3 ms·
A lot of what she says is true, but a lot of it is cultural and transcends borders. If you go up to frugal places in new england, putting on airs will not get
by mc32 11y ago
A lot of what she says is true, but a lot of it is cultural and transcends borders. If you go up to frugal places in new england, putting on airs will not get you too far... but in other places, more flashy places, it helps.
But this phenomenon is certainly not only American or essentially white. You can go to Japan and you can go to urban coastal china and contrast that with rural china. Or you can go to Nigeria and contrast Lagos with people not from Lagos.
The signaling and the the appearances are not either uniquely american nor are they borne from mainstream american culture. It's pretty much semi-universal.
On the other hand, poor people in China and Japan will try to look as presentable as possible while being quite frugal.
This whole thing brings up a pet peeve of mine and that's the "cultural fit" meme one finds so pervasive in the valley. It's as if someone who has a Motorola 'culture' is a bad 'fit' for working at Cloudera, to make something up.
None the less, you see people slurping up the corporate culture du jour as if a 'jobdesiac'. You could imagine how if essentially mainstream engineers can be categorized as bad cultural fits just from one company to the next, how slightly different cultures would have even more pronounced experiences due to discrepancy.
- detcader 11y agoWhat if "whiteness" is not a geographical/physical trait but a social construction? What if whiteness varies in the specifics of its processes around the world?
- mc32 11y agolabeling it 'whiteness' muddies things here. This kind of thing arose independently of any culture. But yeah, social mechanism --a cultural shibboleth. Why do so many native english speakers insist _insist_ upon using French phraseology, even when the French phrase is quite cumbersome, if you understand French and there are native english counterparts? The same could be said about abusing buzzwords. Basically, the goal is to mimic the received and expected behavior of where you are. If I were in india, it would behoove me to adopt more local norms in conducting business. Acting white and american, would do white americans a disservice.
- rhizome 11y ago"Whiteness" is absolutely physical/biological, but if you want to talk about characteristics signifying traits associated with power and dominant status, then yes, they are socially constructed. It's just not called "whiteness."
- roywiggins 11y agoIt is though. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiteness_studies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiteness_studies
- FeepingCreature 11y ago> if you want to talk about characteristics signifying traits associated with power and dominant status Whiteness is associated with power and dominant status, but not all categorizations of "characteristics signifying traits associated with power and dominant status" are Whiteness. Whiteness is a subset of CSTAWPADS.
- coldtea 11y ago>"Whiteness" is absolutely physical/biological Actually not so much. In late-19th early 20th century, Italian, Greek, Bulgarian, etc immigrants were decidely labeled as "non white" -- to the point of lynching when one of those "non whites" were e.g. found dating a "white girl" (white being mostly WASP).
- detcader 11y agoI think "How the Irish Became White" by Noel Ignatiev is a good place to start with respect to engaging on this topic.
- jacobolus 11y agoI promise you that even in the frugalest least flashy place you can find in New England, a black woman who grew up poor in the South will get more respect from just about everyone by dressing in tasteful expensive clothes and speaking with a college-educated vocabulary and “white” dialect/accent.
- zo1 11y agoMaybe it's not the presence of certain features, but rather the lack of others. I.e. the gatekeeping is not by virtue of having certain features, but of not having some "negative" ones?
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoMaybe I missed some subtle parts of this, but I'm not from the US and I didn't read the original piece as being specific to the US.