4 ms·
"there are a lot of AIs and some of them are writing code already?" That's post-Singularity, and can't be meaningfully discussed. Since the idea of the singul
by jerf 11y ago
"there are a lot of AIs and some of them are writing code already?"
That's post-Singularity, and can't be meaningfully discussed.
Since the idea of the singularity has gotten conflated with one particular possible outcome ("rapture of the nerds" is merely one of the better possibilities, not the totality of the idea), let me remind you that the core idea of the singularity is that it is when the future is so different than it is now that our ability to predict it has dropped to zero. There's a certain amount of relativity to it... we're post-singularity for a cave man, for instance. AIs that are smart enough to program themselves will result in a world so radically different that there is no meaningful way to plan for what to do from here in 2015.
In the future before then, which for all we know may well encompass the entire lives of everybody here, and assuming no major civilizational hiccups (which may not be "singularities" but are also fairly difficult to predict around), programming will be one of the few fields that probably will continue to grow more or less indefinitely for the forseeable future. More stuff is going to be programmable, and the advantage for a company to have better programmer better than its competitor will likely also grow.
In fact I think there's a decent chance that demand for programmers, and especially good programmers, is likely to rise beyond the base level of people who are even theoretically capable of becoming that level of programmer. I suspect we have not actually seen peak salary in this field for good programmers.
(Interesting tidbit... programming has the tendency to "eat" other fields, as others have noticed. Even if genetics and biology manage to do everything that they've ever promised... the top level of biological designers are going to look an awful lot like programmers, moreso than biologists, precisely because the only way we'll ever have that level of control over biology is to abstract the issues away until we have a programming language on top. Nobody can work at the raw gene level, at scale. Oh, it won't be C or Haskell or Python, but it'll still be a programming language. Probably declarative.)
I'm not just trying to say good things to make us happy; this has been my assessment of the field's prognosis for a while, even since before the bubble pop, and I've seen nothing to make me change it, even the bubble pop and the 2008 crisis. Even if we are in another bubble now and it pops, it would have to epically pop, like, the entire country, person by person, decides this whole "Internet" thing is a total waste of time forever for all things, for me to change my mind.
The fact that I feel this way about this field and that I work in this field is not a coincidence. Per my comment [1], when in 1996 I mentally did what I suggested in that post and "computer programmer" popped out in my second slot for Jobs I'd Like To Do, I was pretty grateful, and, again, have seen nothing to make me change my mind since.
[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9667145 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9667145
- z92 11y ago"some of them are writing code already?" I read it as, some AI are already writing code. In the present day.
- jerf 11y agoWriting a bit of code is nothing interesting. I haven't seen anything that convinces me that any AIs have taken any interesting steps in the direction of replacing programmers. In a way, writing code is literally the maximally pessimal case for an AI, exposure to the full power of Turing Chaos [1], the worst possible space of possibilities for an AI to consider. Frankly, even after decades of training and practice, the smartest humans are not even all that great at it. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7111308 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7111308