3 ms·
Did you read my last paragraph? But all the talk of not releasing data and hiding from FOIA requests does make me uneasy. Science is better when other scientis
by jgrahamc 17y ago
Did you read my last paragraph?
But all the talk of not releasing data and hiding from FOIA requests does make me uneasy. Science is better when other scientists can reproduce what you are doing,
I'm not happy about that either.
- gaius 17y agoIf a bank repeatedly refused to hand over its data to the regulator after some fraud occurred, then suddenly changed their tune and said the data was lost, someone's going to jail. If a drug company does the same after some side-effects are discovered, ditto. If an engineering firm after an airliner goes down, or a bridge collapses, ditto. Now we are being asked to redirect resources in the entire global economy based on... What, exactly? The word of people who have been caught with a smoking gun of disregarding the scientific process to silence their critics by any means necessary? Everyone, the greens especially, ought to be furious.
- jgrahamc 17y agoActually, I am very upset about the fact that all the data was not being routinely released so that others could follow along or falsify. But I'm not letting that cloud my own analysis of the source code that has been released.
- sethg 17y agoIf this one study were the only evidence of global warming, it wouldn't justify redirecting the global economy's resources, even if we had all the raw data.
- flipbrad 17y agofine, but losing it undermines the overall case and any present justification there is. how much is a matter of opinion, but it's bound to be non-negligible given the continuous obstructionism to releasing it in the first place.
- Nwallins 17y ago> Science is better when other scientists can reproduce what you are doing s/is better when/requires that/ Right?
- KirinDave 17y agoYes, but you're implying that direct reproduction of the work with the original subject is necessary. Obviously, it is not required in a variety of scientific fields. For example, research into medicine cannot re-infect a patient with a disease to re-test a vaccine to "reproduce" the experiment, that would be unethical. If multiple lines of evidence all indicate the same thing, that is considered reproducible enough.