6 ms·
What I learned during the Fukushima disaster and ongoing clean up is that the human race literally has no plan or technology to deal with things when nuclear pl
by grecy 11y ago
What I learned during the Fukushima disaster and ongoing clean up is that the human race literally has no plan or technology to deal with things when nuclear plants go bad.
I'm not anti-nuclear by any stretch, but it boggles my mind that we just stood around and said "well, shit. We don't have a backup plan, and we're stuck with this for a very, very long time".
- toomuchtodo 11y agoSame here! I argue constantly for wind and solar instead of nuclear not because nuclear is a bad technology, but we are bad as a species at managing it. EDIT: It takes 10-20 years to get a nuclear generation plant built, starting at $1 billion USD, and I've never seen a wind turbine or solar panel need to be kept cool for days after having moderator rods dropped to prevent fuel rods from melting down and hydrogen gas destroying a pressured containment vessel. Don't talk to me about thorium, MSRs, breeders, or whatever new fangled reactor is being pushed this year unless you're willing to guarantee with incredibly steep financial penalties that if you start building a reactor today, you will be done on time, and within your budget. Otherwise, move out of the way while we build out solar, wind, and utility-scale battery storage, all proven to work with existing tech, needing no liability waivers from the government nor permanent spent fuel storage that doesn't (and won't ever) exist.
- tdy721 11y agoManage it, we barely understand it! The Strong and Weak fields are Klingon Poetry next to the scripture that describes Gravity and Electromagnetism.
- gregor7777 11y agoBig fan of this post
- jebblue 11y agoAgreed, the Sun is a massive power we also still don't fully understand, is mostly safe and has all the energy humans will ever need (IMO); we just need to strive at understanding it and how to harness it better.
- saalweachter 11y agoThe Sun, safe? 3000 people die each year from non-melanoma skin cancers. That is way more people than nuclear kills. It's damn near competitive with coal.
- serf 11y agothat's true, but we can't choose to turn the sun off.
- pvaldes 11y agoYou are doing the wrong maths here. The real sum is: About seven billion of people living because there is a sun, minus those 3000 that died because sun related problems. The sun is pretty safe to us, yes. No comparison possible.
- vidarh 11y ago> is mostly safe It isn't. Any power generation method that requires human staff will have deaths due to installation and operations accidents. Solar is right up there in terms of number of deaths because installation is labour intensive compared to the energy output vs. nuclear. Maybe that would change if we favoured larger plants over rooftop installations, but at the moment if we replaced all nuclear with solar, the number of deaths would increase significantly.
- tptacek 11y agoAs far as I know, nobody reasonable prefers a nuclear kwh to a solar kwh. The important question is: should we prefer nuclear kwhs to coal or oil kwhs? The answer to that question is less clear. Coal, in particular, kills thousands of people every year. People aren't just going to turn the lights and air conditioners off.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> The important question is: should we prefer nuclear kwhs to coal or oil kwhs? The answer to that question is less clear. Coal, in particular, kills thousands of people every year. I find that answer to be simple. Of course we prefer nuclear over coal, with the caveat that its existing nuclear capacity that will be attritioned out as more renewables come online. > People aren't just going to turn the lights and air conditioners off. Agree. Use pricing to incentivize the expedited reduction in fossil fuel generation. Don't allow new coal fired plants to be brought online. Allow natural gas plants, but only for peaking and with strict emissions controls until utility scale battery installations are provisioned.
- hueving 11y ago>Agree. Use pricing to incentivize the expedited reduction in fossil fuel generation. a.k.a give everyone in the lower middle-class and below a big middle-finger
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> a.k.a give everyone in the lower middle-class and below a big middle-finger Having come from a family of modest means, I can appreciate the cost of power when budgeting on a limited income. On the other hand, we don't allow "the poor" to drive without emissions controls on their cars because its cheaper and they're poor. Raising the price of fossil fuel electrical generation and using that to directly subsidize renewable generation gets very close to a net zero increase in power costs, considering that wind and solar are already at grid parity in most states (and those costs will continue to decline). If you want to be specific, we can significantly curb our fossil fuel subsidies at the federal level, and use those to directly subsidize renewables production (with any deficit made up by the general fund).
- vidarh 11y agoDespite how bad we are at dealing with it, more people die from solar (or pretty much any other alternative form of power generation) per unit of energy generated through e.g. installation and maintenance accidents. You could grind up all the current radioactive waste into particles and pump it into the atmosphere on purpose, and nuclear would still likely cause less harm than most of the alternatives. The problem with nuclear is fear and politics. And most of the management "problems" with nuclear is down to exactly that too. We have plants that generate more waste than necessary because of cold war politics. We have storage "problems" because of irrational levels of fear of the risks. Meanwhile we keep burning coal that continues to shower us in radioactivity and other nastiness sufficient to do as much damage (including deaths) as a Chernobyl sized incident every couple of year or more.
- antocv 11y agoHe didnt say he wants coal instead of nucler, he said he wants solar and wind. How difficult is it for pro-nuclear people to read? Can you also explain how people die from solar energy?
- lcswi 11y ago>Despite how bad we are at dealing with it, more people die from solar (or pretty much any other alternative form of power generation) per unit of energy generated through e.g. installation and maintenance accidents. Citation please. Also I'd like to know if the numbers are in any way significant compared to overall construction work accidents.
- jhartmann 11y agoHere is a good summary of the stats from various sources. Death rate per terawatt/hr is 0.04 for Nuclear and 0.44 for Rooftop Solar. Basically Rooftop solar is a full order of magnitude more dangerous. Coal is WAY more nasty at a world average of around 100 deaths per terawatt/hr if you consider heating/cooking/electricity or 60 for just electricity. Those numbers for China are 170 & 90 respectively. If you include the worst hydro accident, Hydro is 1.4 deaths per terawatt/hr, or 0.10 if that is excluded. Nuclear is the best game in town, even though the accidents are well publicized and the marketing for alternatives have done a really good job of making us scared of the nasty radioactivity, nuclear has the best safety culture and safety record. http://nextbigfuture.com/2011/03/deaths-per-twh-by-energy-source.html http://nextbigfuture.com/2011/03/deaths-per-twh-by-energy-so...
- onewaystreet 11y ago>It takes 10-20 years to get a nuclear generation plant built, starting at $1 billion USD This is because of draconian regulations.
- TorKlingberg 11y agoAren't those regulations what makes nuclear power safe?
- mirimir 11y agoHyman Rickover designed a very clever reactor for nuclear subs. But scaling it up 100x was naive at best. So was doing that with the graphite core design. Maybe there are inherently safe designs.
- Zigurd 11y agoWhile even some designs that were thought to be inherently safe turned out to have engineering problems when put into practice, it is probably imperative that we learn how to use new-generation reactors, and build new, safer reactors and new reactor technologies that could solve our current nuclear waste problem. Nuclear needs to be an available tool for bridging humanity out of the oil age.
- selimthegrim 11y agoHyman Rickover was a power-grabbing, egocentric fool who stymied miniaturization and development of alternatives that didn't enhance his influence. http://www.airpower.maxwell.af.mil/airchronicles/aureview/1983/jul-aug/schratz.html http://www.airpower.maxwell.af.mil/airchronicles/aureview/19...
- mcv 11y agoThe main thing I learned from it is that even in modern, high tech countries withe tech to handle it safely, corporations will always cut corners. It's not just the technology itself that's unsafe, it's the fact that it's handled by profit-driven corporations. I think nuclear energy may be unavoidable as transitional tech until we can move entirely to cleaner technology, but it very clearly needs very tight regulation, and it's not the end goal. (At least uranium fission isn't; I keep hearing positive stuff about thorium. But even then, wind and solar already works; we need a lot more of that.)
- lmm 11y agoIt's really not very dangerous, even in the worst case, compared to the alternatives for baseline power. Supposing we just ignored the radioactivity and did nothing, compare the number of deaths and environmental damage per kwh to what business as usual for any alternative would cause (coal mining? Oil drilling? Flooding land for hydro-electric? Mining the stuff that solar panels are made of?).
- j-pb 11y ago>mining the stuff that solar panels are made of You mean silicon-oxide a.k.a. sand?
- vidarh 11y agoYou think nobody dies mining sand?
- astrodust 11y agoOf all the things to mine, sand is probably the least dangerous. A gravel quarry has more hazards.
- vidarh 11y agoIt very well might be one of the least dangerous things to mine, but that doesn't mean people aren't dying while mining sand. Sand and gravel is often extracted at the same quarries, and it appears they're generally treated as one category with respect to accident stats, so breaking that apart is tricky unfortunately. Actually I was being a bit facetious as well, given that sand is one of the forms of mining where there are quite a few deaths due to organized crime involvement in illegal sand mines [1] [2] [3]. Exactly because it's easy to set up and not much capital lost if you get shut down. [1] https://www.toovia.com/posts/2015/apr/05/0.13503.611792578420998154 https://www.toovia.com/posts/2015/apr/05/0.13503.61179257842... [2] http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/woman-hacked-to-death-for-opposing-illicit-sand-mining/article7172104.ece http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/woman-hacke... [3] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-12-17/indian-college-kids-a-sand-mafia-path-a-river-of-death.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-12-17/indian-college-kids...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]