2 ms·
This is not about 'fuck TEPCO', is about 'Should we trust still in what TEPCO says?'. There is a well documented chain of lies, accidents, and surrealistic mist
by pvaldes 11y ago
This is not about 'fuck TEPCO', is about 'Should we trust still in what TEPCO says?'. There is a well documented chain of lies, accidents, and surrealistic mistakes from this company in the last four years.
I don't know enough about the claimed process of purification so I could be wrong, but I'm understanding by the article that tons of radioactive saltwater are magically converted in yummy distilled water and that tritium is the only cause of concern. It reminds me the same old rethoric: "they are clever, they know how to do this, don't make questions, nature will gobble the problem and we all will be safe and happy again".
I think that is reasonable to be sceptic in this case.
Are we talking about to dump distilled pure water or saltwater to the sea?. Is a different situation. It is saltwater there is a lot of things about to care, not just hydrogen. What happened with the dissolved salts and organic matter in the radioactive saltwater?.
And of course, how we could control the real composition of the dumped water?. Just because TEPCO promises us that this time is safe?. This is also a legitimate question. Are we just sending a clear message of 'do as you please with the waste'?. This could be a huge mistake in my opinion.
- tptacek 11y agoI don't trust TEPCO at all. I'm interested in the discussion we're actually capable of having: if you have a large and growing number of tanks full of tritiated water, is it better to store them aboveground, or dump them in the ocean?
- pvaldes 11y agoTo dump them in the ocean is irreversible and basically unpredictable. Maybe could entirely wipe species that filter the water, like the right whales. Maybe could create malformations in cod eggs for example, leading to a small percentage of surviving cod larvae. As we need thousands of eggs to have a single adult cod this could quickly escalate to the entire collapse of the population. All commercial fish species and fishing grounds are currently under a big (increasing) pressure by fishermen so this is not a good moment to do this experiment. There is available space in Fukushima for more tanks. Nobody lives in the area and if properly designed to be durable seems a safer option. We have the technology to design such containers.
- tptacek 11y agoIt seems pretty easy to do the math on the dilution. What is the specific effect you're concerned about? If the question was just "should TEPCO keep paying", I'd agree. But that's not the only question. In the ocean, the tritiated water gets diluted, quickly, to levels asymptotically approaching ambient beta radiation. A mishap with the tanks on land however exposes the land ecosystem to potentially concentrated radiation.
- pvaldes 11y agoI'm deeply concerned about the possibility that tritium is just a red herring in this case to obtain license to dump radioactive water to the sea 'ad libitum'.
- tptacek 11y agoIf that's what you believe, you don't need to invent arguments about how tiny amounts of tritium are going to cause mass extinctions. Just say "I don't trust TEPCO that it's just tritium" and leave it at that. Surely there's something --- large amounts of pure plutonium? --- we can all agree shouldn't be dumped into the ocean.