6 ms·
The geopolitics of this one is fascinating. Stuxnet was a combined Israeli/US attack on Iran's nuclear capability. Kaspersky is a Russian security company whi
by btilly 11y ago
The geopolitics of this one is fascinating.
Stuxnet was a combined Israeli/US attack on Iran's nuclear capability. Kaspersky is a Russian security company which was started with government support, and is believed to still have connections there. Russia and Iran are allies.
Now look at how it played out. The US and Israel attacked Iran. Kaspersky tracked it down and publicized it to the world. And now some combination of the US, Israel, or close allies launched a spying attack on Kaspersky. Which, for all we know, may actually be an important part of the Russian cybersecurity infrastructure.
For all that organizations like the NSA do wrong (like spying on all of us), this is the kind of thing that we actually wanted them doing when they were created.
- avodonosov 11y agoWith your fantasy you can work in tabloids like Wired. Russia and Iran are allies? US is going to use Iran against Russia to sell Iranian gas and oil to Europe and subdue Russian influence - that's why US decided to fix relations with Iran and come to a deal allowing to finish the sanctions. It's more like competitors than allies.
- btilly 11y agoIn recent history, Russia and Iran have indeed been allies. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Russia_relations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Russia_relations for verification. And the US has repeatedly found itself on the opposite end of geopolitical conflicts with both countries. For a random example, both Iran and Russia have been supportive of Assad's government in Syria, while the US is opposed. Of course interests shift over time. We are indeed doing things to improve relations with Iran. But that doesn't change the fact that in recent history we've been calling them part of "the axis of evil" and they have been calling us "the great Satan".
- avodonosov 11y agoI've heard that Iran calls US "great Satan", and Russia "small Satan"
- btilly 11y agoI've heard that Iran calls Israel "small Satan", not Russia. A quick Google search finds lots of confirmation of that.
- avodonosov 11y agoWikipedia mentions both :) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Satan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Satan
- btilly 11y agoAnd so it does. I stand corrected. The USSR was indeed called the lesser Satan 35 years ago. However the link that I provided to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Russia_relations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Russia_relations says that Iran and the USSR had poor relations (due to the whole atheism thing), but Iran and Russia have had good relations since the USSR fell. Do you have a reference to Iran calling Russia any version of Satan in, say, the last 15 years?
- avodonosov 11y agoLets better return to the subject. I agree with your overall conclusion that it's possible the attack was carried out by some special agencies, and that it might be reasonable from their standpoint. But the chain of causality you draw looks to me as an arbitrary fantasy; or to say better, only one of many possible explanations. It puts together several unverified assumptions - statements which are not 100% true, but only probable to some degree. The probability of all that happen together is a multiplication of all the probabilities, and therefore a small number. There is no evidence that Kaspersky Labs work for Russian intelligence. Yes, there were articles where journalists say "oh, he worked in KGB, so we can imagine they still cooperate". The fact we can imagine something doesn't mean it's true. All we can say for sure, Kaspersky Labs maybe work for KGB, or maybe not (including they work for somebody else, why not imagine this). Does Russia want to support Iranian nuclear program, up to providing cyber security? IMHO unlikely, but again - maybe yes, maybe no. Even if Russia decided to support Iran, there is no proof Russia employed Kaspersky and not a proper department of intelligence service - maybe Kaspersky detected stuxnet fairly, during their anti-virus research (their primary business, isn't it possible)? Even that stuxnet is an US intelligence creature is not a 100% fact; there were strong evidence to support that, but we don't know 100%. 0.1 * 0.2 * 0.4 * 0.9 = 0.0072 Put your own number if you find your assumptions more realistic: P(Kaspersky Labs work for KGB) = 0.8 P(Russia wants so provide cyber security for Iranian nuclear program) = 0.5 P(Kasperky Labs detected stuxnet specifically because of intelligence order, as russian intelligence has no other cybersecurity departments) = 0.5 P(stuxned is developed by US intelligence to attack Iran) = 0.95 Anyway, the combined probability of 0.8 * 0.5 * 0.5 * 0.95 = 0.19
- huhtenberg 11y ago> a Russian company started with government support From what I know this is simply not true. Got a source? But I think your overall point holds. Kaspersky's 400 million user base includes a boatload of US/Western users, including enterprise and government clients. This simply cannot NOT be of some concern to respective countries, so it's perfectly logical that they would want to keep an eye on the situation.
- btilly 11y agoI thought I had a source, but when I went looking I found tons of interesting connections (eg Kaspersky having gotten started in anti-virus while he was KGB) but no actual proof of involvement. Given how Russian business works, though, it would seem likely that there is a connection. But http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-19/cybersecurity-kaspersky-has-close-ties-to-russian-spies http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-19/cybersecur... is an article that gives more recent reason for why Kaspersky is a potentially interesting target for Western spies.
- AdBait 11y ago>tons of interesting connections Mind sharing those? >he was KGB. A claim unsupported by evidence. >Given how Russian business works "Given how I assume Russian business works based at most on anecdotal evidence." FTFY Anyway I wouldn't bother to reply to your post, if you hadn't had used source that is full of shit, pardon my French. You can check out Kaspersky's blog for rebuttal of this article. Now if you insist on inductive reasoning I can offer you no evidence to the contrary, of course. And no, I don't work for Russian troll agency and am not Russian in any way. I doubt they would bother with ycombinator anyway. In no way this is attack on you of course, but I find these kind of posts severely annoying because of aforementioned reasons.