4 ms·
A more interesting thing would be to understand how the mis-attribution occurs in the first place (and who is at the origin of it).
by ekianjo 11y ago
A more interesting thing would be to understand how the mis-attribution occurs in the first place (and who is at the origin of it).
- dang 11y agoWell now I have to tell you my theory, which I happen to have handy. Famous quotes are a winner-take-all market: they all accrue to the most famous person of a given category and period. Thus mid-19th-century American folk wit goes to Abraham Lincoln (who, for example, never actually said the thing about fooling some of the people all of the time), mid-20th-century artist wisdom goes to Picasso (who never said great artists steal), mid-20th-century scientist wisdom goes to Einstein, and so on. The big names are large planets; their gravity pulls in the small stuff. As past eras recede, more and more figures get forgotten, so the quotes get reassigned to the last ones standing, who come to seem wittier and wittier over time. Occasionally a folk attribution is even correct, but the odds are surprisingly low, and if there's no textual evidence forget it. It used to bug me that quotes always get misattributed, but it's almost a process of nature if you think about it. And there's a related phenomenon: they get optimized as countless people repeat them. Any inelegant bits that are hard to remember or say out loud get dropped. An example is T.S. Eliot's "Immature poets imitate; mature poets steal" turning into "Good artists borrow; great artists steal", which is so much catchier. It's as if detaching from their origin frees them to evolve. Maybe the endgame is that they turn into pure proverbs and enter the language itself. Edit: oh, and the internet has accelerated all this. It's way easier for a misattribution to propagate—Google any famous quote and you'll see page after page of dreck—but it's also way easier to search original sources as well as link to real citations (like Quote Investigator and Wikiquote). So both sides win.
- tjradcliffe 11y agoAnd the even catchier: "Mediocrity borrows, genius steals" which I've never seen attributed to anyone. I think ideas that are really good tend to lose thier attribution entirely because they stand on their own, so the bigger and older the name attributed is, the more critical of the idea we should be.
- loceng 11y ago"The problem with internet quotes is that you can't always depend on their accuracy." - Abraham Lincoln, 1864