4 ms·
It has struck me repeatedly over the past couple of years that there's a lot of places in our society where we have 1. Flushed all our old social ideas dow
by jerf 11y ago
It has struck me repeatedly over the past couple of years that there's a lot of places in our society where we have
1. Flushed all our old social ideas down the toilet
2. Had raucous, loud celebrations of our new freedoms
3. Discovered the problems that prompted the old social ideas
4. Started the long, slow process of groping for new social
ideals
and in many cases, it seems to me that we're headed for
5. Re-discovering the old social ideals actually had reasons
and that rather than discarding them and replacing
them wholesale we'd have been a lot better off
tweaking them.
There's a lot of places where we're doing this. Some of them still have too many people in #2 to make it politic to name all of them, but when you look at our society through this lens a lot of stuff suddenly makes more sense. We'll see how this theory's predictive power pans out.
(And to be clear, in step 5, a lot of our ideals do need tweaking; that's not a rhetorical concession, but a core part of the process. But I'd submit we've thrown out far more baby with the bathwater than almost anybody in modern times is any longer equipped to understand.)
- walterbell 11y agoGood algo draft. Any semi-capable provacateur will propose forks of culture/language/code/regulation with putative popular benefits but silent advantages to some groups. This especially applies to the retention of previous silent advantages. With slow forks and manipulation of "corrective" pendulum swings, each swing of the scythe can redistrict the landscape in non-obvious ways. The short stories of R.A. Lafferty contain many instances of such patterns, often as historical or science fiction.
- brg 11y agoThis is the second time R.A. Lafferty has come up in comments today. Amazon.com shows 69 different texts, do you have any recommendation on where to begin? http://www.amazon.com/R.-A.-Lafferty/e/B001HCU6PE http://www.amazon.com/R.-A.-Lafferty/e/B001HCU6PE
- walterbell 11y agoSome of his stories are on the web, http://www.ralafferty.org/works/collections/online-stories/ http://www.ralafferty.org/works/collections/online-stories/ An overview of his style, http://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2014/aug/13/ra-lafferty-secret-sci-fi-genius-poised-for-comeback http://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2014/aug/13/ra-la... His most popular collection was Nine Hundred Grandmothers, http://www.ralafferty.org/works/collections/nine-hundred-grandmothers/ http://www.ralafferty.org/works/collections/nine-hundred-gra... Most of his work is out of print or rare, but a search for "Man Who Talled Tales" may help.
- cactusface 11y ago> But I'd submit we've thrown out far more baby with the bathwater than almost anybody in modern times is any longer equipped to understand. Then again, the world has been through a lot in the last couple of centuries.
- jerf 11y agoI said what I said in full and abundant awareness of that fact. And I'm making this reply because that's worth making the point explicitly. I view it as similarly to how it seems like the programming world is in such fast flux. On the one hand, a Javascript framework comes out every week and you MUST MUST MUST change everything to using it or you're falling behind! On the other hand, I can't help but notice the computer science undergrad curriculum hasn't hardly budged an inch since I took it 1996-2000, nor can I help but notice that for all the sound & fury of web development, 2015-me could pretty much bring 2005-me up to speed in a couple of days. (A smidge of cheat there... 2005-me had actually written a pure-JS widget system that I can't necessarily call "modern", but let's just say that "shadow DOMs" wouldn't exactly blow 2005-me's mind either.) There's a lot of high-frequency churn... there's a lot less fundamental change. Again, not zero. But a lot less. A study of history will even show a lot of modern trends you think are unique in history may not be.
- cactusface 11y agoOh I might not get what you're saying at all. I just meant like, for example, the wholesale throwing away of religion (or kinds of government, whatever) seems more bathtub emptying than throwing away something to do with some communication method.
- jerf 11y agoIn this particular case I'm thinking more culture-level, or the operating system of a civilization. Which, as I'm being a bit deliberately elliptical, is not necessarily something you'd be able to easily extract from that message. Religions are carriers of these things, but in this case I am thinking more of what they are carrying rather than the religions themselves. As with many human things, it's all a big mess that can't be cleanly segmented out.... On topic, "the need for privacy" is one of these things. Many have heralded a generation who has no need of privacy, but then, as we all live in the "global village", we are slowly groping back towards some of the very same ideals of privacy that villages used to have, for instance, or at least I'd contend that over time in lots of little ways people tend to rediscover that just chucking the entire idea overboard wasn't smart. That's not a religion, nor directly a hot-button issue. And should we ever decide that totalitarianism sounds totally awesome and we should totally do it, a whole bunch of people will have the opportunity to rediscover the virtues of privacy. "Yay."