3 ms·
So what about it, then? Is cultural fit supposed to be completely ignored? It's important, and assuming that it means illegal discrimination is totally false.
by pc86 11y ago
So what about it, then? Is cultural fit supposed to be completely ignored? It's important, and assuming that it means illegal discrimination is totally false.
- davidgerard 11y agoTotally false? So what are the typical demographics of the tech industry? How homogeneous is the age range, the racial percentages, the gender makeup? Seriously, look at the report from Google just for a much-discussed recent example. It's not like this hasn't been discussed at length on HN.
- fecak 11y agoCultural fit can be a legitimate concern. However, companies that discriminate will often choose to use "cultural fit" (or simply "not a fit") as the reason for rejection, which complicates things.
- SilasX 11y agoI don't think the problem is filtering by cultural fit itself, but rather, the overbroad use of the term for widely different scenarios to the point where it conveys no information at best, or hides bad reasons at worst. The term can mean a legitimate work compatibility issue like "people feel awkward around him when they try to crack innocent jokes to ease the stress", but can also mean "he insists on picking up his kid every day rather than going out drinking".
- mcv 11y ago"Cultural fit" is just a phrase. You need to articulate what exactly you're looking for. I once worked in a Scrum team with a tester who really needed to be in a Waterfall environment. She was an excellent tester, but just didn't have the right mindset for Scrum. But how do you filter that out? You need to know exactly what you're looking for. But as soon as your "cultural fit" becomes about hiring young, hip dudes who like unusual food and kite surfing, it becomes a harmful aspect of your hiring process. You'll end up with less diversity, and therefore less represented view points in your company, and therefore less customers that you will understand. Diversity is important.