3 ms·
Trying to calculate expected value is a reasonable approach. (I understand expected value, just hadn't seen the $100K estimate.) This appears to be the full so
by gojomo 17y ago
Trying to calculate expected value is a reasonable approach. (I understand expected value, just hadn't seen the $100K estimate.)
This appears to be the full solicitation of which the "(IC)" area is part:
http://www.nsf.gov/pubs/2009/nsf09609/nsf09609.htm http://www.nsf.gov/pubs/2009/nsf09609/nsf09609.htm
Looks to be 200-300 awards of up to $150K each
It might be reasonable to assign a much higher expected value, if the applicant knows (via communication with the program officer) that their team and area are in a favored area, or if they expect to also seek government funding past the first stage, or if they get some value (experience/feedback) even from a 'loss'.
Also, the costs of applying could be far less than 2 weeks if (for whatever reason) an applicant is good at the process or can repurpose other presentation materials.
So perhaps the expected value is some multiple of $10K, for just a day or two's effort,
- DenisM 17y agoI expect most other applicants to do the due diligence and communicate with program officers as well, it's even suggested on the application paperwork. In general I expect similar situations to attract similar caliber of people, the only exceptionality I expect is in their core competency not in other things such as process, paperwork etc. I agree on non-monetary rewards, those can be useful for some people depending on their future plan. I see myself in consumer market, so it's not clear how much benefit will I get from it. Would be nice to know more about that. I need to look closer into the two-week thing. You might be right, and if it's less than a week I might as well just do it. Speaking of probabilities, they have funded 395 out of 2067 submissions in 2007, so the estimates are going up slightly: http://www.nsf.gov/eng/iip/sbir/phaseI_map.ppt http://www.nsf.gov/eng/iip/sbir/phaseI_map.ppt
- rfreytag 17y agoDefinitely try to speak to the PM.
- rfreytag 17y agoIf you don't know the existence let alone the order of magnitude on some of the cost terms then expected value will mislead you. The SBIR/STTR program does what it is intended to do but do study it carefully first.