5 ms·
50 hospitals charge uninsured more than 10 times cost of care
- HongQiGong 11y agoThis is outrageous. Does Obamacare address this?
- Gustomaximus 11y agoIt seems to me a reasonable fix would be to legislate hospitals have to set open and fixed pricing for procedures/services for all. So no group/insurance company discounts. Make them compete openly and without discrimination. Then people/business can select fairly for non-emergency type treatments their hospital on a level playing field. That said, I'm fortunate to have lived in several countries that have great universal healthcare. I thoroughly believe achieving this should be one of 3 key goals for any country.
- grecy 11y ago> have to set open and fixed pricing for procedures/services for all You mean guaranteed (set) profits. The telco I work for operates under exactly that model, and it sucks. For everyone.
- Gustomaximus 11y agoThis would have nothing to do with guaranteed profits. If people don't like the prices no-one will go to the hospital and profits wont exist. They simply have to price transparently at amounts that are available for all people without discrimination to someones healthcare company or lack of.
- jbi 11y agoUhm.. Sometimes there is a need to go to a hospital ;)
- Gustomaximus 11y agoIf you refer to the original comment you will see this refers to non-emergency treatments. In this people have choice and can largely travel to an alternate locations making this solution feasible for the majority. For emergency treatment, a different model would be needed to reduce gouging issues, likely more direct market intervention for areas the discussed wouldn't benefit. I'll leave that for another day.
- grecy 11y ago> legislate hospitals have to set open and fixed pricing for procedures/services for all. Fixed pricing = fixed profits.
- jbi 11y agoThere is a regulation like this in Germany. It leads to a behaviour where hospitals try to have as many well-paid treatments as possible. 'Surgery 1' does not pay well by list so they add 'Unnecessary Treatment 2'. My point: such a list would have failures and they would be exploited.
- dylanjermiah 11y ago>It seems to me a reasonable fix would be to legislate hospitals have to set open and fixed pricing for procedures/services for all. So no group/insurance company discounts. Make them compete openly and without discrimination. Legislation created the current environment, I do not believe more legislation will fix it.
- ars 11y agoThe thing that is driving this problem is that medicare pays less than it costs for the service. Hospitals have to make the money up somehow, so they bill everyone else inflated prices. The insurance companies know the prices are inflated, so try to negotiate them down. Hospitals agree to be negotiated down since at least they make something. And of course some insurance companies get a better deal (for various reasons) than others. What ends up happening is that everyone pays a different price, and standardizing the price would only hurt the hospital. This is completely unfixable so long as medicare pays so little. Some people want to fix this with a single payer system, not realizing that doing so would only make things worse. Either medical costs will go up for the government, or hospitals will go broke. Neither outcome is acceptable to people. And that is how we ended up in the pathetic state we are in today.
- guelo 11y agoThat argumet doesnt make sense because hospitals are not forced to take Medicare. It is a profitable business decision to take Medicare otherwise they wouldn't do it.
- ars 11y agoThey sort of are forced to by community pressure. If they don't they lose status, and are sent fewer patients, politicians criticize them, etc, etc. They lose money on the actual procedures, but make it up in other ways, so it's worth it for them in total.
- Gustomaximus 11y ago> Some people want to fix this with a single payer system, not realizing that doing so would only make things worse. Either medical costs will go up for the government, or hospitals will go broke. I don't buy this. USA has huge per-person medical costs beyond any other country. There is absolutely room for efficiency by society/government that private enterprise isn't delivering. Look at some of these comparisons: http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/health-costs-how-the-us-compares-with-other-countries/ http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/health-costs-how-the-us-...
- rgbrenner 11y agoWhat makes this so much worse is that no doctor or hospital will tell you upfront what something will cost. So the uninsured go into one of these hospitals... can't compare prices, or even find out what something will cost before they agree to it... and later get hit with a ridiculously marked up bill.
- nrao123 11y agoWhenever I see examples of reported price gouging in sensitive industries like Healthcare, I try & pull up the financials of the companies. Two of the biggest owners of these hospitals are Hospital Corp. of America (Ticker= HCA) & Community Health Systems (Ticker=CHY) (1) The return on assets (ROA) for HCA is 6.9%: https://ycharts.com/companies/HCA/return_on_assets https://ycharts.com/companies/HCA/return_on_assets The Return on Assets for CYH is ~1.9%: https://ycharts.com/companies/CYH/return_on_assets https://ycharts.com/companies/CYH/return_on_assets This is compared to Google (11.9%), P&G (6.5%) & Walmart (7.9%) For those not familiar with ROA, it is taken as Net Income/ Total Assets. This should give you a rough idea on the return one gets on the assets / capital deployed. The higher the ROA, the better the earning power. So, in the case of HCA/CYH, if they are price gouging so much, why aren't they generating far superior returns? ---- Updated: Some people in the comments are suggesting that they are only price gouging the un-insured population. But Return on Assets (ROA) metrics are across the population base. So: if we reduce the price gouging for the un-insured through regulation, then one of two things a) the return on assets (ROA) go down to uneconomical levels & hospitals go bankrupt (2) - See examples b) Costs for insured population (e.g. Medicare etc...) goes up to meet return on capital requirements. What is the tradeoff one needs to make? --- (1)Officials at Community Health Systems of Franklin, Tenn., which operates 25 of the hospitals, and Hospital Corp. of America, based in Nashville, which operates 14, said hospital charges rarely reflect what consumers actually pay. http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/why-some-hospitals-can-get-away-with-price-gouging-patients-study-finds/2015/06/08/b7f5118c-0aeb-11e5-9e39-0db921c47b93_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/why-so... (2) http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/hospital-management-administration/20-hospital-closures-bankruptcies-so-far-in-2014.html http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/hospital-management-adm...
- tsotha 11y agoI don't know why this is surprising, since it's purely an outgrowth government policies. The state mandates hospitals provide certain kinds of care without providing funds under EMTALA. That money has to come from somewhere, so it comes from the patients who can pay. Since insurance companies and the government can get negotiated rates (or just dictate rates, in the case of the government) the only people left to squeeze are people without insurance but with enough money to pay. What this map is really telling you is which hospitals have large concentrations of patients who can't pay for care. Before they shut down King-Drew Medical Center in LA six out of seven patients couldn't pay their bill, so if you showed up at the ER without insurance they were going to try to charge you enough to cover the six people in front of you.
- vparikh 11y agoBiggest problem is that in the US we keep trying to apply capitalism to something that does not really fit the supply/demand model. EVERYONE will get sick or injured, and at that point it is not a a luxury. When you get a heart attack, it is not a choice weather you go to get medical attention. Therefore you cannot run it as a free and open capital market. Besides how is it that we are the wealthiest country the world has ever known and yet we fail to provide the basics (health, education, and care for the elderly) to our citizenry? The root issue is the US will be forced to re-evaluate its blind allegiance to capitalism as the end all be all system to regulate costs and provide services. We need a more balanced approach.