyright standpoint (regardless of whether any malware author would bother to enforce their rights), but also because the AV software would completely fill up your hard drive and it would give everybody (including competitors) access to complete copies of malware.