6 ms·
So sorry to hear this; Evince rocks! On a side note, as someone with cancer i'm getting more and more annoyed with people saying 'lost the fight' 'after a long
by tluyben2 11y ago
So sorry to hear this; Evince rocks!
On a side note, as someone with cancer i'm getting more and more annoyed with people saying 'lost the fight' 'after a long fight' etc. Somehow (and I know more people have this) it makes it feel like you didn't try hard enough. Stop saying that please.
- bodhi 11y ago> Stop saying that please. Might come across as snarky, but really meaning not to: What's an expression that would be more acceptable?
- tluyben2 11y agoWell, if you die of something else, these terms are not used. Or maybe I didn't see, but you don't say 'after fighting alzheimers' 'after fighting ALS' etc, they just say; he/she died of X. That feels more fair than taking some kind of process into account whereby one gets the feeling that if you had battled harder you would've come out on top. For many cancers this is simply not the case yet; I was 'lucky', he was not, but that's all it is. It has not much to do with fighting IMHO.
- bodhi 11y ago> they just say; he/she died of X That's what my sneaking suspicion was. I recall having heard expressions like "after a long battle with illness", but your point makes a lot of sense. Actually, I realise there's no mention of losing in that expression, which was made clear to me after finding this article http://www.huffingtonpost.com/carole-brody-fleet/long-term-illness_b_2051071.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/carole-brody-fleet/long-term-i... after searching Google for the above phrase.
- csbrooks 11y agoInteresting point. I wonder if one reason for the difference in language is that chemotherapy is so brutal that it ends up feeling like a "battle". Plus maybe that there's a chance of "winning", which isn't there with Alzheimer's or with ALS. (I'm not justifying the correctness of the word, just speculating on the cause.)
- hsitz 11y agoIt's that "chance of winning" thing when "battling" that's part of the reason it shouldn't be used. Too easy to imply (or for others to infer) that if they don't win it's because they didn't fight hard enough. Better to just get rid of the battle analogy altogether, IMO.
- crazypyro 11y agoI've read phrases like "battling", "fighting", etc. used in a variety of illnesses. Its never been apparent to me that it is specifically relating to cancer.
- dagurp 11y agoLosing doesn't mean you didn't try your best though.
- tluyben2 11y agoI know, it just doesn't feel right. And like said before; I'm not the only one who thinks that. I hear it quite a lot.
- oso96_2000 11y agoI lost my mom to cancer almost two years ago. I read this in reddit [1] and I liked it: "She didn't lose the battle - the cancer didn't live on either. At worst it was a draw, at best she took that fucker down with her." Take care, buddy. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/talesfromtechsupport/comments/2pjmux/sometimes_its_the_simple_tickets_that_humble_you/cmxh0ri https://www.reddit.com/r/talesfromtechsupport/comments/2pjmu...
- mahouse 11y agoIt's metaphorical... PS, get well
- thirsteh 11y agoIt's not even technically accurate. At the very least it's a draw :)
- brudgers 11y agoAs a long time hospice spouse, I wonder if "Living with cancer" might better capture what matters. The battle metaphor often leads to medical approaches that reduce quality of life and induce pointless suffering. Accepting the inevitable fact of mortality isn't necessarily surrender, sometimes it is innate wisdom.
- icebraining 11y agoOn that note, I really liked this conversation of D. G. Mayers (who died of cancer in September) regarding this topic. A small excerpt: "Tony Gwynn died recently, just last month, of salivary gland cancer. (…) He was a great ball player, and a great man. He had salivary gland cancer for 8 years. (…) Every article about Gwynn's death quite rightly celebrated his prowess on the ball field and what a wonderful man he was. The last 4 and a half years of his life disappeared from all of the accounts. The only thing they ever said was that he had a 4-and-a-half year "battle" with cancer. And you know how much I hate that word, "battle." (…) You know, his experience of it--he continued to coach baseball at San Diego State. How did it affect his coaching? What did it do to his religious faith? How did it alter his relationship with his wife? All of this went unsaid, and it just disappeared into one word--battle." http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/07/dg_myers_on_can.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/07/dg_myers_on_can.htm...
- Avitas 11y agoThis seems like very good idea to me. It is good enough that I will try to remind people in-person and online about it. I have given eulogies before. I have focused on only things I wanted to remember and perhaps things I thought others would want to remember--not that there's anything majorly wrong with that. It is not easy to devise guidelines about what should and should not be communicated. But, I do think it is a disservice to someone's life with a disease to be summarized with a single word or short phrase--ESPECIALLY if that time frame is many years. In summary, I see the issues as: - Individuals summarizing another person's experience with a disease or condition using single words or short phrases such as "battle" or "long fight" - Focusing only on periods of their life prior to to their diagnosis - The ignoring of accomplishments, day-to-day realities of life, significant persons, significant places, etc. after their diagnosis
- srean 11y agoI am glad that you brought this up. It annoys and saddens me when people associate will, strength of character and general moral rectitude with surviving cancer. As if those who passed away were lacking in those qualities. Oh your dad died of cancer, so sorry, he must have been a wimp that's why he died. Please dont do this and no my dad doesnt have cancer.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gknoy 11y agoI expect you're being downvoted for appearing insensitive to a person with cancer. The person you replied to has cancer. It's likely difficult, and it's easy to think of it as a battle -- but the person you replied to is allowed to complain about what we call it, whereas we and the familes of people facing cancer are not allowed to complain about it __to them__. (I also realize that many people with cancer might _prefer_ the "battle" term, as well.) This is based on something I've read that was very formative [0]. The main idea is that the central person is allowed to complain to anyone, but anyone not at the center of a tragedy is only allowed to complain to people farther from the tragedy. A short version of this is, "comfort goes in, complaints go out", if you think of these layers as rings. Cancer patient: Can complain to anyone about anything Cancer patient's family: Can complain to anyone __except__ cancer patients about anything. Bystanders (me): basically has no standing to complain about things ("this is so hard for me to deal with!"). ;) Sorry if this seems a little preachy, because your feelings are valid. I think that the downvotes are mainly because of the way you said them, and on who you replied to. I found this article really helpful in framing my own thoughts and words about tragedies, because I've been inadvertently insensitive in the past about things like this. I hope you enjoy it too. 0: http://articles.latimes.com/2013/apr/07/opinion/la-oe-0407-silk-ring-theory-20130407 http://articles.latimes.com/2013/apr/07/opinion/la-oe-0407-s...
- lisper 11y ago> Stop saying that please. What should we say instead?
- DINKDINK 11y agoPossibly 'succumbed'
- Fordrus 11y agoI agree that it certainly isn't accurate to assert that they (or you) could've done more, but I hesitate to tell people to stop using that terminology. Because it IS a fight, and it's one that each day brings us closer to collectively winning properly. I'm a bioinformatician working in genetics- I'm moving away a little from cancer genetics right now, but I've been involved some in the past. I think it'd be a little more accurate to assert that people like ME lost the battle against cancer- because we're the ones trying to understand cancer behavior and develop effective treatments. I celebrate that people see cancer as something to be 'fought', though, and hope that even more talented programmers will enter the fray. Here's hoping your fight against cancer goes well, and that you have many happy days ahead, tluyben2! :)
- viewer5 11y ago> and hope that even more talented programmers will enter the fray Where'd be a good place to start? And is it all statistical modelling and stuff, or what's involved in programming in the fight with cancer?
- Fordrus 11y agohttp://rosalind.info/problems/list-view/ http://rosalind.info/problems/list-view/ It's the 'bioinformatics stronghold' at Rosalind- I feel like explanations I might give would be lacking, but these being practice problems in genomics, they might explain it better! :) Certainly there's a lot of statistical modeling involved, but just as much, it's a matter of getting a large number of command line programs to work together and yield a usable result! Many tools that do not all play nicely together. XD https://tutegenomics.com/ https://tutegenomics.com/ is the place I'm interning at right now, part time, while I also help at a lab at university. That website is pretty interesting, as well, you might find- and I'd best get back to work for now. Ask me any other questions you have, though, I'd be happy to help, just a little short on time at the moment. :)
- Fordrus 11y agoAh! I think Biostars might also be a good resource to get an idea for the programming, statistical, and biological techniques required- this link may help! https://www.biostars.org/t/Tutorials/?sort=followers&limit=all%20time&q= https://www.biostars.org/t/Tutorials/?sort=followers&limit=a... Good luck, viewer5! :)
- classicsnoot 11y agoI just lost my Aunt. Her last years were a battle, but it often felt like a proxy war between Medicine and Mutation using her body as the battleground. First they sent in advisors, then they attempted regime change, then there were truce talks, then the conflict reignited. At the end she told the doctors to fuck off with their knives and needles so she could melt slowly into a hospice bed, robbed of her beauty, dignity, and life. fuck cancer. i hear what you are saying, and i will try to phrase it differently, but i do see it as a war. i am a smoker. i often work with carcinogenic chemicals. i see cancer as an inevitability, and when it shows up, i plan to either do nothing therapeutic (chemo, removal) and just go on a no holds barred adventure around the world to look at stuff i've only read about OR donate my body to some team of researchers who need a living model to test their ideas on. this is just my thinking currently; it may change. i have no children, few possessions, and few ties outside of family. So for me, i do see it as a war that i will inevitably become a part of. fuck fucking cancer.
- pascalmemories 11y ago> when it shows up, i plan to either do nothing therapeutic (chemo, removal) > donate my body to some team of researchers who need a living model to test their ideas on. I have a cousin who has been diagnosed with terminal cancer and, like everyone, have lost various other relatives and friends to cancer over the years. One thing which is very clear from their experience is that all cancer treatment is experimentation on living people, with a hope that some combination of treatments will bring a cure. For some people there is a brief success (reduced tumor size, sometimes to undetectable levels) but, outside of some cancers which are very treatable, this is normally a brief pause. Treatments people receive today are because of the experiences of people in the past which showed a good response and this is fed into developing and fine-tuning what is done today. The hope is this experimentation will mean more success in future and longer lives with better quality. There are lots of anger filled comments (understandably so) here. The reality is you are best to receive the experimentation early on when it can bring benefits, but to also recognize it's not always going to benefit you for long and the benefit may go to someone a few years from now who have a better treatment and better results because of your experiences. I think that's really the only positive thing you can take from the experience. If you ever do get diagnosed, the bucket list thing is good. That's what I'm doing with my cousin while she has time. There is only a brief interval to tick that off; take it before it's too late.